- Practice
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Why the culture is what it is: cause and effect
Answer 'why' questions by linking festivals and traditions to geography and history: the sea, the forest, the monsoon and the Portuguese past.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Better exam questions ask 'why' instead of 'what'. Why is there a sea festival in Daman and Diu? Why do Christians keep Christmas there? Why does Marathi matter inland? The answers follow from geography and history. In this lesson, you practise tracing a custom to its cause.
The causal chain
From cause to custom
- Geography or history Sea coast, hills and forest, Portuguese rule, neighbouring states
- Livelihood or community Fishing, tribal farming, Christian parishes, Gujarati traders
- Belief and calendar What is worshipped and when
- Festival or art The custom that exams ask about
Four standard causes
| Cause | Effect on culture | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Arabian Sea coast | Fishing communities and a sea festival | Nariyal Purnima in Daman and Diu |
| Forested hills and heavy monsoon | Farming year of paddy and nagli; nature worship | Tarpa harvest dance; Waghdev |
| Portuguese rule over Daman and Diu (the 1500s to 1961) | Churches, Christian feasts, a Christian community | Christmas, church feast days |
| Closeness to Gujarat and Maharashtra | Gujarati festivals and language; Marathi inland | Navratri garba; Marathi in Dadra and Nagar Haveli |
Notice that every cause has a limit. The Portuguese ruled Dadra and Nagar Haveli only from the late eighteenth century to 1954, and mostly for revenue, so Christian feasts are not its main festivals. The earlier history lessons make the same point: Portuguese influence is strongest in Daman and Diu.
Reading a question for its cause
- Find the place word: coast, hills, island, inland.
- Find the community word: fishers, tribal, Christian, Gujarati.
- Decide what sort of cause is hidden: geography, history or livelihood.
- Pick the option that agrees with both the place and the cause.
Worked example 1: the sea festival
Question: 'Why is Nariyal Purnima celebrated in Daman and Diu?' Working: Daman and Diu lie on the Arabian Sea, and fishing is a traditional occupation. Families therefore thank the sea before the boats go out after the monsoon. Answer: because their livelihood depends on the sea.
Worked example 2: Christmas on the coast
Question: 'Why do the churches and Christian feasts stand out in Daman and Diu?' Working: the Portuguese held Daman and Diu from the sixteenth century to 1961 and built churches there. The Christian community grew up around them. Answer: the long Portuguese rule.
Worked example 3: the inland language
Question: 'Why is Marathi common in Dadra and Nagar Haveli?' Working: it borders Maharashtra, and language follows neighbours. Answer: its border with Maharashtra.
Worked example 4: rain and farming
Question: 'Why is the tarpa dance heard mostly after the monsoon crops are gathered?' Working: the villages live by paddy and nagli sown in the monsoon. The harvest brings food and rest, so thanks are offered with music and dance. Answer: because the harvest ends the farming year.
Worked example 5: a wrong cause
Question: 'A student says that Nariyal Purnima is a festival of Dadra and Nagar Haveli because that is where the Daman Ganga flows. What is wrong?' Working: the Daman Ganga does flow through Dadra and Nagar Haveli, but Dadra and Nagar Haveli has no sea coast. The festival belongs to the sea-going communities of the coast. Answer: the river is not the sea.
Name the place, name the livelihood, then name the custom.
Key takeaways: culture follows geography and history. The sea gives Nariyal Purnima, the hills and monsoon give the tarpa and farming traditions, the Portuguese past gives churches and Christian feasts, and the neighbours give Gujarati and Marathi influence.
Check your understanding
-
1. Why is Portuguese influence strongest in Daman and Diu?
- The Portuguese never left them
- The Portuguese held them from the sixteenth century to 1961
- They were part of Goa until 2020
- Dadra and Nagar Haveli had no Portuguese rule
Show answer
Answer: B. Daman and Diu had centuries of Portuguese rule. Dadra and Nagar Haveli had a shorter period, mainly for revenue, and was freed in 1954.
-
2. Why is Marathi spoken by many people in Dadra and Nagar Haveli?
- It has no Gujarati speakers
- It was ruled by Bombay in 1961
- It has a long sea coast
- It borders Maharashtra
Show answer
Answer: D. Languages follow neighbours, and Dadra and Nagar Haveli lies between Gujarat and Maharashtra.
-
3. The coconut offered on Nariyal Purnima is a sign of thanks to:
- the sea
- the forest
- a fort
- the harvest god
Show answer
Answer: A. The offering is made to the sea before the boats go out again.
-
4. Which cause best explains tribal harvest music?
- The Portuguese churches
- Sea trade
- The farming year of paddy and nagli
- The merger of 2020
Show answer
Answer: C. Harvest music is tied to the monsoon-fed fields of Dadra and Nagar Haveli.
-
5. Which is a WRONG cause-and-effect link?
- Arabian Sea coast leads to fishing festivals
- Portuguese rule led to churches in Daman and Diu
- Heavy monsoon leads to paddy farming inland
- Daman Ganga flows through Dadra and Nagar Haveli, so it has a sea festival
Show answer
Answer: D. A river is not a sea. Dadra and Nagar Haveli has no coastline, so it has no sea festival of its own.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.