• Practice
  • About 14 min
  • 5 practice questions

Executive questions: who appoints, who advises, who answers

Solve exam-style questions on the Governor, the Council of Ministers and the Advocate General without falling for the usual swaps.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

The executive chapter is full of 'who appoints whom' items. The trick is to hold a small chain in your head and to remember who is responsible to whom. This lesson drills the chain and the traps that go with it.

The appointment chain

President appoints the Governor. Governor appoints the Chief Minister, and on the Chief Minister's advice the other ministers. Governor appoints the Advocate General of the state (Article 165), a person qualified to be a High Court judge, who holds office during the Governor's pleasure. Governor appoints the members of the State Public Service Commission under Article 316, but its members can be removed only by the President on a reference to the Supreme Court. A useful picture: the arrows go downward from the President.

The appointment chain

  1. President Appoints the Governor
  2. Governor Appoints the Chief Minister and others
  3. Chief Minister Advises on other ministers
  4. Council Answers to the Assembly
Who appoints whom

Powers that need care

Powers and Articles
PowerArticleTrap
Executive power in Governor's name154Exercised through officers, mostly on ministers' advice
Council aids and advises the Governor163The Governor has a few discretionary matters
CM and ministers appointed164The Council answers to the Assembly, not to the Governor
Advocate General165Appointed by the Governor, not by the High Court
Ordinance213Only when the Legislature is not in session
Governor's report on breakdown of state machinery356 is the President's powerThe Governor reports; the President acts

Memory method

Take the letters of the articles in sequence: 153 the Governor exists, 154 executive power, 155 appointment, 156 term, 157 qualifications, then 163 advice, 164 Chief Minister, 165 Advocate General. Saying them as a sequence helps you spot a wrong Article quickly.

Worked example 1: the swapped option

Question: 'The Chief Minister is appointed by:' Options: the President, the Governor, the Speaker, the Prime Minister. Working: Article 164 says the Governor. The President option is the trap, because the President appoints the Governor.

Worked example 2: Advocate General

Question: who appoints the Advocate General of a state? Working: Article 165 says the Governor does. The qualification is the same as for a High Court judge. He or she holds office during the pleasure of the Governor, so the post is a legal adviser to the state government.

Worked example 3: statement type

Statement 1: the Council of Ministers is collectively responsible to the Governor. Statement 2: it is collectively responsible to the Legislative Assembly. Working: Article 164 supports only the second. The first is the trap, since the Governor appoints but the Assembly can remove through a no-confidence vote.

Worked example 4: the chain in a longer question

Question: 'Arrange in order of appointment: Advocate General, Governor, Chief Minister.' Working: the President appoints the Governor first. The Governor then appoints the Chief Minister, and the Advocate General is also appointed by the Governor. So the Governor comes first, and the other two come after. If the stem asks who appoints the ministers other than the Chief Minister, the answer is the Governor, but only on the advice of the Chief Minister. Reading the last words of the question carefully saves marks.

Why the Governor is not the answer to every question

Many options say 'Governor' because the executive power is formally his or hers. But the question usually asks for the person who actually decides. When the stem says 'on whose advice', 'responsible to' or 'removes through a vote', the answer is the Council of Ministers or the Assembly, not the Governor.

President, Governor, CM. 153-157 Governor; 163 advice; 164 CM; 165 Advocate General; 213 ordinance; Council answers to the Assembly.

Key takeaways: the chain of appointment flows downwards, the chain of responsibility flows to the Assembly, and Articles 153 to 165 should be learned in sequence.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Who appoints the Advocate General of a state?

    1. The President
    2. The Governor
    3. The Chief Minister alone
    4. The High Court
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Article 165 gives the Governor the power.

  2. 2. Which Article makes the Council of Ministers collectively responsible to the Assembly?

    1. Article 153
    2. Article 157
    3. Article 164
    4. Article 165
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Article 164(2) states collective responsibility to the Legislative Assembly.

  3. 3. The President acts on a state's breakdown of constitutional machinery under:

    1. Article 356
    2. Article 213
    3. Article 163
    4. Article 154
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Article 356 is the President's power; the Governor reports.

  4. 4. Which pair is correct?

    1. Article 155: ordinance
    2. Article 165: High Court
    3. Article 155: appointment of Governor
    4. Article 164: Gram Sabha
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Article 155 deals with the Governor's appointment.

  5. 5. An ordinance can be issued by the Governor:

    1. when the Legislature is not in session
    2. at any time, even in session
    3. only by order of the High Court
    4. only for money matters
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Article 213 limits the power to the time the Legislature is not in session.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery