- Foundation
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
From concrete to abstract: manipulatives and the CPA approach
Plan a sequence that moves from concrete objects to pictures to symbols, and choose suitable manipulatives for common topics.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Lesson 1 showed that mathematics is abstract, and that abstraction is hard for children. The concrete-pictorial-abstract (CPA) approach is the most widely used answer to this difficulty. It is linked to Jerome Bruner's idea that learners represent knowledge through action, images and symbols. This lesson explains the three stages and the materials, called manipulatives, that support them.
The three stages
- Concrete: pupils handle real objects, such as counters, sticks, beads, blocks or paper strips, and act out the idea.
- Pictorial: pupils draw or use pictures, diagrams and models that represent the objects, such as dots, tally marks, bar models or number lines.
- Abstract: pupils use numbers and symbols alone, such as 3 + 4 = 7 or 1/2 + 1/4 = 3/4.
The stages are not a rigid one-way ladder. A teacher moves forward when pupils are ready and goes back to objects or pictures when a pupil is confused. The pictorial stage is the bridge: it keeps the meaning of the objects while preparing for symbols. Skipping straight from objects to symbols, or starting with symbols, is a common reason why children learn rules without understanding.
Time spent at each stage varies. A pupil who has handled many bundles of sticks may need only a quick concrete reminder before drawing, while another may need several sessions with objects. The teacher watches for signs of readiness: a pupil who can explain what the drawing stands for, or who can predict the result before counting, is ready to move on. A pupil who counts on fingers to check every symbolic answer may need more pictorial work.
Manipulatives for common topics
| Topic | Concrete material | Pictorial step |
|---|---|---|
| Counting and addition | Counters, beads, sticks | Dots, number line |
| Place value | Bundles of ten sticks; base-ten blocks | Drawings of tens and ones |
| Fractions | Paper folding, fraction strips | Shaded shapes, bar models |
| Geometry | Geoboard, cut-out shapes, tangram | Drawings on dotted paper |
| Measurement | Rulers, string, containers, balance | Diagrams with labels |
A manipulative is useful only if it shows the idea clearly and pupils talk about what they are doing. Handling blocks without discussion can become play with no learning. The teacher asks questions such as 'What happened when you made a bundle of ten?' so that the action is linked to the mathematical idea.
Worked example 1
Task: plan a CPA sequence for 23 + 15 in Class 2. Working: concrete, pupils show 23 as 2 bundles of ten sticks and 3 loose sticks, and 15 as 1 bundle and 5 loose sticks; they put the bundles together (3 tens) and the loose sticks together (8 ones). Pictorial, they draw three long lines for tens and eight dots for ones. Abstract, they write 23 + 15 = 38, seeing that 20 + 10 = 30 and 3 + 5 = 8. The answer, 38, is the same at every stage, which is what makes the link clear.
Worked example 2
Situation: Pupils can write 1/2 > 1/4 but cannot explain why; several think 1/4 is bigger because 4 is bigger than 2. Question: which step should the teacher take? Working: the pupils are at the symbol stage without meaning, so the teacher returns to the concrete stage. Each pupil folds one paper strip into 2 equal parts and an equal strip into 4 equal parts, then compares one part of each. The half is clearly larger. Then they draw both as shaded bars (pictorial) before returning to the symbols.
Concrete, then pictorial, then abstract: handle it, draw it, then write it, and go back a stage whenever meaning is lost.
Key takeaways
The CPA approach moves from objects to pictures to symbols, with the pictorial stage as a bridge. Choose manipulatives that show the idea clearly, such as bundles for place value or strips for fractions, and always link action to talk. When pupils use symbols without understanding, return to an earlier stage.
Check your understanding
-
1. In the CPA approach, drawing tally marks to show 7 belongs to which stage?
- Concrete
- Abstract
- Formal deduction
- Pictorial
Show answer
Answer: D. Drawings that represent objects belong to the pictorial stage.
-
2. Which material best shows place value (tens and ones) concretely?
- Bundles of ten sticks and loose sticks
- A clock face
- A protractor
- A list of number names
Show answer
Answer: A. Bundles make 'ten ones = one ten' visible and handleable.
-
3. A pupil thinks 1/3 is greater than 1/2 because 3 is greater than 2. What should the teacher do first?
- Make the pupil memorise the rule
- Give a test on fractions
- Return to paper strips or folding to compare the parts
- Move on to adding fractions
Show answer
Answer: C. Returning to the concrete stage rebuilds the meaning of the fractions.
-
4. Using 23 sticks bundled as tens and ones, how many bundles and loose sticks represent 23?
- 3 bundles and 2 loose sticks
- 23 bundles
- 2 bundles and 3 loose sticks
- 1 bundle and 13 loose sticks
Show answer
Answer: C. 23 = 2 tens + 3 ones; one bundle and 13 loose is not in standard tens-and-ones form.
-
5. Why should a teacher ask pupils to talk about what they are doing with manipulatives?
- Talk links the action with the mathematical idea
- Talking keeps pupils quiet later
- Manipulatives work only in silence
- Talk replaces the need for symbols
Show answer
Answer: A. Without discussion, handling materials can become play without learning.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.