- Advanced
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Multi-statement questions: testing each claim alone
Solve questions with two or three statements by testing every claim separately and by spotting half-true claims that carry a wrong detail.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Advanced papers often replace single-fact questions with statement sets. You are given three claims and four options such as '1 and 2 only'. The question is not harder because the facts are harder; it is harder because one small detail in one claim has been changed. In this lesson you will learn to find that detail quickly.
The four ways a claim can be spoiled
| Kind of spoiling | Example | How to catch it |
|---|---|---|
| Wrong part | Panikota is a church in Daman | Ask: which of the three parts? |
| Wrong bank | The Fort of St. Jerome is in Moti Daman | Moti is south and big; Nani is north and small |
| Wrong type | Madhuban is a lake garden | Reservoir against lake: how was it made? |
| Wrong date | Daman was captured in 1535 | Treaty 1535; Daman 1559 |
Solving a statement set
- Split Write each claim on its own line
- Test Mark T or F for each, with the reason
- Match Find the option that gives exactly your T set
- Recheck Look again at any claim you marked T quickly
Half-true claims
The most dangerous claim is half true. 'Vanganga is a lake garden used for recreation and for supplying drinking water to the Union Territory' starts correctly but ends wrongly, because the garden is a place for walks and boating. A claim is true only when every word is true. When in doubt, ask whether you can name the evidence for each half.
Using the reason for a fact
Facts are easier to defend when you know why. Moti Daman, the bigger town, is on the south bank with a walled fort. The Fort of St. Jerome is in Nani Daman, on the north bank. The Portuguese captured Daman in 1559 and fortified both banks. From this one sentence you can judge many claims. In the same way, the Naida caves are natural because limestone is worn by water; the Gangeshwar Mahadev temple is a Shiva shrine because Gangeshwar names Ganga and Ishwar, a name of Shiva.
A useful habit is to keep a short fact card in your head for each place: part, type and one feature. Satmaliya: Dadra and Nagar Haveli, deer park. Tribal Cultural Museum: Silvassa, tribal objects. Madhuban: near Silvassa, reservoir. Moti Daman: Daman, south bank. Panikota: Diu, fortress in the sea. With the card ready, a spoiled claim stands out at once, because one of its three details will not match. Practise by taking a place at random and saying its card aloud, then deliberately saying one wrong detail and noticing how wrong it sounds.
Worked example 1: three claims
Question: '(1) Satmaliya is a deer park near Silvassa. (2) The Tribal Cultural Museum is at Silvassa. (3) Satmaliya is in Diu.' Working: (1) true, (2) true, (3) false. The option with exactly (1) and (2) is correct. Answer: (1) and (2) only.
Worked example 2: a spoiled date
Question: '(1) The treaty for the fort at Diu was signed in 1535. (2) The siege of Diu came in 1538. (3) Both events happened after the capture of Daman.' Working: (1) and (2) are true. For (3), Daman was captured in 1559, which is later than both, so (3) is false. Answer: (1) and (2) only.
Worked example 3: two spoilings in one claim
Question: 'The Church of Bom Jesus is a Baroque church in Nani Daman.' Working: the church stands in Moti Daman, and the Baroque carved front belongs to St. Paul's Church in Diu. The claim has two errors, in the town and in the style, so it is false. Answer: false, with two errors.
A claim is true only when every part of it is true.
Key takeaways: Split, test, match, recheck. Know the four spoilings, treat half-true claims as false, and use reasons to defend facts.
Check your understanding
-
1. Statements: (1) Moti Daman is on the south bank. (2) The Fort of St. Jerome is in Moti Daman. (3) Panikota is in the sea. Which are correct?
- (1) and (2) only
- (1) and (3) only
- (2) and (3) only
- All three
Show answer
Answer: B. (1) is true. (2) is false: the Fort of St. Jerome guards Nani Daman on the north bank. (3) is true.
-
2. Statements: (1) Madhuban is a reservoir. (2) Vanganga is a lake garden at Dadra. (3) Both are in Diu. Which are correct?
- (1) only
- (2) and (3) only
- (1) and (3) only
- (1) and (2) only
Show answer
Answer: D. Both are near Silvassa in Dadra and Nagar Haveli, so (3) is false.
-
3. Statements: (1) The Naida caves are in limestone. (2) Limestone caves are formed by the work of water over a long time. (3) The caves are man-made. Which are correct?
- (1) and (2) only
- (1) and (3) only
- (2) and (3) only
- (3) only
Show answer
Answer: A. The caves are natural, carved in limestone over time, so (3) is false.
-
4. Which combination of treaty and fort is correct?
- 1559 treaty and Diu Fort
- 1535 treaty and Moti Daman fort
- 1535 treaty and Diu Fort
- 1954 treaty and Panikota
Show answer
Answer: C. The treaty of 1535 let the Portuguese build the fort at Diu. Daman was captured in 1559, not acquired by this treaty.
-
5. Statements: (1) Devka and Jampore are beaches of Daman. (2) Nagoa and Chakratirth are beaches of Diu. (3) Ghoghla is a beach of Daman. Which are correct?
- (1) only
- (2) and (3) only
- (1) and (2) only
- All three
Show answer
Answer: C. Ghoghla belongs to Diu, on the mainland part, so (3) is false.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.