- Foundation
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
SIP and lump sum: rupee-cost averaging
Explain how a systematic investment plan works, calculate units bought and average cost per unit with invented NAVs, and compare a SIP with a lump-sum investment without assuming either always wins.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
There are two simple ways to put money into a mutual fund: all at once, called a lump sum, or a fixed amount at regular intervals, called a systematic investment plan (SIP). Each has its own arithmetic, and the idea behind the SIP, rupee-cost averaging, is a favourite numerical question. All NAVs below are invented and labelled 'suppose'. Nothing here recommends one method over the other for any person.
How a SIP works
In a SIP the investor puts the same amount into the fund at regular intervals, for example on a fixed date every month. Each time, the units bought = amount ÷ NAV on that date. When the NAV is low, the fixed amount buys more units; when the NAV is high, it buys fewer. Over time the investor builds up units without trying to guess the right moment to invest.
Rupee-cost averaging
Because more units are bought at low prices and fewer at high prices, the average cost per unit of a SIP (total invested ÷ total units) is lower than the simple average of the NAVs on the purchase dates, whenever those NAVs differ. This effect is called rupee-cost averaging. It is a fact of arithmetic, not a promise of profit: if the NAV ends lower than the average cost, the investor still loses.
SIP: fixed amount each time; units = amount ÷ NAV. Average cost per unit = total invested ÷ total units, which is below the simple average of the NAVs when they vary.
Worked example 1: a three-month SIP
Suppose Kiran invests ₹600 a month for three months, at NAVs of ₹10, ₹15 and ₹30. Working: units = 600 ÷ 10 = 60, then 600 ÷ 15 = 40, then 600 ÷ 30 = 20, a total of 120 units for ₹1,800. Average cost per unit = 1,800 ÷ 120 = ₹15. The simple average of the three NAVs is (10 + 15 + 30) ÷ 3 = ₹18.33, which is higher: the SIP bought most of its units when the NAV was low.
Worked example 2: neither method always wins
Take the same NAVs, ₹10, ₹15 and ₹30, and suppose the NAV ends at ₹30. A lump sum of ₹1,800 at the start buys 1,800 ÷ 10 = 180 units, worth 180 × 30 = ₹5,400. The SIP's 120 units are worth 120 × 30 = ₹3,600. In this rising market the lump sum did better.
Now reverse the NAVs: suppose they are ₹30, ₹15 and ₹10, and the NAV ends at ₹10. A lump sum of ₹1,800 at the start buys 1,800 ÷ 30 = 60 units, worth 60 × 10 = ₹600. The SIP buys 20 + 40 + 60 = 120 units, worth 120 × 10 = ₹1,200. In this falling market the SIP did better. Which method gives more depends on how prices move, which nobody knows in advance.
Why people use SIPs
- They suit a regular income: a fixed sum each month.
- They remove the need to choose a single moment to invest.
- They build a habit of saving.
- They spread purchases over different prices.
Key takeaways: a SIP invests a fixed amount at regular intervals; units each time = amount ÷ NAV; average cost = total invested ÷ total units, never the simple average of NAVs; rupee-cost averaging lowers the average cost when NAVs vary; and neither SIP nor lump sum is guaranteed to give more.
Check your understanding
-
1. A systematic investment plan (SIP) means:
- Investing a fixed amount in a fund at regular intervals
- Investing the whole amount in a single payment
- Withdrawing a fixed amount from a fund every month
- Investing only when the NAV falls
Show answer
Answer: A. A SIP puts the same amount in at regular intervals, whatever the NAV. A single payment is a lump sum.
-
2. Suppose Meera invests ₹1,000 a month for three months at NAVs of ₹20, ₹25 and ₹40. How many units does she hold in total?
- 100
- 115
- 120
- 105
Show answer
Answer: B. Units = 1,000 ÷ 20 + 1,000 ÷ 25 + 1,000 ÷ 40 = 50 + 40 + 25 = 115.
-
3. Suppose Vinod invests ₹2,000 a month for three months at NAVs of ₹20, ₹40 and ₹40. What is his average cost per unit?
- ₹33.33
- ₹40
- ₹20
- ₹30
Show answer
Answer: D. Units = 100 + 50 + 50 = 200 for ₹6,000. Average cost = 6,000 ÷ 200 = ₹30. ₹33.33 is the simple average of the NAVs, which is not the cost per unit.
-
4. Which statement describes rupee-cost averaging in a SIP?
- The fixed amount buys more units when the NAV is low and fewer when it is high
- The investor buys the same number of units every month
- The average cost per unit always equals the simple average of the NAVs
- It guarantees that the investment will make a profit
Show answer
Answer: A. A fixed rupee amount buys more units at low NAVs. This lowers the average cost when NAVs vary, but it does not guarantee a profit.
-
5. Which statement about SIP and lump-sum investing is correct?
- A SIP always gives a higher value than a lump sum
- A lump sum always gives a higher value than a SIP
- Neither always gives a higher value; it depends on how the NAV moves
- Both always give exactly the same value
Show answer
Answer: C. In a rising market a lump sum at the start can do better; in a falling market a SIP can do better. Nobody knows the path in advance.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.