- Advanced
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Statement questions on the reformers: how to catch one wrong word
Practise the statement and assertion-reason formats on the reformers of Bengal, learning the usual false twists: swapped years, swapped names, and words like 'only' and 'first'.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
At the advanced level, examiners rarely ask 'who founded X?'. They give two statements, or an assertion and a reason, and ask what is true. The facts are the ones you already know, but now one wrong word can make a whole statement false. This lesson teaches the method on the reformers of the Bengal Renaissance.
A four-step method
Solving a statement question
- Split Treat each statement separately
- Test each part Check names, years and verbs one by one
- Spot absolutes Words like only, first, all, always
- Choose Pick the option that matches your verdicts
The usual false twists
| Twist | Example of a false version | Correct fact |
|---|---|---|
| Swapped years | Sati was ended in 1856 | Sati was ended in 1829; the 1856 Act is for widow remarriage |
| Swapped names | Vidyasagar founded the Brahmo Sabha | Raja Ram Mohan Roy did, in 1828 |
| Swapped causes | The Brahmo Sabha was set up to promote widow remarriage | It stood for one God and against idol worship and rigid custom |
| Wrong place | Ramakrishna was a priest at Belur Math | He served at the Dakshineswar temple |
| Too strong a word | Roy was the only reformer of Bengal | Many reformers worked in Bengal |
Assertion and reason
In an assertion-reason question you must decide three things. Is the assertion true? Is the reason true? And, if both are true, does the reason actually explain the assertion? A reason can be a true fact that is simply unrelated. For example, it is true that Vidyasagar wrote Barnaparichay and also true that he campaigned for widow remarriage, but the first does not explain the second.
A useful test is to put the word 'because' between the two parts. If the sentence 'Assertion, because reason' reads naturally and is correct, the reason explains the assertion.
Why examiners like these formats
A direct question tests one fact. A statement question tests whether you know the fact well enough to notice a small change. That is why the same fact can come back in a new disguise: the year 1829 may appear as the date of Vidyasagar's Act, or the name Roy may appear in the place of Vidyasagar. If you learned each person with a field, a place and one fact, as the Foundation course taught, you can catch these swaps.
Be careful with the word only. A statement such as 'Raja Ram Mohan Roy was the only reformer who worked against sati' is false even though Roy did lead that campaign, because the word only claims more than the facts allow. In the same way first, all, never and always need a firm basis before you accept them. When a statement uses a strong word that you cannot verify, treat it as doubtful and look at the other statement before deciding.
Worked example 1: two statements
Statement I: Sati was made illegal in 1829. Statement II: Vidyasagar founded the Brahmo Sabha. Working: Statement I is true (Lord William Bentinck, after Roy's campaign). Statement II is false; the Brahmo Sabha was Roy's, founded in 1828. Answer: only Statement I is true.
Worked example 2: assertion and reason
Assertion: Raja Ram Mohan Roy is called a pioneer of the Bengal Renaissance. Reason: He campaigned against sati and founded the Brahmo Sabha. Working: both are true, and the reason gives the evidence for the assertion. Answer: both true and the reason explains the assertion.
Worked example 3: a true reason that does not explain
Assertion: The Widows' Remarriage Act was passed in 1856. Reason: Vidyasagar was the Principal of the Sanskrit College. Working: both are true, but being a college principal is not the cause of an Act. Answer: both true, but the reason does not explain the assertion.
Split, test, spot absolutes, choose. Put 'because' between assertion and reason.
Key takeaways: never accept a statement as a whole. Check each name, year and verb. A true reason is not always the explanation.
Check your understanding
-
1. Statement I: Raja Ram Mohan Roy founded the Brahmo Sabha in 1828. Statement II: The Hindu Widows' Remarriage Act was passed in 1856.
- Only Statement I is true
- Both statements are true
- Only Statement II is true
- Neither statement is true
Show answer
Answer: B. Both are correct facts of the Bengal Renaissance.
-
2. Statement I: Sati was made illegal in 1856. Statement II: Vidyasagar was born in 1820.
- Both statements are true
- Only Statement I is true
- Only Statement II is true
- Neither statement is true
Show answer
Answer: C. Sati was banned in 1829, so Statement I is false; Vidyasagar was born in 1820.
-
3. Statement I: Ramakrishna Paramahamsa founded the Brahmo Sabha. Statement II: Ramakrishna served at the Dakshineswar temple.
- Both statements are true
- Only Statement I is true
- Neither statement is true
- Only Statement II is true
Show answer
Answer: D. The Brahmo Sabha was Roy's, so I is false; II is true.
-
4. Assertion: Sati was ended in Bengal in 1829. Reason: Lord William Bentinck passed the law after a long public campaign led by Raja Ram Mohan Roy.
- Both are true and the reason correctly explains the assertion
- Both are true but the reason does not explain the assertion
- The assertion is true but the reason is false
- The assertion is false but the reason is true
Show answer
Answer: A. Both facts are true and the second explains how the first came about.
-
5. Assertion: The Widows' Remarriage Act was passed in 1856. Reason: Vidyasagar wrote the primer Barnaparichay.
- Both are true and the reason correctly explains the assertion
- Both are true but the reason does not explain the assertion
- The assertion is true but the reason is false
- The assertion is false but the reason is true
Show answer
Answer: B. Both are true, but writing a primer did not cause the Act; his campaign did.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.