- Foundation
- About 13 min
- 5 practice questions
The Governor, the Chief Minister and the Council of Ministers
Explain who heads the state government of West Bengal, how the Governor and the Chief Minister differ, and to whom the ministers are answerable.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
India is a union of states, and each state runs its own government under the Constitution. The Union has a President, a Prime Minister and a Council of Ministers. A state has a Governor, a Chief Minister and a Council of Ministers. This lesson explains the three, so that you can answer 'who appoints', 'who is the real head' and 'who is answerable to whom' questions about West Bengal.
The Governor
- The Constitution says there shall be a Governor for each state (Article 153), and that the executive power of the state is vested in the Governor (Article 154).
- The Governor is appointed by the President of India and holds office during the President's pleasure; the usual term is five years.
- The Governor must be an Indian citizen and at least 35 years old.
- The Governor is the constitutional (nominal) head of the state and acts, in most matters, on the advice of the Council of Ministers.
- The Governor appoints the Chief Minister, calls the Vidhan Sabha to meet, and gives or refuses assent to bills.
- The Governor's residence in Kolkata is called Raj Bhavan.
The Chief Minister
Under Article 164 the Governor appoints the Chief Minister, and appoints the other ministers on the Chief Minister's advice. In practice, after an election the Governor invites the leader of the party or group that has the support of a majority in the Vidhan Sabha. The Chief Minister is the real head of the government: he or she leads the Council of Ministers, shares out the departments among ministers and keeps the Governor informed of its decisions.
The Council of Ministers
The Council of Ministers aids and advises the Governor. Article 164 makes it collectively responsible to the Vidhan Sabha. 'Collectively' means the ministers sink or swim together: if the Vidhan Sabha loses confidence in the Council, the whole Council must resign, not just one minister. A minister who heads a department is also answerable for that department's work.
| Point | Governor | Chief Minister |
|---|---|---|
| Position | Nominal head | Real head of the government |
| How chosen | Appointed by the President | Appointed by the Governor; usually the leader of the majority |
| Answerable to | The President (holds office at his pleasure) | The Vidhan Sabha, which can remove the government |
| Term | Usually five years | As long as majority support lasts |
The state executive
- Governor Nominal head, appointed by the President
- Chief Minister Real head, backed by a majority in the Vidhan Sabha
- Council of Ministers Collectively responsible to the Vidhan Sabha
The permanent civil service
Ministers decide policy, but officers carry it out. The senior-most civil servant of the state is the Chief Secretary, who works with the secretaries of the departments in the state Secretariat. Ministers change after elections; the civil servants continue, which is why they are called the 'permanent executive'. Appointments to state services are handled by the West Bengal Public Service Commission, which is set up under Article 315.
Worked example 1: who is answerable to the Vidhan Sabha?
Question: the Governor, the Chief Minister, or the Council of Ministers: which is collectively responsible to the Vidhan Sabha? Working: Article 164 makes the Council of Ministers collectively responsible to the legislative assembly. The Governor is not elected and is not answerable to the assembly. So the answer is the Council of Ministers.
Worked example 2: a party with a majority
Question: after an election one party wins a clear majority. Whom does the Governor invite to form the government? Working: the Governor invites the person who can command the support of a majority of members, normally the leader chosen by the majority party. The Governor then appoints that person Chief Minister, who advises on the other ministers.
Worked example 3: nominal or real?
Question: who is the nominal head and who is the real head of the executive in a state? Working: the Governor, who is appointed by the President and acts on the advice of the ministers, is nominal. The Chief Minister, who has the majority behind him or her, takes the real decisions. So nominal = Governor; real = Chief Minister.
Governor: nominal head, appointed by the President. Chief Minister: real head, with a majority in the Vidhan Sabha.
Key takeaways: the Governor is appointed by the President and is the nominal head of the state. The Chief Minister, appointed by the Governor, leads the real government. The Council of Ministers is collectively responsible to the Vidhan Sabha. The Chief Secretary heads the permanent civil service, and the Public Service Commission recruits for state posts.
Check your understanding
-
1. Who appoints the Governor of West Bengal?
- The Chief Minister
- The Chief Justice
- The Speaker
- The President of India
Show answer
Answer: D. A Governor is appointed by the President and holds office during the President's pleasure.
-
2. Who is the real head of the state government?
- The Chief Minister
- The Governor
- The Chief Secretary
- The Speaker
Show answer
Answer: A. The Governor is the nominal head; the Chief Minister leads the Council of Ministers and takes the real decisions.
-
3. The Council of Ministers is collectively responsible to:
- The Governor alone
- The Vidhan Sabha
- The High Court
- The Public Service Commission
Show answer
Answer: B. Article 164 makes the Council collectively responsible to the legislative assembly.
-
4. What is the minimum age to be a Governor?
- 25 years
- 30 years
- 35 years
- 40 years
Show answer
Answer: C. A Governor must be an Indian citizen of at least 35 years.
-
5. The Governor appoints the Chief Minister. Whom does the Governor normally invite?
- The oldest member of the Vidhan Sabha
- The person chosen by the High Court
- Any minister of the previous government
- The leader who has the support of a majority in the Vidhan Sabha
Show answer
Answer: D. The Chief Minister must command a majority, so the Governor invites the leader who has that support.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.