- Practice
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Tradition or record? Legends, officers and the McMahon Line
Learn how to answer questions that say 'according to tradition', and practise on the legendary figures and the frontier officers.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Some questions on personalities use words such as 'according to tradition' or 'it is believed'. These signal that the answer comes from a legend and not from a written record. If you understand the difference, you will choose the right answer even when you do not recall the exact name.
By the end of this lesson you can:
- Tell a question about tradition from one about a record
- Match each legendary figure with the right site
- Answer statement questions on Adam White, Williamson and McMahon
Tradition and record
Two kinds of fact
-
Tradition
- Handed down in stories
- Signalled by 'according to tradition'
- Bhishmaka, Rukmini, Krishna, Parashurama
-
Record
- Fixed by a date and a document
- Signalled by a year
- White 1839, Williamson 1911, McMahon 1913-14
| Tradition says | Site |
|---|---|
| Bhishmaka's capital | Bhismaknagar, near Roing |
| Krishna and Rukmini rested | Malinithan, near Likabali |
| Parashurama freed from sin | Parshuram Kund, Lohit river |
| Malini means garland maker | Name of Malinithan |
A question that says 'which site is linked with Rukmini's father?' wants Bhismaknagar. One that says 'where did Krishna and Rukmini rest?' wants Malinithan. The two questions use the same family of names but ask about different places. Always ask whether the person in the question is the father, the couple or the sage.
Frontier officers: three questions to ask
For White, Williamson and McMahon, ask three questions: When? Where? What followed? White: 1839, Sadiya, a Khamti attack. Williamson: 1911, the Adi hills, the expedition of 1911-12. McMahon: 1913-14, the Simla conference, the line named after him. Only one of the three is a person killed in a clash with Adis, only one a person whose name is on a boundary line. Most wrong options fail one of these three tests.
Statement questions
Statement questions usually combine a correct name with a wrong detail. 'Noel Williamson was killed at Sadiya in 1839' joins Williamson's name with White's place and date. 'The McMahon Line was drawn at Tawang' joins McMahon with a wrong place; the line was agreed at the Simla conference. 'Parashurama rested at Malinithan' joins a sage with a site meant for Krishna and Rukmini. In each case the fault lies in one detail. Find it by testing the name against its own date or place.
Worked example 1: tradition question
Question: 'According to tradition, where did Krishna and Rukmini rest on their way?' Working: the signal words are 'according to tradition'; Bhismaknagar is her father's capital, and the resting place is Malinithan. Answer: Malinithan, near Likabali.
Worked example 2: the faulty statement
Question: 'Adam White was killed in 1911 in the Adi hills.' True or false? Working: White was killed in 1839 at Sadiya. The date and place belong to Williamson and the Adi hills. Answer: false.
Worked example 3: record question
Question: 'Where was the boundary named after Henry McMahon agreed?' Working: a record question with a year, 1913-14. The conference was held at Simla. Answer: at the Simla conference of 1913-14.
Tradition = story and site. Record = year, place and event.
Key takeaways: read signal words to tell tradition from record. Bhishmaka goes with Bhismaknagar, Krishna and Rukmini with Malinithan and Parashurama with Parshuram Kund. For British officers ask when, where and what followed. In statement questions, find the one detail that belongs to another person.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which site is linked by tradition with the father of Rukmini?
- Malinithan
- Bhismaknagar
- Parshuram Kund
- Sadiya
Show answer
Answer: B. Bhismaknagar is identified with the capital of King Bhishmaka, the father of Rukmini.
-
2. Where do pilgrims bathe at Makar Sankranti?
- Parshuram Kund
- Malinithan
- Bhismaknagar
- Jaswantgarh
Show answer
Answer: A. Pilgrims bathe at Parshuram Kund on the Lohit river at Makar Sankranti.
-
3. Which statement is false?
- Adam White was killed in 1839
- The McMahon Line comes from the Simla conference
- Noel Williamson was killed at Sadiya in 1839
- Williamson's death led to the expedition of 1911-12
Show answer
Answer: C. That date and place belong to Adam White; Williamson was killed in the Adi hills in 1911.
-
4. The signal words 'according to tradition' show that the answer is likely to be about?
- A date in a treaty
- A legend
- A boundary line
- A gallantry award
Show answer
Answer: B. They signal a story handed down, not a written record.
-
5. Malinithan gets its name from?
- A British officer
- A Dalai Lama
- A river
- 'Malini', a garland maker
Show answer
Answer: D. The name comes from 'malini', a garland maker, from the tradition of the goddess offering garlands.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.