- Practice
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Governor, ministers and the two Houses: traps and recall
Revise who heads the state, how ministers are chosen and answerable, and the two Houses of the legislature, then practise the traps examiners set.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Questions on the state government test whether you can tell the formal head from the real head, and the lower House from the upper. The facts are few and settled, but examiners swap the Governor with the Chief Minister, or the Vidhan Sabha with the Vidhan Parishad. This lesson fixes the structure in compact form and then shows the usual traps.
Revision table: the state executive
| Office | How it is filled | What to remember | Trap to avoid |
|---|---|---|---|
| Governor | Appointed by the President (Article 155) | Executive power of the state is vested in the Governor (Article 154) | The Governor is the formal head, not the real head |
| Chief Minister | Appointed by the Governor (Article 164) | Usually the leader of the majority in the Vidhan Sabha | Not elected by the people directly as CM |
| Council of Ministers | Appointed on the Chief Minister's advice | Collectively responsible to the Vidhan Sabha | Responsible to the lower House, not to the Council |
| Advocate-General | Appointed by the Governor (Article 165) | The state's chief law officer | Not a judge |
The legislature: two Houses
Uttar Pradesh is one of the few states with a bicameral legislature. The lower House is the Vidhan Sabha, which has 403 seats; members are elected directly by voters for five years unless it is dissolved earlier. The upper House is the Vidhan Parishad, which has 100 members. It is a permanent House and is never dissolved as a whole: a part of its members retire at regular intervals. Its members are elected by the MLAs, by local bodies, by graduates and by teachers, and the Governor nominates the rest. The state also sends members to Parliament: 80 to the Lok Sabha and 31 to the Rajya Sabha.
Vidhan Sabha and Vidhan Parishad
-
Vidhan Sabha
- Lower House
- Direct election
- Five-year term unless dissolved
- Council of Ministers answers here
-
Vidhan Parishad
- Upper House
- Indirect election plus nominated members
- Permanent; never dissolved as a whole
- Cannot remove the government
Ages and the limit on ministers
A person must be at least 25 years old to sit in the Vidhan Sabha and at least 30 to sit in the Vidhan Parishad (Article 173). The number of ministers, including the Chief Minister, may not exceed 15 per cent of the strength of the Vidhan Sabha. This limit was added in 2003 by the 91st Amendment. A numerical question may therefore ask for the largest ministry that a House of a given size can have.
Worked example 1: who answers to whom
Question: The Council of Ministers of Uttar Pradesh is collectively responsible to which body? Working: Collective responsibility attaches to the elected lower House, because it is the House that can pass a vote of no confidence. Answer: the Vidhan Sabha.
Worked example 2: the 15 per cent limit
Question: What is the largest size of the Council of Ministers if the Vidhan Sabha has 403 members? Working: 15 per cent of 403 is 60.45. The limit is a ceiling, and a body cannot have part of a minister, so the figure is rounded down. Answer: 60 ministers, counting the Chief Minister.
Worked example 3: the Governor's role
Question: (1) The Governor is appointed by the President. (2) The Governor is elected by the Vidhan Sabha. Which is correct? Working: Statement 1 matches Article 155. Statement 2 gives the Governor an election that does not exist. Answer: 1 only.
Governor appointed by the President; Chief Minister by the Governor; ministers answer to the Vidhan Sabha. 403 and 100. Ages 25 and 30. Ministers not above 15 per cent of the House.
Key takeaways: the Governor is the formal head and the Council of Ministers is the real head. The ministry answers to the lower House only. Keep 403 with the Vidhan Sabha and 100 with the Parishad, and do the 15 per cent sum by rounding down.
Check your understanding
-
1. The Governor of Uttar Pradesh is appointed by:
- The Chief Minister
- The President
- The Vidhan Sabha
- The Chief Justice
Show answer
Answer: B. Article 155 says the Governor is appointed by the President. The Chief Minister is appointed by the Governor.
-
2. The Council of Ministers is collectively responsible to the:
- Vidhan Sabha
- Vidhan Parishad
- Governor
- High Court
Show answer
Answer: A. The ministry answers to the elected lower House. The Parishad cannot remove it.
-
3. The minimum age to be a member of the Vidhan Parishad is:
- 21 years
- 25 years
- 30 years
- 35 years
Show answer
Answer: C. Article 173 sets 30 for the upper House and 25 for the lower. Thirty-five is the Governor's minimum age.
-
4. Consider: (1) The Vidhan Parishad is a permanent House. (2) It has 403 members. Which is correct?
- 1 only
- Both 1 and 2
- 2 only
- Neither 1 nor 2
Show answer
Answer: A. The Parishad is never dissolved as a whole, so 1 is true. It has 100 members; 403 belongs to the Vidhan Sabha, so 2 is false.
-
5. If a House has 200 members, the largest ministry allowed at 15 per cent is:
- 15
- 20
- 40
- 30
Show answer
Answer: D. 15 per cent of 200 is 30.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.