• Practice
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

NPAs in the profit and loss account, and choosing the recovery route

Work out how provisions, settlements and recoveries from written-off loans change a bank's profit and NPA figures, and match a borrower's situation to the right recovery route.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

The earlier lessons treated NPAs as balance-sheet figures. But every NPA also passes through the profit and loss account: it stops earning, it needs provisions, and when money is finally recovered, part of the earlier provision may come back. This lesson works through those effects with invented figures, and then practises matching borrower situations to the recovery routes named in the foundation course.

Three ways NPAs touch profit

First, lost income: interest on an NPA is not counted as income until it is actually received, so a loan that turns bad stops adding to profit immediately. Second, provisions: each provision is an expense charged against profit in the year it is made. Third, write-backs: if a bank later recovers more than the net book value of the loan (the loan minus the provision held), the provision that turns out not to be needed is written back and adds to profit. A loan that has already been written off works the same way in spirit: anything recovered later is income in the year it arrives.

Gain or loss on settling an NPA = amount recovered − (loan − provision held). Money recovered on a written-off loan is income when received and does not change gross NPA.

Worked example 1: settlement of a provided loan

Suppose a loan of ₹40 crore is an NPA and the bank already holds a provision of ₹24 crore against it. The borrower offers ₹30 crore in full settlement; the bank accepts and closes the account. Ignoring tax and costs, what happens to profit, to gross NPA and to provisions? Working: net book value = 40 − 24 = ₹16 crore. The bank receives ₹30 crore, so it gains 30 − 16 = ₹14 crore against net book value. Put another way, the shortfall of 40 − 30 = ₹10 crore is absorbed by the provision, leaving 24 − 10 = ₹14 crore of provision unused, which is written back to profit. Gross NPA falls by the full ₹40 crore, and provisions fall by ₹24 crore. Answer: profit up ₹14 crore; gross NPA down ₹40 crore.

The lesson for problems is that a settlement below the loan amount can still raise this year's profit, because the loss was charged earlier through provisions. What matters for this year is the comparison with net book value, not with the original loan.

Worked example 2: recovery from a written-off loan

Suppose a bank wrote off a fully provided loan of ₹12 crore last year. This year it recovers ₹5 crore from the borrower. What changes? Working: the loan left the books last year, so it is not part of this year's gross NPA. The ₹5 crore received is income in the year received. Answer: profit rises by ₹5 crore; gross NPA and net NPA do not change. This is also why a write-off is not a waiver: the bank keeps trying to recover, and any success shows up as income.

Matching the situation to the route

SituationRoute usually suited
Viable business in temporary difficultyRestructuring: change the terms so the borrower can pay
Secured lender wants to sell the security after notice, without first going to courtEnforcement under the SARFAESI Act, 2002
Company in default; creditors want a resolution of the company as a wholeInsolvency resolution under the IBC, 2016, before the National Company Law Tribunal
Bank wants to sell the bad loan to a specialist and get it off its booksSale to an asset reconstruction company
Bank and borrower can reach agreement through conciliationSettlement at a Lok Adalat
Bank files a recovery caseDebt Recovery Tribunal

In matching questions, look for the key phrase. 'Without going to court' points to SARFAESI. 'Resolution of the company' or 'NCLT' points to the IBC. 'Sell the loan' points to an asset reconstruction company. 'Temporary difficulty, viable business' points to restructuring. Options that name unrelated laws, such as the Negotiable Instruments Act, are distractors. This course gives no thresholds or timelines for these routes; questions at this level test which route fits, not the current limits.

Key takeaways: an NPA stops earning, its provisions cut profit, and a recovery above net book value writes back provision and adds to profit; recovery on a written-off loan is income and leaves NPA figures unchanged; and each recovery route has a signature phrase that identifies it in matching questions.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. How is interest on a loan that has become an NPA treated in the bank's income?

    1. It is counted as income as it falls due, like any other loan
    2. It is not counted as income until it is actually received
    3. It is counted twice, once when due and once when paid
    4. It is converted into a provision as soon as it falls due
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Income on an NPA is recognised only when actually received; this is one reason NPAs cut a bank's earnings.

  2. 2. Suppose a loan of ₹60 crore is an NPA and the bank holds a provision of ₹45 crore against it. The borrower settles for ₹20 crore and the account is closed. Ignoring tax and costs, what is the effect on this year's profit?

    1. Profit rises by ₹5 crore
    2. Profit falls by ₹40 crore
    3. Profit rises by ₹20 crore
    4. Profit falls by ₹15 crore
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Net book value = 60 − 45 = 15. The bank receives 20, which is 5 more than the net book value. The shortfall of 40 is absorbed by the provision of 45, and the unused 5 is written back to profit.

  3. 3. Suppose a bank wrote off a fully provided loan of ₹8 crore last year. This year the borrower pays ₹3 crore. What happens?

    1. Gross NPA falls by ₹3 crore
    2. Profit falls by ₹5 crore
    3. Nothing, because a written-off loan can no longer be recovered
    4. Profit rises by ₹3 crore; gross NPA does not change
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The loan left the books when written off, so it is no longer in gross NPA. Money recovered later is income in the year received: profit rises by 3.

  4. 4. A secured lender wants to take possession of a defaulting borrower's mortgaged factory and sell it, after giving notice, without first going to court. Which law provides this route?

    1. The Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016
    2. The Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881
    3. The SARFAESI Act, 2002
    4. The Indian Contract Act, 1872
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Enforcing security without first approaching a court is the route given by the SARFAESI Act, 2002.

  5. 5. Suppose a bank expected a profit of ₹100 crore, and must now make new provisions of ₹30 crore against loans that turned bad. Ignoring tax, what profit does it now report?

    1. ₹130 crore
    2. ₹100 crore
    3. ₹70 crore
    4. ₹30 crore
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Provisions are charged against profit: 100 − 30 = ₹70 crore.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery