• Advanced
  • About 16 min
  • 5 practice questions

The Governor between the state and the Union: discretion, reservation and President's Rule

Analyse where the Governor acts alone, how a bill is reserved for the President, and how President's Rule under Article 356 affects a state like Tripura.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

In the foundation course you learned that the Governor is a nominal head who acts on the advice of the Council of Ministers. Advanced questions ask the harder thing: in which situations is the Governor not simply following advice, and how does the Union enter a state's affairs? Tripura became a full state only in 1972, so these rules shape its politics from that date onwards.

Where the Governor has room

Article 163 says the Governor acts on advice 'except in so far as he is by or under this Constitution required to exercise his functions in his discretion'. The discretion is therefore limited to what the Constitution provides, and to the situations that naturally arise from the parliamentary system. Four are most important.

  • Choosing a Chief Minister when no party has a clear majority in the Assembly. The Governor must judge who is most likely to command the confidence of the House, and that judgement is tested by a vote in the Assembly.
  • Reserving a bill for the President under Article 200. The Governor does not have to follow the Council's advice on this.
  • Reporting to the President that the constitutional machinery in the state has failed.
  • Functions under the Sixth Schedule for the autonomous council areas, which the Governor performs in discretion in several matters.

The reserved bill

Under Article 200, a bill passed by the Assembly goes to the Governor, who may assent, withhold assent, return it (if it is not a money bill) or reserve it. A reserved bill goes to the President under Article 201. The President may assent or withhold assent, or direct the Governor to return the bill. If it is returned, the Assembly must reconsider it within six months, and if the Assembly passes it again, it is sent to the President again.

President's Rule

Article 355 makes it the Union's duty to protect each state from external aggression and internal disturbance. Article 356 lets the President proclaim that the government of a state cannot be carried on according to the Constitution, on a report from the Governor or otherwise. The proclamation must be approved by both Houses of Parliament within two months. During this rule the Assembly may be suspended or dissolved and Parliament makes laws for the state. In S R Bommai (1994) the Supreme Court held that such a proclamation is open to judicial review.

Union and state: powers and checks
ProvisionPowerCheck on the power
Article 163Governor's discretionLimited to what the Constitution allows
Article 200 and 201Reservation of a billThe President decides; the bill may return
Article 213OrdinanceLapses six weeks after the Assembly meets
Article 356President's RuleParliament's approval within two months; judicial review

The reserved bill

  1. Assembly passes a bill Sent to the Governor
  2. Governor reserves it Under Article 200
  3. President considers it Assent, withhold or return
  4. Assembly reconsiders Within six months of the return
  5. Bill sent again To the President

Then back to step 1: Assembly passes a bill

The bill can come back to the Assembly

Worked example 1: a hung Assembly

Question: in a 60-member Assembly no party has 31 seats. Who decides whom to invite to form the government? Working: the Governor, in discretion, invites the person who can best show the confidence of the House, and the Assembly then tests this. Thirty-one is the simple majority of sixty, since half of sixty is thirty and a majority needs one more.

Worked example 2: a long chain

Question: the Assembly passes a bill, the Governor reserves it and the President returns it with a message. The Assembly passes it again three months later. What happens? Working: the bill goes to the President again, since the Assembly acted within six months. The Governor does not decide it. The President is not bound to assent, unlike the Governor on an ordinary bill.

Worked example 3: Parliament's time limit

Question: a proclamation under Article 356 is issued on 1 June. By which date must both Houses approve it? Working: within two months, so by 1 August. If it is not approved, the proclamation ceases at the end of that time.

Discretion is narrow; reservation sends a bill to the President; Article 356 needs approval in two months and can be reviewed by courts.

Key takeaways: the Governor's discretion exists, but is narrow. A reserved bill is decided by the President. President's Rule under Article 356 needs approval from both Houses of Parliament within two months, and is open to judicial review.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which statement about the Governor is correct?

    1. The Governor may reserve a bill for the President without the Council's advice
    2. The Governor can never act in discretion
    3. The Governor can dissolve Parliament
    4. The Governor appoints the judges of the High Court
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Reservation is among the matters where the Governor acts on his own judgement. The other options describe powers the Governor does not have.

  2. 2. Consider: 1. A proclamation under Article 356 must be approved by Parliament within two months. 2. The proclamation cannot be questioned in any court. Which is correct?

    1. 2 only
    2. Both 1 and 2
    3. Neither 1 nor 2
    4. 1 only
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The first statement is correct. In the Bommai case the Supreme Court held that a proclamation is subject to judicial review, so statement 2 is wrong.

  3. 3. A: The Governor of Tripura must give assent when the Assembly passes a bill again after he returned it. R: Article 200 forbids the Governor from withholding assent on a bill passed again after return. Choose:

    1. Both A and R are true but R is not the correct explanation of A
    2. A is true but R is false
    3. Both A and R are true and R is the correct explanation of A
    4. A is false but R is true
    Show answer

    Answer: C. After a bill is returned and passed again, the Governor shall not withhold assent. This rule is the reason for the assertion, so R explains A.

  4. 4. A bill reserved for the President is returned and the Assembly passes it again. The Assembly must have acted within:

    1. One month
    2. Six months of the return
    3. Two years
    4. Six weeks
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Article 201 gives six months for the Assembly to reconsider a returned bill.

  5. 5. The duty of the Union to protect states from internal disturbance is stated in:

    1. Article 356
    2. Article 355
    3. Article 352
    4. Article 360
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Article 355 states the duty. Article 356 is the power to proclaim failure of constitutional machinery.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery