• Practice
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

Informal against formal credit: comparing the true cost of a loan

Work out how much a borrower actually receives, convert monthly or weekly rates to a yearly basis, and add fees and travel to compare a moneylender with a bank.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

A borrower who compares only the headline rate can choose the wrong loan. The right comparison asks two questions: how much money do I actually receive, and how much do I pay in all? This lesson turns those questions into steps and applies them to a moneylender and a bank. All figures are invented for practice.

Receive, repay and cost

  • Money received = amount lent − anything deducted at the start, such as advance interest or a fee.
  • Money repaid = what the borrower must pay back in total.
  • Cost of the loan = money repaid − money received, plus any extra costs such as travel or lost wages.

Interest taken at the start is a trap. If ₹5,000 is lent but ₹300 is taken off at once, the borrower receives only ₹4,700 but must repay the full ₹5,000. The ₹300 is then charged on money the borrower never had.

Converting to a yearly basis

Rates quoted by the week or month must be turned into a yearly rate before they are compared with a bank's rate. With simple interest: yearly rate = monthly rate × 12, or weekly rate × 52. When money is deducted at the start, work out the rate on the amount actually received.

Cost of a loan = repaid − received. Yearly rate = cost ÷ received × (periods in a year ÷ periods of the loan) × 100.

Worked example 1: advance interest

A moneylender lends ₹5,000 but deducts ₹300 at once, and the borrower repays ₹5,000 after 10 weeks. What does the borrower receive, what does the loan cost, and what is the approximate simple yearly rate? Working: received = 5,000 − 300 = ₹4,700. Repaid = ₹5,000. Cost = 5,000 − 4,700 = ₹300. For 10 weeks the rate on the money received is 300 ÷ 4,700 × 100 = 6.38%. A year has 52 weeks, so the yearly rate is about 6.38 × 52 ÷ 10 = 33.2% simple. The loan looked like 'only ₹300 for ten weeks', but it is an expensive loan over a year.

Worked example 2: moneylender against bank

Ramesh needs ₹20,000 for a year. A moneylender charges 3% a month simple interest. A bank charges 12% a year simple interest, a processing fee of 1% of the loan and requires 4 trips costing ₹150 each in travel and lost work. Compare the costs. Working: moneylender: interest = 20,000 × 3 ÷ 100 = ₹600 a month, so 600 × 12 = ₹7,200. Bank: interest = 20,000 × 12 ÷ 100 = ₹2,400; fee = 20,000 × 1 ÷ 100 = ₹200; travel = 4 × 150 = ₹600. Total = 2,400 + 200 + 600 = ₹3,200. The bank is cheaper by 7,200 − 3,200 = ₹4,000, even after counting the paperwork and travel. The bank's advantage is that it also builds a repayment record, and it is regulated.

What the comparison does not show

Cost is not everything. The moneylender gives money quickly, without documents, and in an emergency this matters. But a family that always borrows in emergencies from the costliest source stays poor. Inclusion aims to make a cheap formal source as quick and easy to reach as the moneylender, for example through agents, small loans and savings records. Another danger is daily or weekly collection at the doorstep, which feels light but adds up to a high rate, and a borrower who is late may be pressed hard. Regulated lenders are required to follow fair practices in recovery.

Traps

  • Using the amount lent, rather than the amount received, as the base for the rate.
  • Comparing a monthly rate with a yearly rate without converting.
  • Leaving out fees, travel and lost wages from the bank's cost.
  • Choosing a loan only for its speed without asking about the total repayment.

Key takeaways: find the money actually received and the total repaid; the difference is the cost; convert weekly and monthly rates to a yearly basis; include fees and travel for a fair comparison; the cheapest source may still not be the quickest, which is why inclusion aims to make formal credit easy to reach.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. A lender gives ₹8,000 but deducts ₹400 at the start (invented). How much does the borrower receive?

    1. ₹8,400
    2. ₹7,600
    3. ₹8,000
    4. ₹400
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Received = 8,000 − 400 = ₹7,600, though the borrower must repay ₹8,000.

  2. 2. A moneylender charges 5% a month simple interest. What is the yearly simple rate?

    1. 5%
    2. 12%
    3. 60%
    4. 17%
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Yearly rate = 5% × 12 = 60%.

  3. 3. A bank charges 12% a year on ₹15,000, a fee of 1% and travel of ₹400 in all (invented). What is the total cost for one year?

    1. ₹1,800
    2. ₹1,950
    3. ₹2,200
    4. ₹2,350
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Interest = ₹1,800; fee = 15,000 × 1% = ₹150; travel = ₹400. Total = 1,800 + 150 + 400 = ₹2,350.

  4. 4. A moneylender charges 4% a month simple interest on ₹15,000 for a year. How much more is that than the bank cost of ₹2,350 above?

    1. ₹4,850
    2. ₹5,400
    3. ₹4,200
    4. ₹7,200
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Moneylender interest = 15,000 × 4 ÷ 100 × 12 = ₹7,200. The difference = 7,200 − 2,350 = ₹4,850.

  5. 5. When advance interest is deducted, on which amount should the rate be worked out for a fair comparison?

    1. The amount actually received
    2. The amount that was advertised
    3. The total of all fees
    4. The average of both amounts
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The borrower only has the amount received, so the cost should be measured against that amount, not the amount advertised.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery