- Foundation
- About 13 min
- 5 practice questions
Growth and income distribution options, direct and regular plans
Tell the growth option from the income distribution (IDCW) option, work out what a payout does to the NAV and to the holder, and compare the direct and regular plans of the same scheme.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
One mutual fund scheme is usually offered in several versions. Each version holds the same portfolio under the same manager, but each has its own NAV and treats the investor's gains in a different way. Banking awareness papers ask what the options and plans are called and what each one does to the NAV. All figures in this lesson are invented for practice and describe no real fund.
Options: what happens to the gains
An option decides what the fund does with the profit it earns. In the growth option the fund keeps all gains inside the scheme. Nothing is paid out, so the NAV keeps rising as the portfolio gains value, and the investor receives the gain only when units are redeemed. In the income distribution cum capital withdrawal (IDCW) option, once called the dividend option, the fund pays out part of its money to unit holders from time to time. The amount is decided by the fund, is not guaranteed and may be nil. A payout is the investor's own money coming back, not an extra return.
| Feature | Growth option | IDCW option |
|---|---|---|
| Payout to holder | None | Paid from time to time, if the fund decides |
| Effect on NAV | NAV keeps rising with the portfolio | NAV falls by the payout per unit on payout day |
| Units held | Stay the same | Stay the same, unless the payout is reinvested |
| Gain reaches the holder | On redemption | Partly as payouts, rest on redemption |
Under the reinvestment variant of the IDCW option the payout is used at once to buy more units of the same scheme at the new, lower NAV, so the holder gets cash value as extra units instead of cash in hand.
Plans: how the fund is bought
A plan decides the route through which units are bought. In a regular plan the investor buys through an agent or distributor, and a part of the scheme's expenses pays the distributor's commission. In a direct plan the investor buys straight from the fund house, there is no distributor to pay, and the expense ratio is therefore lower. The portfolio and manager are the same, so the direct plan's NAV grows a little faster over time. A direct plan does not mean better advice or better stock picking; it only means lower cost and no intermediary.
Worked examples
Example 1. Suppose Sheela holds 900 units of a scheme whose IDCW option has a NAV of ₹50, so her holding is worth 900 × 50 = ₹45,000. The fund pays ₹5 per unit. Cash received = 900 × 5 = ₹4,500. The NAV falls to 50 − 5 = ₹45, so her units are worth 900 × 45 = ₹40,500. Cash plus units = 4,500 + 40,500 = ₹45,000, exactly as before: the payout moved value from the fund to her pocket and created none.
Example 2. Continue Example 1 but suppose Sheela had chosen reinvestment. The ₹4,500 buys units at the new NAV: 4,500 ÷ 45 = 100 units. She now holds 900 + 100 = 1,000 units at ₹45, worth ₹45,000. Her value is again unchanged; only the number of units rose.
Example 3. Suppose the portfolio of a scheme earns 10% a year before expenses. The regular plan has an expense ratio of 1.5% and the direct plan 0.5%, so the yearly returns are about 10 − 1.5 = 8.5% and 10 − 0.5 = 9.5%. On ₹1,00,000 for two years: regular = 1,00,000 × 1.085 × 1.085 = ₹1,17,722.50; direct = 1,00,000 × 1.095 × 1.095 = ₹1,19,902.50. The direct plan ends ₹2,180 ahead, from the cost difference alone.
Growth keeps gains in the fund. IDCW pays some out and lowers the NAV by the payout. A direct plan skips the distributor's commission.
Key takeaways. The option decides whether gains are paid out; the plan decides the buying route. A payout lowers the NAV by the same amount per unit and so is not extra profit. Reinvestment turns the payout into more units. Direct and regular plans share one portfolio, and the direct plan's lower expense ratio gives it a higher NAV over time. Nothing in these choices guarantees a return.
Check your understanding
-
1. In which option does a mutual fund keep all gains inside the scheme and pay nothing out?
- Growth option
- IDCW payout option
- Reinvestment of payouts
- Regular plan only
Show answer
Answer: A. The growth option pays nothing out, so gains stay in the scheme and show up as a rising NAV. The IDCW option pays part out.
-
2. Suppose a scheme's NAV is ₹60 and it pays an IDCW of ₹6 per unit. What is the NAV just after the payout, other things being equal?
- ₹66
- ₹54
- ₹60
- ₹6
Show answer
Answer: B. A payout leaves the fund, so the NAV falls by the amount paid: 60 − 6 = ₹54. The holder receives the ₹6 per unit in cash.
-
3. What is the main difference between a direct plan and a regular plan of the same scheme?
- The direct plan holds different shares from the regular one
- The regular plan guarantees a higher return than the direct
- The direct plan has a lower expense ratio (no commission)
- Only banks and large institutions can buy the direct plan
Show answer
Answer: C. Both plans share one portfolio and manager. The regular plan's expenses include a distributor's commission, so the direct plan costs less.
-
4. Suppose Vikram holds 450 units of an IDCW scheme at a NAV of ₹40, and a payout of ₹4 per unit is reinvested. How many units does he hold afterwards?
- 450 units
- 500 units
- 540 units
- 495 units
Show answer
Answer: B. Payout = 450 × 4 = ₹1,800. The new NAV is 40 − 4 = ₹36, so the new units = 1,800 ÷ 36 = 50. Total = 450 + 50 = 500 units.
-
5. Which statement about an IDCW payout is correct?
- It is a guaranteed yearly return on the units
- It comes out of the fund and lowers the NAV
- It adds to the investor's total wealth at once
- It is paid by SEBI to every unit holder
Show answer
Answer: B. The payout comes out of the scheme, so the NAV falls by that amount. It is neither guaranteed nor extra wealth.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.