- Advanced
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Born, ruled, remembered: reading a personality question precisely
Separate what a person did, where they did it and where they are remembered, and use the method on hard questions where the obvious name is the wrong one.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
At the advanced level, examiners stop asking 'who was Almeida?' and start asking questions in which two or three names seem to fit. The difference between a right and a wrong answer is usually one small word in the question: where a person fought, where a person is remembered, or which side a person was on. This lesson gives you a method to read those words.
Three questions to ask of every name
The reading method
-
What did the person do?
- Sailed, fought, ruled, signed, surrendered, commanded
- Match the verb with the grid
-
Where did it happen?
- Calicut, Diu, Daman, Silvassa, the sea off Diu
- A place of action is not always a place of memory
-
Which side and when?
- Portuguese, Gujarat, Mughal, volunteer, Indian forces
- Year decides the side
Where the obvious name fails
| Question | Obvious but wrong | Right |
|---|---|---|
| Who made the sea route to India known? | Almeida | Vasco da Gama |
| Who won the battle off Diu in 1509? | Gama | Francisco de Almeida |
| Who signed the treaty that allowed the Diu fort? | Humayun | Bahadur Shah |
| Who governed Free Dadra and Nagar Haveli? | Azad Gomantak Dal | Varishta Panchayat |
| Who signed the Portuguese surrender in 1961? | Salazar | Manuel Vassalo e Silva |
In each pair the wrong answer is a real person or body from the same story. That is how a good distractor works. The wrong answer is wrong because of the verb: made known, won, signed, governed, surrendered.
Born, worked and remembered
Some people are known by one place and some by several. Captain Mulla commanded a ship that was lost in the Arabian Sea, and he is remembered at Diu, where the INS Khukri Memorial stands. Almeida's battle was at sea off Diu, but he was a Portuguese viceroy and his base was not in Diu. Bahadur Shah ruled Gujarat, but he died near Diu. A question that says 'died near' wants Diu; a question that says 'ruled' wants Gujarat.
A checklist for distractors
- Is the name a person of the right century? Gama, Almeida, Cunha and Braganza are sixteenth century; Mulla is 1971.
- Is the name on the right side? Malik Ayaz and Bahadur Shah are Gujarat; Humayun is Mughal; the rest are Portuguese or Indian.
- Is the name a person or a body? The Varishta Panchayat, the United Front of Goans and the Azad Gomantak Dal are bodies, not individuals.
- Does the verb fit the role? A viceroy commands, a sultan permits, a governor-general surrenders, a captain goes down with his ship.
Run these four tests silently on each option. Usually two options fail the first test and one more fails the second, which leaves the answer without any need to recall the page of a textbook.
Worked example 1: the verb decides
Question: 'Who allowed the Portuguese to build a fort at Diu: Almeida, Bahadur Shah, Cunha or Braganza?' Working: only a ruler can allow a fort on his land. Almeida, Cunha and Braganza were Portuguese. Answer: Bahadur Shah.
Worked example 2: the year decides the side
Question: 'In 1509, who fought for Gujarat at Diu: Malik Ayaz, Humayun, Cunha or Silveira?' Working: Cunha and Silveira were Portuguese and belong to the 1530s. Humayun was a Mughal emperor, not at Diu. Malik Ayaz was the governor of Diu under Gujarat. Answer: Malik Ayaz.
Worked example 3: statements
Statement 1: Dadra was freed by volunteers in 1954. Statement 2: Daman and Diu were freed by Operation Vijay in 1961. Statement 3: Both were freed by the same method. Working: statements 1 and 2 are correct; statement 3 is wrong since volunteers acted in 1954 and the armed forces in 1961. Answer: 1 and 2 only.
Worked example 4: assertion and reason
Assertion: Vasco da Gama cannot be called the conqueror of Diu. Reason: He reached Calicut in 1498, while Diu came into Portuguese hands through the treaty of 1535. Working: both true and the reason explains the assertion. Answer: both true; reason explains.
Verb, place, side, year: read these four words before the options.
Key takeaways: distractors are real people from the same story, so read the verb. For anything about present status, check the current legal position.
Check your understanding
-
1. Who allowed the Portuguese to build a fort at Diu?
- Francisco de Almeida
- Bahadur Shah
- Nuno da Cunha
- Dom Constantino de Braganza
Show answer
Answer: B. Only a ruler can allow a fort on his land; Bahadur Shah did so in 1535.
-
2. Who fought for Gujarat at Diu in 1509?
- Silveira
- Cunha
- Malik Ayaz
- Humayun
Show answer
Answer: C. Malik Ayaz was the governor of Diu under Gujarat.
-
3. Statement 1: Dadra freed by volunteers (1954). Statement 2: Daman and Diu freed by Operation Vijay (1961). Which are correct?
- Neither
- 1 only
- 2 only
- Both 1 and 2
Show answer
Answer: D. Both are correct.
-
4. Assertion: Gama did not conquer Diu. Reason: He reached Calicut in 1498 and Diu came by treaty in 1535. Choose:
- Both true, reason explains
- Both true, reason does not explain
- Assertion true, reason false
- Assertion false, reason true
Show answer
Answer: A. Both are true, and the reason explains why Gama is not the conqueror.
-
5. A question says a person is remembered at Diu with a memorial. The best match is:
- Almeida
- Mahendra Nath Mulla
- Bahadur Shah
- Vassalo e Silva
Show answer
Answer: B. The INS Khukri Memorial at Diu remembers Captain Mulla's ship and crew.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.