Sources and their limits
EvidenceExampleWhat it can proveWhat it cannot prove
Prehistoric artLakhudiyar rock shelter, near AlmoraPeople lived and made art in the hills before writingNames of rulers or dates of kingdoms
Religious textSkanda Purana: Kedarkhand and ManaskhandHow the region's sacred geography was imaginedExact political boundaries or reigns
Imperial edictAshoka's rock edicts at Kalsi, near DehradunMauryan contact with the western edge of the hills, 3rd century BCEThat the whole hill region was ruled directly by the Mauryas
CoinsKuninda coins of AmoghabhutiA ruler's name, his authority and trade linksDetailed events of his reign
Copper plates and templesKatyuri grants; Baijnath templesRoyal names, land gifts, patronage of templesEveryday life outside the court

Ask of every source: what does it actually show? Paintings show people, edicts show contact, coins show rulers, copper plates show grants and kings - none of them proves more than it says.

  • Lakhudiyar (prehistoric), Kalsi (Mauryan), Kuninda coins (ancient), Katyuri plates and temples (early medieval) form a sequence of evidence.
  • Kalsi's edicts are in Brahmi and prove Mauryan contact, not direct rule over the whole region.
  • Kuninda history rests on coins (Amoghabhuti), supported by textual mention of the Kulindas.
  • Katyuri copper plates, such as those from Pandukeshwar, and the Baijnath temples document the dynasty.