- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Is the complaint maintainable? The four-gate test
Decide quickly whether the RBI's ombudsman can take a complaint, using four gates: bank first, bank failed, no parallel case, and a subject within the scheme.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Many exam questions describe a customer and ask whether the ombudsman can take the complaint, or which of several complaints it can take. 'Maintainable' means the complaint is of a kind the scheme will hear. Instead of memorising a long list, pass each case through four gates. Rupee figures here are invented and marked "suppose". Real schemes set their own waiting periods and other details, which can change, so this course says "within the time the scheme allows" rather than quoting numbers; an exam question that gives a number expects you to use it.
The four gates
- Gate 1: bank first. Did the customer complain to the bank (or other regulated entity) first?
- Gate 2: bank failed. Did the bank reject it wholly or partly, reply unsatisfactorily, or not reply within the time the scheme allows? And is the customer coming within the time the scheme allows?
- Gate 3: no parallel case. Is the same matter free of any pending or decided case in a court, tribunal, arbitration or consumer forum, and not already decided by the ombudsman on the same grounds?
- Gate 4: right subject. Is it a deficiency in service, rather than the bank's commercial judgement or an employment dispute between the bank and its staff?
A complaint is maintainable only if it passes all four gates. Exams test each gate with a typical story: the customer who goes straight to the ombudsman (gate 1), the customer who complains to the ombudsman the day after writing to the bank (gate 2), the customer who already filed in a consumer commission (gate 3), and the customer upset that a loan was refused after assessment (gate 4).
Gate 4 in more detail
The line between commercial judgement and service is the subtle one. A bank may decide, after assessing an applicant, not to lend: that is commercial judgement. But if the bank never acknowledged the application, ignored its own published process or charged a processing fee it had not disclosed, those are service matters. Similarly, an employee's complaint about promotion is an employment dispute; but a bank employee who, as an ordinary customer, finds an unauthorised debit in his own savings account has a customer complaint like anyone else.
Maintainable = bank first + bank failed (within the time the scheme allows) + no parallel case + a deficiency in service. Fail any gate and the ombudsman will not take it.
Worked example 1: four customers
(a) Asha wrote to her bank about an unexplained debit; the bank rejected her complaint; she then went to the ombudsman. All gates pass: maintainable. (b) Bilal went to the ombudsman first without writing to his bank: gate 1 fails. (c) Charu's case on the same debit is pending in the district consumer commission: gate 3 fails. (d) Dev says the bank's decision to refuse his loan after assessing his income was unfair: gate 4 fails. Only Asha's complaint is maintainable.
Worked example 2: a split complaint
Suppose Esha complains that her bank (i) refused her a top-up loan after assessing her income and (ii) deducted a ₹1,500 'appraisal charge' that it had never disclosed, and refused to refund it when she complained. Part (i) is commercial judgement and fails gate 4. Part (ii) is a deficiency in service that passes all gates. So the part the ombudsman can consider concerns the ₹1,500 charge, not the loan refusal. Exams reward candidates who split such a complaint instead of accepting or rejecting it whole.
Speed method
Read the story looking for the gate words. 'Directly', 'without informing the bank': gate 1. 'The next day', 'immediately': gate 2. 'Already filed', 'pending', 'decided by': gate 3. 'After assessing', 'refused the loan', 'promotion', 'transfer': gate 4. One gate word usually decides the question.
Key takeaways
Use the four gates in order. The ombudsman checks service, not business decisions. A bank employee can still complain as a customer. Split a mixed complaint into its parts and test each.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which complaint passes all four gates?
- A customer complained to her bank about an unexplained debit, the bank rejected it, and she has no case elsewhere
- A customer went straight to the ombudsman without telling the bank
- A customer's case on the same matter is pending in a consumer commission
- A customer says the bank's loan refusal after credit assessment was unfair
Show answer
Answer: A. Only the customer whose complaint about an unexplained debit the bank rejected, with no case elsewhere, has a bank complaint, a bank failure, no parallel case and a service deficiency.
-
2. A bank clerk finds an unauthorised debit in his own savings account at the bank, complains to the bank, and is refused. Can the ombudsman take it?
- No, because all complaints by bank employees are employment disputes
- No, because employees cannot hold accounts
- Only if a consumer commission refers it
- Yes, because he complains as a customer about a service deficiency
Show answer
Answer: D. The exclusion covers employment disputes. An unauthorised debit to his own account is an ordinary customer complaint.
-
3. Which gate does this fail? 'Suresh wrote to his bank on Monday and, without waiting for any reply, complained to the ombudsman on Tuesday.'
- Gate 1: he never complained to the bank
- Gate 2: the bank has not yet failed or had the time the scheme allows
- Gate 3: there is a parallel court case
- Gate 4: it is commercial judgement
Show answer
Answer: B. He did complain to the bank, but the bank has not rejected it or stayed silent beyond the time the scheme allows.
-
4. A complaint mixes a loan refusal after assessment with an undisclosed ₹1,500 charge that the bank refused to refund. Which part can the ombudsman consider?
- The ₹1,500 charge only
- The loan refusal only
- Both parts
- Neither part
Show answer
Answer: A. The refusal is commercial judgement (gate 4 fails); the undisclosed charge is a service deficiency that passes all gates.
-
5. Which phrase in a question most likely signals gate 3?
- 'refused the loan after assessing his income'
- 'without informing the bank'
- 'already decided by the consumer commission'
- 'the very next day'
Show answer
Answer: C. A matter already decided by a forum fails gate 3. The other phrases point to gates 4, 1 and 2.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.