| Test | Reject an option that... |
|---|---|
| Evidence | labels the pupil ('weak', 'careless', 'not intelligent') without evidence |
| Meaning | relies on memorising, copying or drilling a rule the pupil does not understand |
| Sequence | skips a stage or level, or teaches above the pupil's present thinking |
| Climate | uses fear, public comparison or punishment |
| Target | answers a different question from the one asked |
Ask: what is asked, what is the evidence, what would I do? Then strike out options that label, rely on rote, skip stages, use fear, or answer a different question.
Classify the question first, decide from evidence, predict before reading options, and eliminate with five tests: evidence, meaning, sequence, climate and target. When two options remain, choose the one in which the pupil does the thinking. The following lessons apply this method to harder error analysis, remedial design, geometry and assessment.