- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Direct Benefit Transfer in practice: steps, failures and savings
Lay out the steps of a Direct Benefit Transfer, compute amounts credited and returned when some transfers fail, and estimate the saving from removing duplicate beneficiaries.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Direct Benefit Transfer questions test whether you know the chain of steps and can do simple arithmetic about payments that succeed, fail or should never have been made. This lesson walks through the chain, the common failure points and the calculations. All figures are invented.
The chain of a direct transfer
- Identify the beneficiary under the scheme's rules (done by the department, not by the bank).
- Verify identity and remove duplicates, often using a unique identity number.
- Link the beneficiary to a bank account.
- Transfer: the department's bank sends the amount electronically to the beneficiary's account.
- Credit and access: the money reaches the account and the beneficiary withdraws or spends it, through a branch, ATM, business correspondent or phone.
The idea is often summed up as JAM: Jan Dhan accounts, Aadhaar identity and mobile phones, three pieces of infrastructure that together make direct transfers possible at scale. Each piece answers one link: an account to receive money, an identity to make sure the right person gets it, and a phone to know about it and use it.
Where transfers go wrong
- Wrong or closed account details: the payment fails and is returned to the paying department, to be corrected and sent again.
- Duplicate or fake beneficiaries: money goes to people who should not get it, unless they are removed at verification.
- Last-mile access: the money arrives but the person cannot easily withdraw it, which is why agents near home matter.
DBT moves money straight to an identified person's account. It does not decide who is eligible; it delivers to those already identified. Failed transfers return to the payer; duplicates are a saving only if removed before payment.
Direct transfers change the incentives along the chain. Under older methods, benefits often passed through several hands before reaching the beneficiary, and each hand was a chance for delay or deduction. With an electronic credit, the amount that leaves the department is the amount that arrives in the account, and every payment leaves a record that can be checked. The remaining weak points move to the two ends of the chain: making sure the right people are on the list at the start, and making sure they can reach their money at the end.
Worked example 1: a first payment run
Suppose 2,000 beneficiaries are each due ₹1,500. In the first run, 4% of transfers fail because of wrong account details. How much is credited, and how much is returned? Working: failed = 4% of 2,000 = 80; successful = 1,920. Credited = 1,920 × 1,500 = ₹28,80,000. Returned = 80 × 1,500 = ₹1,20,000. Answer: ₹28,80,000 credited and ₹1,20,000 returned, to be paid again once the details are corrected. Trap: the returned money is not 'lost'; it goes back to the department.
Worked example 2: savings from cleaning the list
Suppose a list has 5,000 names, and verification finds 250 duplicate or fake entries. The benefit is ₹600 a month. How much is saved in a year by removing them? Working: monthly saving = 250 × 600 = ₹1,50,000. Yearly = 1,50,000 × 12 = ₹18,00,000. Answer: ₹18,00,000 a year.
Speed tip for percentages. For 'what share failed' questions, work with the count of beneficiaries first and multiply by the benefit last: 4% of 2,000 is 80 people, and 80 × 1,500 is quick. Doing it the other way round, 4% of ₹30,00,000, gives the same answer but invites a slip with zeros. Also check whether the question asks for the amount credited or returned; options usually include both.
Last-mile access deserves a moment's thought: a benefit that has reached an account but cannot be withdrawn without a long journey has only partly arrived. This is where the channels of lesson 2 meet DBT, since agents near home let beneficiaries draw the money without losing a day's wages.
Statements to judge
- 'DBT decides who is eligible for a scheme.' False: eligibility is set by the scheme; DBT delivers.
- 'DBT needs beneficiaries to have bank accounts.' True: this is why inclusion and DBT support each other.
- 'DBT means paying cash at the village office.' False: it is an electronic credit to the account.
- 'A failed transfer is gone for good.' False: it returns and can be sent again.
Key takeaways: DBT runs identify, verify, link, transfer, credit and access; JAM names the three supports; failed transfers return to the payer; removing duplicates before payment is where the saving comes from; and DBT delivers benefits but does not decide eligibility.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which step of Direct Benefit Transfer removes duplicate or fake beneficiaries?
- The electronic transfer itself
- The beneficiary's withdrawal at an ATM
- Identity verification before payment
- The return of failed payments
Show answer
Answer: C. Duplicates are caught when identities are verified, before money is sent.
-
2. Suppose 3,000 beneficiaries are each due ₹800 and 5% of transfers fail on wrong account details. How much is credited in the first run?
- ₹22,80,000
- ₹24,00,000
- ₹1,20,000
- ₹22,00,000
Show answer
Answer: A. Failed = 5% of 3,000 = 150; successful = 2,850. Credited = 2,850 × 800 = ₹22,80,000.
-
3. What happens to a direct transfer that fails because the account number is wrong?
- It is lost permanently
- It is kept by the beneficiary's bank as a fee
- It is paid to the nearest business correspondent
- It is returned to the paying department and can be sent again once corrected
Show answer
Answer: D. Failed credits come back to the payer, who corrects the details and pays again.
-
4. Suppose verification removes 400 fake names from a list for a benefit of ₹500 a month. How much is saved in a year?
- ₹2,00,000
- ₹24,00,000
- ₹20,00,000
- ₹4,80,000
Show answer
Answer: B. Monthly = 400 × 500 = ₹2,00,000; yearly = 2,00,000 × 12 = ₹24,00,000.
-
5. Which statement about DBT is correct?
- It decides which people are eligible for a scheme
- It pays benefits in cash at a government office
- It works without beneficiaries having bank accounts
- It delivers benefits electronically to accounts of people the scheme has already identified
Show answer
Answer: D. DBT is a delivery method: electronic credit to the accounts of identified beneficiaries.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.