- Advanced
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Reading the evidence: Puranic geography, Kalsi, Kuninda coins and Katyuri inscriptions
Judge what each kind of source can and cannot prove about early Uttarakhand, and use that judgement to solve hard statement and source-based questions.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
At the advanced level, questions on early Uttarakhand stop asking only 'where is Kalsi?' and start asking what a source proves. A rock painting, a Puranic description, an edict, a coin and a copper plate each tell a different kind of truth. Knowing the limits of each source lets you reject options that claim too much.
Five kinds of evidence
| Evidence | Example | What it can prove | What it cannot prove |
|---|---|---|---|
| Prehistoric art | Lakhudiyar rock shelter, near Almora | People lived and made art in the hills before writing | Names of rulers or dates of kingdoms |
| Religious text | Skanda Purana: Kedarkhand and Manaskhand | How the region's sacred geography was imagined | Exact political boundaries or reigns |
| Imperial edict | Ashoka's rock edicts at Kalsi, near Dehradun | Mauryan contact with the western edge of the hills, 3rd century BCE | That the whole hill region was ruled directly by the Mauryas |
| Coins | Kuninda coins of Amoghabhuti | A ruler's name, his authority and trade links | Detailed events of his reign |
| Copper plates and temples | Katyuri grants; Baijnath temples | Royal names, land gifts, patronage of temples | Everyday life outside the court |
Kalsi in detail
Kalsi lies on the western edge of the hills near the meeting of the Tons and the Yamuna. The rock carries a set of Ashoka's major rock edicts written in the Brahmi script. The site shows that Mauryan messages reached this edge of the Himalaya. Notice the careful wording: an edict at the edge proves contact and influence, not direct government of every valley in the interior. An option saying 'Kalsi proves that the whole of Garhwal and Kumaon was a Mauryan province' claims too much.
Kunindas: coins as political evidence
The Kunindas are known mainly through coins. Coins with the name of Amoghabhuti show a ruler confident enough to issue money in his own name, which in turn shows organised authority and trade. Old texts, including the Mahabharata, also mention a hill people called the Kulindas, so text and coin support each other. When two independent kinds of evidence agree, historians treat the conclusion as strong.
Katyuris: inscriptions and temples
The Katyuris left copper-plate grants recording land given to temples and Brahmins; plates found at Pandukeshwar in Garhwal are among the best known. Such grants name kings and places, so they help place the dynasty's early centre at Kartikeyapura, identified with Joshimath, before power shifted to the Katyur valley around Baijnath on the Gomti. The Baijnath temples show the dynasty's patronage of temple building in stone.
Worked example 1: what does the source prove?
Question: 'The Kalsi rock edict proves that (1) the region had contact with the Mauryan empire (2) Ashoka built a capital at Kalsi (3) Brahmi writing was used there.' Working: (1) is proved by the presence of the edict. (2) is not stated by the edict at all. (3) is proved because the edict is in Brahmi. Answer: 1 and 3 only.
Worked example 2: matching evidence to period
Question: 'Arrange the evidence from oldest to most recent: Katyuri copper plates, Lakhudiyar paintings, Kalsi edict, Kuninda coins.' Working: Lakhudiyar is prehistoric; Kalsi is 3rd century BCE; Kuninda coins belong to the ancient period after the Mauryas; Katyuri plates are early medieval. Answer: Lakhudiyar, Kalsi, Kuninda coins, Katyuri plates.
Ask of every source: what does it actually show? Paintings show people, edicts show contact, coins show rulers, copper plates show grants and kings - none of them proves more than it says.
Key takeaways
- Lakhudiyar (prehistoric), Kalsi (Mauryan), Kuninda coins (ancient), Katyuri plates and temples (early medieval) form a sequence of evidence.
- Kalsi's edicts are in Brahmi and prove Mauryan contact, not direct rule over the whole region.
- Kuninda history rests on coins (Amoghabhuti), supported by textual mention of the Kulindas.
- Katyuri copper plates, such as those from Pandukeshwar, and the Baijnath temples document the dynasty.
Check your understanding
-
1. Ashoka's edicts at Kalsi are written in which script?
- Kharosthi
- Devanagari
- Brahmi
- Sharada
Show answer
Answer: C. The Kalsi edicts are in the Brahmi script, the script of most of Ashoka's inscriptions in India.
-
2. Which conclusion goes BEYOND what the Kalsi edict can prove?
- The Mauryas governed every valley of Garhwal and Kumaon directly
- Mauryan messages reached the edge of the hills
- Writing was carved at Kalsi in the 3rd century BCE
- The site was important enough for an imperial message
Show answer
Answer: A. An edict at the western edge of the hills shows contact and influence; it does not prove direct government of every interior valley.
-
3. Copper plates found at Pandukeshwar are linked with which dynasty?
- Chand
- Kuninda
- Panwar
- Katyuri
Show answer
Answer: D. The Pandukeshwar copper plates are grants of the Katyuri period and help historians reconstruct Katyuri rule.
-
4. Arrange from oldest to most recent: (1) Katyuri copper plates (2) Kalsi edict (3) Lakhudiyar paintings (4) Kuninda coins
- 3, 4, 2, 1
- 3, 2, 4, 1
- 2, 3, 4, 1
- 3, 2, 1, 4
Show answer
Answer: B. Lakhudiyar is prehistoric, Kalsi is Mauryan (3rd century BCE), Kuninda coins are later ancient, and Katyuri plates are early medieval.
-
5. Why do historians treat the Kunindas' existence as well established?
- Because the British recorded it
- Because coins and old texts independently support it
- Because they built the Baijnath temples
- Because the Skanda Purana names Amoghabhuti as king of Kedarkhand
Show answer
Answer: B. Kuninda coins (with Amoghabhuti's name) and textual mention of the Kulindas are independent kinds of evidence that agree.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.