• Practice
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

Is the claim payable? A case drill on lapse, disclosure and exclusions

Decide whether a claim is payable by checking, in order, whether the policy was in force, whether the loss was covered, whether anything was concealed and what is deducted.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Case questions ask for a decision: is the claim payable, and for how much? Doing them well needs a fixed order of checks, not a hunt through all the facts at once. This lesson gives that order and drills it. Waiting periods, grace periods and limits differ by policy; the figures here are invented and marked 'suppose', and a question that gives its own terms overrides them.

The five checks

  • Was the policy in force? Premium paid, not lapsed, and the event within the period covered (after any waiting period).
  • Was the loss covered? The cause must be an insured peril and not one the policy excludes (use proximate cause).
  • Was anything concealed? A hidden material fact can defeat the claim.
  • Is the claimant right? Insurable interest, and the nominee or insured is the one claiming.
  • How much? Actual loss or sum assured, adjusted for deductible, co-payment or inadmissible items, and capped by the sum insured.

Work down the list and stop at the first check that fails. If all five pass, compute the amount.

Worked examples

Example 1. Suppose a life policy has a sum assured of ₹5,00,000 and a yearly premium of ₹18,000 due on 1 January. Suppose the grace period is 30 days, and the insured dies on 20 January with the premium unpaid. Check 1: the death is within the grace period, so the policy is in force. Check 2: death is covered. Check 3 to 4 pass. Amount: the policy pays the sum assured, usually with the unpaid premium deducted: 5,00,000 - 18,000 = ₹4,82,000. If the death had been on 20 February, after the grace period, the policy would have lapsed and nothing would be payable.

Example 2. Suppose a health policy has a waiting period of 2 years for a particular condition. Mohit, who has had the policy for 10 months, is admitted for that condition. Check 1 fails: the event falls within the waiting period, so the claim is not payable for that condition. If he is admitted instead for an accident in the same month, the waiting period for the condition is irrelevant, and the claim passes check 1.

Example 3. Suppose a health claim for a covered illness is ₹3,00,000, of which ₹40,000 is for inadmissible items, and the sum insured is ₹5,00,000. Checks 1 to 4 pass. Admissible bill = 3,00,000 - 40,000 = ₹2,60,000, which is below the sum insured. The insurer pays ₹2,60,000. Now suppose the same case, but the proposer had hidden a material fact. Check 3 fails, and the insurer may reject the whole claim, whatever the amount.

In force? Covered? Concealment? Right claimant? How much? Stop at the first failure; compute only if all pass.

Speed signals

Matching a phrase to a check
Phrase in the caseThink of
Premium not paid, long agoLapse: check 1
Admitted soon after buyingWaiting period: check 1
Cause is on the list of exclusionsCheck 2
Did not mention an earlier illnessCheck 3
Claim by someone with no stakeCheck 4
Bill with non-medical itemsCheck 5

Key takeaways. Follow the five checks in order. A lapsed policy, a waiting period, an excluded peril or a concealed material fact can defeat a claim. A payable claim is then reduced by the deductions the policy allows.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which check comes first when deciding a claim?

    1. The amount payable
    2. Whether the policy was in force
    3. Whether the claimant is a nominee
    4. The claim settlement ratio
    Show answer

    Answer: B. If the policy was not in force, nothing else matters, so it is checked first.

  2. 2. Suppose a sum assured of ₹5,00,000 is payable and an unpaid premium of ₹18,000 is deducted. The claim paid is:

    1. ₹5,18,000
    2. ₹18,000
    3. ₹4,82,000
    4. ₹5,00,000
    Show answer

    Answer: C. 5,00,000 - 18,000 = ₹4,82,000.

  3. 3. A claim is made within a waiting period for the condition. The claim is most likely:

    1. Paid in full by the insurer
    2. Not payable for that condition
    3. Paid at double the amount claimed
    4. Paid by the reinsurer instead
    Show answer

    Answer: B. During the waiting period a condition is not covered, so the claim fails the first check.

  4. 4. Suppose a bill is ₹3,00,000, of which ₹40,000 is inadmissible, within the sum insured. The insurer pays:

    1. ₹3,40,000
    2. ₹40,000
    3. ₹2,60,000
    4. ₹3,00,000
    Show answer

    Answer: C. 3,00,000 - 40,000 = ₹2,60,000, the admissible part.

  5. 5. A proposer hid a material fact and the insurer discovered it at claim time. Which check fails?

    1. Concealment
    2. Cause of loss
    3. Amount payable
    4. Policy in force
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Concealing a material fact fails the check on concealment, breaking utmost good faith.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery