• Practice
  • About 14 min
  • 5 practice questions

Assertion and reason, and matching: a mixed grievance drill

Answer assertion-and-reason and matching questions on bank complaints by testing each part on its own and then asking whether the reason really explains the assertion.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Two formats appear again and again in competitive exams: assertion and reason, and matching. Both look different from plain multiple-choice questions, but the method is the same. Break the question into parts, test each part against what you know, and only then judge the connection. Rupee figures here are invented. Real schemes set their own time periods and limits, which can change.

How an assertion-and-reason question works

You are given an assertion (A), a claim, and a reason (R), a second claim that is offered as its explanation. The answer options are almost always the same four:

  • Both A and R are true, and R explains A.
  • Both A and R are true, but R does not explain A.
  • A is true, but R is false.
  • A is false, but R is true.

The method has three steps. Decide whether A is true. Decide whether R is true. If both are true, ask the 'because' test: put the word because between them and see if the sentence is a real explanation. 'The ombudsman asks the bank first because the scheme expects the bank to have its chance' passes. 'The sky is blue because banks open at ten' fails.

Matching questions

In a matching question you pair items in two lists. Do not start at the top of list one. Start with the pair you are surest of and cross it out. Each correct pair removes options, and the last pair is then free.

Pairs worth knowing
SituationLikely match
Complaint not yet made to the bankGate 1: bank first
Case pending in a consumer forumGate 3: no parallel case
Loan refused after assessing incomeCommercial judgement, not a deficiency
Customer told a product was compulsory with a loanMis-selling, and the right to choose
Appeal against an ombudsman's decisionAppellate authority within the RBI

Worked examples

Example 1. (A) A matter pending before a consumer commission cannot be taken to the ombudsman. (R) The ombudsman is a higher body than the commission. A is true: it fails the no-parallel-case gate. R is false, because the ombudsman is a separate route and is not above the commission. So A is true but R is false.

Example 2. (A) A customer should first complain to the bank. (R) The scheme expects the bank to be given a chance to resolve the complaint before the ombudsman steps in. Both are true. The because test works: the customer complains to the bank first because the scheme expects the bank to have its chance. So both are true and R explains A.

Example 3. Match: (1) disclosed fee applied as disclosed, (2) delayed credit beyond the bank's own policy, (3) undisclosed charge, with (p) deficiency: payments, (q) deficiency: charges, (r) not a deficiency. Start with the surest: (2) is p. Then (3) is q, an undisclosed charge. That leaves (1) with r, since a disclosed term applied as disclosed is not a deficiency. Answer: 1-r, 2-p, 3-q. Arriving at the last pair by elimination avoids a careless slip.

Test A. Test R. If both are true, put 'because' between them. Match the surest pair first.

Traps

  • Two true statements are not automatically cause and effect: 'both true, R explains A' needs the because test.
  • An absolute word (always, only, never) in A or R often makes it false.
  • A reason can be true as a fact and still not explain the assertion; that is option two.

Key takeaways. Judge A and R separately, then judge the link. In matching, begin with the pair you know best. Reduce long scenarios to the gates, the families of complaint and the appeal path.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. (A) The ombudsman is appointed by the Reserve Bank. (R) The ombudsman scheme is run by the Reserve Bank. Which option is correct?

    1. A is true, but R is false
    2. Both are true, but R does not explain A
    3. A is false, but R is true
    4. Both are true, and R explains A
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The scheme is run by the Reserve Bank, and that is why the appointment is made by it. R explains A.

  2. 2. (A) A bank employee who finds an unauthorised debit in his own savings account can complain as a customer. (R) A complaint about the employee's promotion is a customer complaint. Which option is correct?

    1. A is true, but R is false
    2. Both are true, and R explains A
    3. A is false, but R is true
    4. Both are true, but R does not explain A
    Show answer

    Answer: A. As an ordinary customer the employee has a valid complaint, so A is true. A promotion dispute is an employment matter, not a customer complaint, so R is false.

  3. 3. Which pair is matched correctly?

    1. Appeal against an award with the consumer commission
    2. Case pending in a court with the first gate
    3. Undisclosed charge with a charges complaint
    4. Loan refusal after assessment with a deficiency
    Show answer

    Answer: C. An undisclosed charge belongs to the charges family. A pending court case is the third gate, and an appeal against an award goes to the RBI's appellate authority.

  4. 4. In an assertion-and-reason question, what does the 'because' test check?

    1. Whether A is true
    2. Whether R really explains A
    3. Whether R is true
    4. Whether the options are in order
    Show answer

    Answer: B. After you decide that both are true, the because test checks whether R is a real explanation of A, which separates 'R explains A' from 'R does not explain A'.

  5. 5. (A) The ombudsman is the first step in every complaint. (R) The bank is the first step. Which option is correct?

    1. A is false, but R is true
    2. A is true, but R is false
    3. Both are true, but R does not explain A
    4. Both are true, and R explains A
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The bank is the first step, so R is true. A claims the ombudsman is first, which is false. So A is false and R is true.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery