• Foundation
  • About 14 min
  • 5 practice questions

Why France was in crisis: empty treasury, costly bread and new ideas

Explain the three big pressures before 1789 - the government's debt, the subsistence crisis and Enlightenment ideas - in simple words.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Unfair societies can last a long time. So why did France explode in 1789 and not earlier? Because three pressures came together at the same moment: the government ran out of money, ordinary people could not afford bread, and new ideas told them that things did not have to be this way.

Pressure 1: an empty treasury

When Louis XVI came to the throne, the treasury was already weighed down by long wars. France then helped the thirteen American colonies win their independence from Britain, its old rival. That war added a great deal to the debt. Lenders charged interest, so a large share of the government's income went just to pay interest. On top of this, the court at Versailles and the army were expensive to run.

The obvious answer was to raise taxes. But the clergy and the nobles were exempt, so new taxes could only fall on the Third Estate, which was already squeezed. The king's ministers proposed taxing the privileged groups too, and those groups resisted. The government was stuck.

Pressure 2: the price of bread

Bread was the main food of the poor. The population of France was growing, so the demand for grain grew faster than its supply. Bread prices rose, but wages did not keep pace. A poor harvest in 1788 made matters worse. When people cannot afford the basic means of living, historians call it a subsistence crisis. Hungry people in towns and villages were ready to riot.

Pressure 3: new ideas from the Enlightenment

In the 1700s, writers of the Enlightenment argued that reason, not custom or birth, should decide how society is run. Their books were discussed in salons and coffee-houses and spread through newspapers and pamphlets. The educated and wealthy members of the Third Estate - often called the middle class - read them eagerly, because these ideas said that privileges by birth were wrong.

Thinkers who shaped revolutionary ideas
ThinkerMain idea in simple words
John Locke (English)In *Two Treatises of Government* he rejected the divine and absolute right of kings; people have natural rights.
Jean-Jacques RousseauIn *The Social Contract* he argued that government rests on an agreement among the people and should follow the general will.
MontesquieuIn *The Spirit of the Laws* he proposed dividing power among the legislature, the executive and the judiciary.
VoltaireAttacked the intolerance of the Church and defended religious tolerance and freedom of thought.

Worked example 1: matching a thinker to an idea

Question: Which thinker is linked with the separation of powers? Working: the separation of powers means dividing government into law-making (legislature), law-executing (executive) and law-judging (judiciary) branches so that no single person holds all power. This idea comes from Montesquieu's The Spirit of the Laws. Answer: Montesquieu. A common mistake is to choose Rousseau; Rousseau's book is The Social Contract, about the general will.

Worked example 2: why the money crisis could not be solved

Question: Why could the king not simply tax the nobles and clergy? Working step by step: (1) the government needed more money; (2) the clergy and nobles were exempt from taxes to the state by long custom; (3) changing that meant taking away their privileges, and they refused; (4) the Third Estate was already overburdened. So the king had no easy way out, and he finally agreed to call an old assembly, the Estates-General, to approve new taxes. That decision opened the door to revolution.

Three pressures before 1789: debt (wars, including help to the American colonies), the subsistence crisis (dear bread, poor harvest of 1788) and Enlightenment ideas (Locke, Rousseau, Montesquieu, Voltaire).

  • Key takeaways: wars, including France's help to the American colonies against Britain, left the treasury deep in debt.
  • Rising population and a poor harvest in 1788 made bread too expensive - a subsistence crisis.
  • Enlightenment writers questioned privilege by birth and the absolute power of kings; the educated middle class spread these ideas.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which book did Jean-Jacques Rousseau write?

    1. The Spirit of the Laws
    2. Two Treatises of Government
    3. The Social Contract
    4. What is the Third Estate?
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Rousseau wrote The Social Contract, arguing that government rests on an agreement among the people. The Spirit of the Laws is by Montesquieu and Two Treatises of Government is by John Locke.

  2. 2. The idea of dividing power among the legislature, executive and judiciary is mainly linked with:

    1. Montesquieu
    2. Voltaire
    3. Rousseau
    4. Louis XVI
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Montesquieu proposed the separation of powers in The Spirit of the Laws.

  3. 3. A 'subsistence crisis' means a situation in which:

    1. The government cannot repay its loans
    2. The basic means of living, such as food, become too scarce or too costly for ordinary people
    3. The king loses a war
    4. Nobles refuse to pay feudal dues
    Show answer

    Answer: B. A subsistence crisis is when people cannot get the basic means of living. In France, rising bread prices and a poor harvest in 1788 created one.

  4. 4. Which war added greatly to France's debt before 1789?

    1. The First World War
    2. The war of the thirteen American colonies for independence from Britain
    3. The Battle of Waterloo
    4. The Napoleonic wars
    Show answer

    Answer: B. France helped the thirteen American colonies win independence from Britain, and the cost added heavily to its debt. Waterloo and the Napoleonic wars came after 1789.

  5. 5. Why could Louis XVI not easily raise money by taxing the clergy and nobility?

    1. They were exempt from taxes to the state by privilege and resisted losing that privilege
    2. They had no money at all
    3. The Church had already paid off all the debt
    4. Foreign kings had forbidden it
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The First and Second Estates were exempt from taxes to the state and refused to give up this privilege, so new taxes could only fall on the Third Estate.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery