• Advanced
  • About 13 min
  • 5 practice questions

The state in the Constitution: Articles 3 and 4, the lists and President's rule

Explain how Parliament can change a state's area or name, how powers are divided between the Union and a state like West Bengal, and when the Union may take over a state's government.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

The Foundation and Practice courses told you how West Bengal's territory grew. This lesson asks the deeper question: by what authority could that happen at all, and what limits does the Constitution place on a state? Advanced questions use statements and assertion-reason forms, so the working in each answer below is as important as the answer.

A Union of states, not a union of fixed borders

Article 1 calls India a 'Union of States'. A state's territory is not guaranteed in the way a country's is. Article 3 lets Parliament, by ordinary law, form a new state, increase or reduce the area of a state, alter its boundaries and alter its name. A bill under Article 3 can be introduced only on the recommendation of the President, and if it affects a state, the President refers it to that state's legislature to give its views within a time he or she fixes. Parliament is not bound by those views. Article 4 says that such a law is not a constitutional amendment under Article 368, so no special majority is needed. This is the reason the transfer of Purulia from Bihar in 1956 could be done by an Act of Parliament, without asking the consent of either state.

Changing a state's area or name

  1. President's recommendation Needed before the bill is introduced
  2. Reference to the state The legislature gives its views by a date
  3. Parliament decides Views are heard but not binding
  4. Law passed by simple majority Not an amendment under Article 368
The Article 3 process

Who may legislate on what

The Seventh Schedule at a glance
ListExamples of subjectsWho makes laws
Union ListDefence, foreign affairsParliament only
State ListPolice, public order, local government, public health, agriculture, landState legislature (Parliament only in special cases)
Concurrent ListCriminal law and procedure, forests, educationBoth; the Union law prevails if they clash

Notice what this means for the course. Police and local government are state subjects, so the Panchayat Act of West Bengal and the state police are the state's own business. The High Court and the Public Service Commission, in turn, work under constitutional articles, not under the lists.

When the state government fails: President's rule

If the President is satisfied, on the Governor's report or otherwise, that the government of a state cannot be carried on according to the Constitution, he or she may proclaim President's rule under Article 356. The proclamation must be approved by Parliament within two months; it lasts six months at first and can be extended in steps of six months, up to a maximum of three years, subject to conditions. While it lasts, the Governor administers the state for the President, the Vidhan Sabha may be suspended or dissolved, and Parliament makes the state's laws.

Worked example 1: assertion and reason

Assertion (A): Parliament can transfer an area from one state to another by ordinary law. Reason (R): a law under Article 3 is not an amendment under Article 368. Working: A is true (the 1956 transfer to West Bengal is the case). R is true and it is exactly why a simple majority is enough. So R explains A.

Worked example 2: two statements

Statement 1: the state legislature's view on an Article 3 bill binds Parliament. Statement 2: the bill needs the President's recommendation. Working: the views are heard but are not binding, so statement 1 is false. Statement 2 is true. Only statement 2 is correct.

Worked example 3: counting the maximum

Question: President's rule is imposed and extended every six months as far as the Constitution allows. How many extensions beyond the first six months are possible if the total may not exceed three years? Working: three years is 36 months. The first period is 6 months, leaving 30 months, which is 5 further extensions of 6 months. So at most 5 extensions, if all conditions are met.

Article 3: Parliament may change a state's area, boundaries or name; the state is heard, not obeyed. Article 356: two months to approve, three years at most.

Key takeaways: a state's area and name can be changed by Parliament under Article 3, with the President's recommendation and the state's views heard but not binding. Such a law is not an Article 368 amendment. Police and local government are state subjects. President's rule needs approval within two months and cannot go beyond three years.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Assertion (A): The Purulia area could be transferred to West Bengal by an Act of Parliament. Reason (R): a law under Article 3 needs the consent of both states concerned.

    1. Both A and R are true, and R explains A
    2. Both A and R are true, but R does not explain A
    3. A is true, but R is false
    4. A is false, but R is true
    Show answer

    Answer: C. A is true: the 1956 Act did it. R is false: the state's views are sought but are not binding, and no consent is needed.

  2. 2. Consider: 1. The President must recommend an Article 3 bill. 2. A state legislature's views are binding on Parliament. Which is correct?

    1. 2 only
    2. Both 1 and 2
    3. Neither 1 nor 2
    4. 1 only
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Statement 1 is true. Statement 2 is false, since Parliament may disregard the views.

  3. 3. A proclamation of President's rule must be approved by Parliament within:

    1. Two months
    2. One month
    3. Six months
    4. Three years
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Article 356 requires approval within two months; the maximum duration is three years.

  4. 4. Which of the following is a State List subject?

    1. Defence
    2. Police
    3. Foreign affairs
    4. Criminal law and procedure
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Police is on the State List. Defence and foreign affairs are Union subjects.

  5. 5. Consider: 1. A law under Article 3 is an amendment under Article 368. 2. Such a law may alter the name of a state. Which is correct?

    1. 1 only
    2. Both 1 and 2
    3. 2 only
    4. Neither 1 nor 2
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Article 4 says a law under Article 3 is not an Article 368 amendment, so statement 1 is false. Name change is within Article 3, so statement 2 is true.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery