- Practice
- About 13 min
- 5 practice questions
Courts and constitutional bodies: who appoints, who runs elections
Match each court and constitutional body of the state with its article and its appointing authority, and catch the swaps between President and Governor.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Most questions on the judiciary and constitutional bodies are matching questions: a body, an article, an appointing authority. They are easy if you hold a clear table, and expensive if you swap two entries. This lesson gives the table, a few memory hooks and the usual traps.
The appointment table
| Post | Appointed by | Article |
|---|---|---|
| Governor | President | 155 |
| Chief Minister | Governor | 164 |
| Advocate General | Governor | 165 |
| Chairman and members of the State Public Service Commission | Governor | 316 |
| High Court judges | President | 217 |
| District Judge | Governor, with the High Court | 233 |
| State Election Commissioner | Governor | 243K |
Look at the pattern. The Governor appoints the people who work inside the state: the Chief Minister, the Advocate General, the Commission members and district judges. The President appoints the Governor and the judges of the High Court, which are linked to the Union system. Remember the line: 'President for the top two; Governor for the rest.' The exception to watch is removal: a Public Service Commission member is appointed by the Governor but removed only by the President (Article 317), after an inquiry by the Supreme Court.
High Court articles
| Article | Subject |
|---|---|
| 214 | High Courts for the states |
| 215 | High Court is a court of record |
| 217 | Appointment and conditions of a judge |
| 226 | Power to issue writs |
| 227 | Power of superintendence over all courts |
| 231 | A common High Court for two or more states or a Union Territory may be set up |
| 233 | Appointment of district judges |
| 235 | Control over subordinate courts |
The Calcutta High Court, with its seat at Kolkata, has the Andaman and Nicobar Islands also under its authority, which is why a single High Court can serve more than one area. The retirement age of its judges is 62; the Supreme Court's is 65.
Climbing the ladder with an appeal
- Lower court A civil judge or a magistrate hears the case
- District court Appeal to the District or Sessions Judge
- Calcutta High Court Further appeal or revision
- Supreme Court Final appeal where allowed
Common traps
- High Court judges are not appointed by the Governor; the Governor is only consulted.
- The Chief Justice of the High Court is not the head of the state; the Governor is.
- Article 226 is wider than the Supreme Court's Article 32 because it is not limited to fundamental rights.
- The Public Service Commission recruits, but it does not make policy; the ministers do.
Worked example 1: the swap
Question: 'The Governor appoints the Chief Justice of the High Court.' True or false? Working: the Chief Justice and other High Court judges are appointed by the President under Article 217. So the statement is false. If it had said 'district judges', it would have been true.
Worked example 2: match the article
Question: which article lets a High Court issue writs? Working: Article 226. Article 227 is about supervision of courts; Article 235 is about control of subordinate courts. The writ power is 226.
Worked example 3: retirement ages
Question: a High Court judge was born on 5 May 1965. In which year does he retire, by age? Working: retirement is at 62. 1965 plus 62 is 2027. So he reaches 62 in 2027.
President: Governor and High Court judges. Governor: Chief Minister, Advocate General, district judges, Commission members, State Election Commissioner.
Key takeaways: President appoints the Governor and High Court judges; the Governor appoints the Chief Minister, Advocate General, district judges, State Public Service Commission members and the State Election Commissioner. Learn 214, 217, 226, 227, 233, 235. High Court judges retire at 62.
Check your understanding
-
1. Who appoints the Advocate General of West Bengal?
- The Governor
- The President
- The Chief Justice of the High Court
- The Speaker
Show answer
Answer: A. Article 165 says the Advocate General is appointed by the Governor.
-
2. Which article gives a High Court power of superintendence over all courts in its area?
- Article 214
- Article 227
- Article 226
- Article 217
Show answer
Answer: B. Article 227 is superintendence; Article 226 is the writ power.
-
3. A High Court judge born on 12 August 1966 retires, by age, in:
- 2026
- 2031
- 2028
- 2030
Show answer
Answer: C. Retirement is at 62; 1966 plus 62 is 2028.
-
4. Which of the following is correctly matched?
- Article 217 - district judges
- Article 233 - Chief Minister
- Article 164 - High Court
- Article 233 - district judges
Show answer
Answer: D. Article 233 deals with the appointment of district judges.
-
5. A member of the State Public Service Commission can be removed by:
- The President
- The Governor alone
- The Speaker
- The Chief Minister
Show answer
Answer: A. Article 317 provides that the President removes a Commission member after an inquiry and report by the Supreme Court.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.