- Practice
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Term deposit problems: premature closure, payout versus cumulative and comparing offers
Calculate the money received when a term deposit is closed early, compare payout and cumulative deposits, and rank offers with different compounding.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
The earlier practice lesson on deposits dealt with CASA and reserves. This one deals with the term deposit itself, where exam questions ask for the amount on early closure, the monthly payout and which of two offers is better. As in the other lessons, all rates and amounts are invented ('suppose').
Premature closure
A depositor who closes a term deposit before maturity is usually paid at the rate for the period that the deposit actually ran, reduced by a penalty of some percentage points. Method: (1) find the period actually run, (2) take the rate for that period, (3) subtract the penalty, (4) apply the reduced rate for the period run only. The trap is applying the original higher rate, or applying the penalty to the amount instead of to the rate.
Cumulative and payout deposits
In a cumulative (reinvestment) deposit, interest is added to the deposit and paid together with the principal at maturity, so interest earns interest. In a payout deposit, interest is paid out at regular intervals, such as every month, and the principal stays unchanged. A payout deposit gives regular income but, because the interest is not reinvested, a smaller total over the full term than a cumulative one at the same rate.
Comparing offers
Offers with different compounding cannot be compared by looking at the quoted rate alone. Convert each to an amount (or a multiple of the principal) over the same period and compare those. More frequent compounding gives a higher effective return at the same quoted rate.
Worked examples
Example 1. Suppose a deposit of ₹1,00,000 is made for 3 years and closed after 2 years. Suppose the rate for a 2-year deposit is 6.5% compounded yearly and the penalty is 1 percentage point. Find the amount received and the cost of the penalty. Reduced rate = 6.5 - 1 = 5.5%. Amount = 1,00,000 x 1.055 x 1.055 = ₹1,11,302.50. Without the penalty it would be 1,00,000 x 1.065 x 1.065 = ₹1,13,422.50. The penalty costs 1,13,422.50 - 1,11,302.50 = ₹2,120.
Example 2. Suppose ₹6,00,000 is placed at 6% a year. Compare a monthly payout deposit with a cumulative deposit (compounded quarterly) over 1 year. Payout: monthly interest = 6,00,000 x 6 ÷ 100 ÷ 12 = ₹3,000, so ₹36,000 in the year. Cumulative: quarterly rate 1.5%, amount = 6,00,000 x 1.015^4 = ₹6,36,818.13 (rounded), interest ₹36,818.13. The cumulative deposit earns ₹818.13 more, but the payout gives cash every month.
Example 3. Suppose offer A pays 6.5% a year compounded yearly and offer B pays 6.4% compounded quarterly, both for 2 years on ₹1,00,000. Which is better? A: 1.065^2 = 1.134225, amount ₹1,13,422.50. B: quarterly rate 1.6%, 8 quarters, 1.016^8 = 1.1354, amount about ₹1,13,540. B is better by about ₹118, even though its quoted rate is lower, because it compounds four times a year.
Early closure: rate for the period run, minus penalty, applied for the period run. Compare offers by their amounts, not their quoted rates.
Key takeaways. Reduce the rate, not the amount, for the penalty. Payout deposits pay interest out; cumulative deposits reinvest it. Quoted rates with different compounding must be compared by converting to amounts. Check your answer by comparing it with simple interest as a rough bound.
Check your understanding
-
1. A depositor closes early. The bank pays at the rate for the period run:
- Plus a small bonus
- Minus a penalty
- The original rate
- Twice the rate
Show answer
Answer: B. The usual rule is the rate for the period actually run less a penalty.
-
2. ₹2,00,000 earns 7% a year, but on early closure the rate is cut by 1 point. For one year of simple interest, the loss is:
- ₹4,000
- ₹1,000
- ₹2,000
- ₹7,000
Show answer
Answer: C. 1% of ₹2,00,000 = ₹2,000.
-
3. Monthly payout on ₹4,80,000 at 6% a year is:
- ₹2,400
- ₹28,800
- ₹4,800
- ₹240
Show answer
Answer: A. Yearly interest = 4,80,000 x 0.06 = ₹28,800; monthly = ₹2,400.
-
4. Offer A: 8% compounded yearly. Offer B: 7.9% compounded quarterly. Which gives the greater return over a year?
- A
- They are exactly equal
- Cannot be said
- B
Show answer
Answer: D. B: (1 + 0.079 ÷ 4)^4 = 1.0814, which is a return of about 8.14%, above A's 8%.
-
5. In a cumulative deposit, interest is:
- Paid out every month
- Added and paid at maturity
- Never paid to anyone
- Paid only to a nominee
Show answer
Answer: B. A cumulative deposit reinvests interest so that it is paid with the principal at maturity.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.