• Practice
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

Spotting the principle in a case

Identify which of the six principles of insurance a case is testing, using keyword signals, and avoid the classic confusions such as contribution versus subrogation.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Questions on the principles of insurance are mostly cases: a short story about a policyholder, a loss and someone's action, followed by 'which principle applies?'. The foundation course explained the six principles. This lesson gives keyword signals that point to each, the confusions examiners rely on, and the conditions that decide where each principle applies. All names and figures are invented.

Keyword signals

If the case mentions...Think of
Hiding, misstating or failing to disclose a factUtmost good faith
Someone insuring property or a life in which he has no stakeInsurable interest
Payment limited to the loss; no profit from a lossIndemnity
Two or more policies on the same property; insurers sharingContribution
Insurer recovering from a third party after payingSubrogation
A chain of events; which cause produced the lossProximate cause

Confusion 1: contribution versus subrogation

Both stop the insured from gaining from a loss, so both follow from indemnity. The difference is who is involved. Contribution is between insurers: several insurers of the same property share one loss. Subrogation is between the insurer and a third party who caused the loss: after paying, the insurer takes over the insured's right to recover from that wrongdoer. If the case has two insurers, think contribution; if it has a careless driver, a negligent carrier or another wrongdoer, think subrogation. Note also that under subrogation the insurer may recover only up to what it paid; anything recovered above that belongs to the insured.

Confusion 2: which principles apply to life insurance

Utmost good faith and insurable interest apply to all insurance, life included. Indemnity, and its two corollaries contribution and subrogation, apply to general insurance but not to life insurance, because a life policy pays a fixed sum. So a person may hold several life policies and all of them pay in full on death; there is no sharing between life insurers.

Confusion 3: when insurable interest must exist

Kind of insuranceWhen insurable interest must exist
Life insuranceWhen the policy is taken
Marine insuranceAt the time of the loss
Fire and other general insuranceBoth when the policy is taken and at the time of the loss

Worked example 1: four cases

Name the principle. (a) Two insurers cover the same warehouse and share a loss. (b) A transporter's negligence damages insured goods; after paying the owner, the insurer sues the transporter. (c) A proposer does not mention a previous heart operation. (d) A businessman insures the life of a rival in whom he has no financial stake. Working: (a) two insurers sharing: contribution. (b) insurer against a wrongdoer after paying: subrogation. (c) a hidden material fact: utmost good faith. (d) no stake in the life: insurable interest is missing. Answer: contribution, subrogation, utmost good faith, insurable interest.

Proximate cause in cases

Read the chain of events and ask which cause was dominant and effective, not just first or last. A standard illustration: a fire policy covers a shop; while putting out a fire, the fire brigade's water damages stock that the flames never touched. The water damage flows directly from the fire, so the proximate cause is the fire and the loss is covered. By contrast, if a new and independent cause breaks the chain, the loss is judged by that new cause.

Worked example 2: a subrogation figure

Suppose Asha's insured goods worth ₹80,000 are destroyed through a carrier's negligence. Her insurer pays her ₹80,000 and later recovers ₹1,00,000 from the carrier, the extra ₹20,000 being for Asha's own uninsured losses. How much may the insurer keep? Working: Under subrogation the insurer stands in Asha's place only up to what it paid. It paid ₹80,000, so it keeps ₹80,000; the remaining ₹20,000 belongs to Asha. Answer: ₹80,000.

Contribution is insurer with insurer; subrogation is insurer against a wrongdoer. Indemnity, contribution and subrogation do not apply to life insurance; good faith and insurable interest apply to all.

Key takeaways: match each case to its keyword signal; separate contribution (several insurers) from subrogation (a third party at fault); remember that life insurance follows good faith and insurable interest but not indemnity, contribution or subrogation; insurable interest is needed at inception for life, at the loss for marine, and at both for fire; proximate cause looks for the dominant cause in a chain.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. A ship's cargo is damaged because of a port operator's negligence. After paying the cargo owner, the insurer recovers from the port operator. Which principle?

    1. Contribution
    2. Subrogation
    3. Utmost good faith
    4. Insurable interest
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The insurer, having paid, takes over the insured's right against the wrongdoer: subrogation.

  2. 2. Which principles do NOT apply to life insurance?

    1. Utmost good faith and insurable interest
    2. Utmost good faith only
    3. Contribution and subrogation
    4. Insurable interest only
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Contribution and subrogation follow from indemnity, which does not apply to life insurance. Good faith and insurable interest apply to all insurance.

  3. 3. In marine insurance, when must insurable interest exist?

    1. Only when the policy is taken
    2. Neither at the start nor at the loss
    3. Only when the premium is paid
    4. At the time of the loss
    Show answer

    Answer: D. In marine insurance, insurable interest must exist at the time of the loss; in life insurance at inception; in fire insurance at both times.

  4. 4. Suppose an insurer pays ₹60,000 for a damaged car and later recovers ₹75,000 from the negligent driver. How much belongs to the insured?

    1. ₹75,000
    2. ₹15,000
    3. ₹60,000
    4. Nothing
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Under subrogation the insurer keeps only what it paid (₹60,000). The excess, ₹75,000 − ₹60,000 = ₹15,000, belongs to the insured.

  5. 5. Water used by firefighters damages goods in a shop that has a fire policy. The proximate cause of the water damage is:

    1. The fire, so the loss is covered
    2. The water, so the loss is not covered
    3. The fire brigade's negligence, so the shop owner must sue
    4. Nobody, because no flames touched the goods
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The water damage flows directly from fighting the fire, so the dominant, effective cause is the fire.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery