- Advanced
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Making and changing states: Articles 2, 3 and 4 and the 2014 Act
Use the constitutional rules on new states to judge statements about how Telangana was created, and separate what the law fixed from what must be checked today.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
At the basic level you learnt that Parliament made Telangana. At this level you are asked why that is so, what the Constitution requires, and what the 2014 Act left time-limited. These questions are usually set as statements, so you need the exact limits of each rule.
Articles 2, 3 and 4
Article 2 lets Parliament admit into the Union, or establish, new states that were not part of India. Article 3 deals with states already in the Union: Parliament may by law form a new state by separating territory from a state or by uniting two or more states or parts of them, increase or reduce the area of a state, alter its boundaries and alter its name. A bill under Article 3 can be introduced only on the recommendation of the President, and the President must refer it to the legislature of the affected state for its views within a period fixed by the President. Parliament may accept or reject the views. Article 4 says such laws, which may change the First and Fourth Schedules and make supplementary provisions, are not constitutional amendments under Article 368, so they need only an ordinary majority.
| Article | Subject | Exam point |
|---|---|---|
| 2 | Admission or establishment of new states | Applies to territory outside the Union |
| 3 | Formation and alteration of existing states | President's recommendation; views of the state legislature |
| 4 | Laws under 2 and 3 | Not an amendment under Article 368 |
| 368 | Constitution amendment | Not needed for Telangana's formation |
Telangana in the rule-book
The Andhra Pradesh Reorganisation Act, 2014 is an Article 3 law. It separated the Telangana region from the state of Andhra Pradesh, set up the new state from 2 June 2014, and provided for matters such as a common High Court at first, a common capital for a period not exceeding ten years and the division of assets. Because the capital and High Court arrangements were time-limited or later changed (a separate High Court for Telangana has worked since 1 January 2019), always check the current legal position on any such arrangement.
Steps under Article 3
- Recommendation The President recommends the bill
- Reference The bill goes to the state legislature for its views
- Parliament Passes it by ordinary majority
- Assent The President assents; the date is notified
Why 1956 also matters
The merger of 1956 was also done by Parliament, through the States Reorganisation Act, on the basis of the report of the States Reorganisation Commission headed by Fazal Ali. The Gentlemen's Agreement of 1956 promised safeguards for the Telangana region in jobs, education and development, and Article 371D, added in the 1970s, deals with equal opportunity in public employment and education in Andhra Pradesh; check the current text of the provision as it applies after 2014.
Worked example 1: statement analysis
S1: A bill under Article 3 can be introduced only on the President's recommendation. S2: Parliament must follow the views of the state legislature. S3: A law under Article 3 needs a special majority like a constitutional amendment. Working: S1 is true. S2 is false, because the views only need to be obtained. S3 is false because of Article 4. Only S1 is correct.
Worked example 2: Article 2 or 3?
Question: under which Article could Parliament form a state out of the territory of an existing state? Working: Article 3. Article 2 deals with admission of new states from outside the existing Union.
Worked example 3: assertion and reason
A: Telangana's formation did not need the Article 368 procedure. R: Article 4 says laws under Article 3 are not constitutional amendments. Working: both are true and R explains A.
Article 2: new states from outside. Article 3: reshaping existing states, President's recommendation, views of the state legislature, ordinary majority. Article 4: not an Article 368 amendment.
Key takeaways: the formation of Telangana is an Article 3 law; the state's views are heard but not binding; the 2014 Act contained time-limited arrangements, so check the current legal position.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which statement about Article 3 is correct?
- The state legislature's views are binding
- The bill can be introduced only on the President's recommendation
- It needs a two-thirds majority and half the states
- The Supreme Court must approve the bill
Show answer
Answer: B. The President's recommendation is needed; the views of the state are heard but not binding; the ordinary majority suffices.
-
2. A: The formation of Telangana did not require a constitutional amendment under Article 368. R: Article 4 says laws under Article 3 are not constitutional amendments.
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- A is true but R is false
- A is false but R is true
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
Show answer
Answer: D. Both are true; Article 4 is the reason.
-
3. Which Article deals with the admission of states that are not yet in the Union?
- Article 2
- Article 3
- Article 4
- Article 356
Show answer
Answer: A. Article 2 is about new states from outside; Article 3 reshapes existing ones.
-
4. The 2014 Act's common-capital provision was for:
- all time
- one year
- a period not exceeding ten years
- fifty years
Show answer
Answer: C. It was time-limited, so the present position must be checked.
-
5. The States Reorganisation Commission of the 1950s was headed by:
- B. R. Ambedkar
- Sardar Patel
- Balwant Rai Mehta
- Fazal Ali
Show answer
Answer: D. The commission is called the Fazal Ali Commission.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.