• Advanced
  • About 18 min
  • 5 practice questions

Causes reconsidered: Versailles, the Depression, ideology and the appeasement debate

Weigh the long-term, short-term and immediate causes of World War II, judge the appeasement debate on both sides, and answer multi-statement questions on the war's origins.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

At the advanced level, questions on causes stop asking what happened and ask how much each factor mattered, or test you with statements that are half true. The skill is to separate long-term conditions, short-term causes and the immediate trigger, and to know the main arguments historians make about each.

Three layers of causation

LayerFactorsWhy it mattered
Long-term conditionsTreaty of Versailles; weakness of the League of Nations; the unsettled borders of central and eastern EuropeCreated grievances and left no strong system to settle disputes
Short-term causesGreat Depression from 1929; rise of Nazism, Fascism and Japanese militarism; appeasementTurned grievances into aggressive policy and let aggressors succeed step by step
Immediate triggerNazi-Soviet Pact (August 1939) and the invasion of Poland (1 September 1939)Removed Hitler's fear of a two-front war and brought the British and French guarantee to Poland into force

Versailles: harsh, but not crushing

Versailles humiliated Germany through the war guilt clause, reparations, disarmament and loss of territory. Yet historians often point out that it left Germany united, with a large population and industry, and therefore potentially the strongest power in central Europe once it recovered. Its terms were also enforced less and less as the years passed. So the treaty is better seen as a source of grievance that Hitler exploited than as a direct cause of war by itself.

The Depression and ideology

The Depression destroyed the fragile stability of the Weimar Republic: mass unemployment helped the Nazis become the largest party in the Reichstag, and Hitler became Chancellor in January 1933. Elsewhere, countries raised tariffs and turned inward, which hit trade-dependent Japan hard and strengthened those who argued that Japan needed an empire of its own. Ideology then shaped the aims. Nazism combined racial doctrine with the demand for "living space" (Lebensraum) in the east; Italian Fascism sought a Mediterranean and African empire; Japanese militarists spoke of a "New Order" in East Asia under Japanese leadership.

Why the League failed

  • It needed broad agreement to act, and had no armed force of its own.
  • The United States never joined; the Soviet Union joined only in 1934 and was expelled in 1939 after attacking Finland.
  • Japan and Germany left in 1933, and Italy in 1937, so the main aggressors were outside its reach.
  • Britain and France, its leading members, put their own interests and their fear of war first, as the weak sanctions on Italy over Abyssinia showed.

The appeasement debate

Arguments used for appeasement at the timeArguments of its critics
Memory of the slaughter of World War I and strong public desire for peaceEach concession convinced Hitler that Britain and France would not fight
Britain was not ready to fight and needed time to rearmMunich handed over Czechoslovakia's border defences and arms industry to Germany
Many felt Versailles had been unfair to GermanyExcluding the Soviet Union from Munich deepened Soviet distrust and helped lead to the Nazi-Soviet Pact
Fear of communism made some see Germany as a barrier against the Soviet UnionHitler's aims went far beyond correcting Versailles, as the occupation of Prague in March 1939 proved

Historians still disagree. A. J. P. Taylor, in his 1961 book The Origins of the Second World War, argued that Hitler was more of an opportunist than a planner following a blueprint; most historians since have given more weight to Nazi ideology and Hitler's long-held aims in the east.

Worked example 1: evaluate the statements

Statements: (1) The Nazi-Soviet Pact contained a secret protocol dividing eastern Europe into German and Soviet spheres. (2) The Soviet Union was a party to the Munich Agreement. (3) Germany left the League of Nations in 1933. Working: (1) is correct; the secret protocol divided Poland and assigned other areas, such as Estonia and Latvia, to the Soviet sphere. (2) is wrong; the Soviet Union was not invited to Munich. (3) is correct. Answer: 1 and 3 only.

Worked example 2: classify the cause

Question: Is the Great Depression a long-term condition, a short-term cause or the trigger? Working: it began in 1929, a decade before the war, and it acted by bringing the Nazis to power and pushing Japan towards expansion, which makes it a short-term cause that turned old grievances into aggressive policy. Answer: a short-term cause.

Versailles gave the grievance, the Depression gave the opportunity, ideology gave the aim, the League and appeasement gave the room, and the Nazi-Soviet Pact gave the moment.

Key takeaways: separate conditions, causes and trigger; treat Versailles as a grievance rather than a sufficient cause; link the Depression to both Nazism and Japanese expansion; know the arguments on both sides of appeasement and the secret protocol of the Nazi-Soviet Pact.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Consider the statements: 1. The United States never joined the League of Nations. 2. The Soviet Union was expelled from the League in 1939. 3. Italy was a founder member of the League and never left it. Which are correct?

    1. 1 only
    2. 1 and 2 only
    3. 2 and 3 only
    4. 1, 2 and 3
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Statements 1 and 2 are correct: the US never joined, and the Soviet Union was expelled in 1939 after attacking Finland. Statement 3 is wrong because Italy left the League in 1937.

  2. 2. Which of these is best described as the immediate trigger of World War II in Europe?

    1. The Treaty of Versailles
    2. The Great Depression
    3. The German invasion of Poland in September 1939
    4. Italy's invasion of Abyssinia
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The invasion of Poland on 1 September 1939 brought the British and French guarantee into force and started the war. Versailles was a long-term condition, the Depression a short-term cause, and Abyssinia an earlier failure of the League.

  3. 3. A critic of appeasement would most likely argue that the Munich Agreement:

    1. Gave Britain time to rearm
    2. Corrected an unfair part of Versailles
    3. Kept the Soviet Union in a firm alliance with Britain
    4. Handed Czechoslovakia's border defences to Germany and encouraged Hitler
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Critics argue that Munich gave Germany the Sudetenland's fortifications and Czech industry and convinced Hitler that Britain and France would not fight. Buying time to rearm was an argument used for appeasement.

  4. 4. The secret protocol of the Nazi-Soviet Pact of August 1939:

    1. Divided eastern Europe, including Poland, into German and Soviet spheres
    2. Made the Soviet Union a member of the Axis
    3. Promised Soviet help to Britain
    4. Returned Alsace-Lorraine to Germany
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The secret protocol divided eastern Europe into spheres of influence: Poland was to be split, and areas such as Estonia and Latvia were assigned to the Soviet sphere.

  5. 5. Which argument about the Treaty of Versailles is most often made by historians?

    1. It was so light that Germany had no grievance
    2. It angered Germany but left it united and able to recover its strength
    3. It permanently destroyed Germany's industry
    4. It was enforced more strictly every year
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Historians often note that Versailles humiliated Germany yet left it united, populous and industrial, so it could recover; enforcement also weakened over time.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery