• Practice
  • About 14 min
  • 5 practice questions

Policy makers: Khathing, Elwin and the Panchsheel

Practise questions on the people behind early frontier policy and learn a memory method for the five principles.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

The policy makers of the frontier appear in questions on the North-East Frontier Agency. Their facts are few, so exam questions tend to ask for them in many different wordings. This lesson shows how the wordings change and how to remember the Tribal Panchsheel.

By the end of this lesson you can:

  • Recognise the same fact in different wordings
  • Recall the five principles with a memory method
  • Separate an adviser, an officer and a Prime Minister

One fact, many wordings

The same fact asked three ways
FactWordings you may meet
Khathing reached Tawang in 1951'Who established Indian administration at Tawang?' / 'Which officer from Manipur led a party to Tawang?' / 'In 1951, Tawang was reached by whom?'
Elwin was Adviser for Tribal Affairs'Who advised the government on tribal policy for NEFA?' / 'Who wrote A Philosophy for NEFA?'
Nehru stated the Tribal Panchsheel'Whose five principles guided policy in tribal areas?'

When you read a question, translate it back to the fact. 'A Manipur officer' means Khathing. 'An anthropologist' or 'an adviser' means Elwin. 'The Prime Minister' means Nehru. Do this translation before looking at the options.

Remembering the Tribal Panchsheel

The five principles can be learned as five key words: genius, rights, train, light, character. Genius stands for developing along their own lines. Rights stands for land and forest. Train stands for training their own people. Light stands for light administration, that is, not over-administered. Character stands for judging results by the quality of human character, not by money spent. The first letters spell GRTLC, which you can pronounce as a nonsense word: 'Gert-lick'.

The five principles in order

  1. Genius Develop along their own lines
  2. Rights Respect rights in land and forests
  3. Train Train their own people to run administration
  4. Light Do not over-administer
  5. Character Judge by human character, not money spent
Genius, Rights, Train, Light, Character

Adviser, officer, Prime Minister

It helps to make a small list of what each person did not do. Khathing did not write the policy; he went to Tawang and set up administration. Elwin did not lead the party to Tawang; he advised and wrote. Nehru did not run the agency's daily affairs; he stated the principles. The questions that confuse students often attribute one person's act to another.

Worked example 1: a new wording

Question: 'The officer from Manipur who established Indian administration at Tawang in 1951 was?' Working: officer from Manipur and Tawang give Khathing. Answer: Major Bob Khathing.

Worked example 2: the principle

Question: 'Which Tribal Panchsheel principle warns against too many schemes and rules?' Working: 'too many' maps to the 'Light' key word: the area should not be over-administered. Answer: that the area should not be over-administered.

Worked example 3: wrong attribution

Question: 'Verrier Elwin led the administrative party that reached Tawang in 1951.' True or false? Working: that act belongs to Khathing. Elwin was the adviser and author. Answer: false.

Another useful habit is to write the three people on a small card with one line each, and test yourself on the card while walking or waiting. Short repeated tests are more effective than a long single reading. When you meet a new mock question on these people, do not just check the answer; ask which of the three people the question was really about, and which wording it used. After ten such questions you will start to recognise the patterns before reading the options.

Genius, Rights, Train, Light, Character: the five words of the Tribal Panchsheel.

— Memory method

Key takeaways: translate each question back to a basic fact. Khathing, Tawang and 1951 go together; Elwin, adviser and A Philosophy for NEFA go together; Nehru and the Tribal Panchsheel go together. Use the five key words to recall the principles.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. An anthropologist who advised NEFA on tribal affairs was?

    1. Verrier Elwin
    2. Bob Khathing
    3. Henry McMahon
    4. Adam White
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Elwin was an anthropologist and Adviser for Tribal Affairs.

  2. 2. Which principle matches the key word 'Light'?

    1. Tribal land should be sold
    2. Outsiders should run the administration
    3. The area should not be over-administered
    4. Results are judged by money spent
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Light stands for light administration, the principle that the area should not be over-administered.

  3. 3. Who established Indian administration at Tawang in 1951?

    1. Verrier Elwin
    2. Jawaharlal Nehru
    3. Bob Khathing
    4. Noel Williamson
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Khathing led the party that reached Tawang.

  4. 4. How many principles are there in the Tribal Panchsheel?

    1. Five
    2. Three
    3. Seven
    4. Ten
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Panchsheel means five principles.

  5. 5. Which statement is false?

    1. Elwin was Adviser for Tribal Affairs
    2. Khathing came from Manipur
    3. Nehru stated the Tribal Panchsheel
    4. Nehru wrote A Philosophy for NEFA
    Show answer

    Answer: D. A Philosophy for NEFA was written by Verrier Elwin, not by Nehru.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery