- Practice
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Security and shortfall problems: value, margin, realisation and provision
Work out what a bank realises when security is sold after a price fall, find the shortfall, split the dues into secured and unsecured parts for a provision, and fix a safe loan-to-value ratio.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Problems on security combine a loan, a value of an asset, a fall in prices and the costs of sale. The method is a short chain: current value, then net realisation, then shortfall, then provision. All numbers, including the provisioning percentages, are invented for practice; real percentages are set by the regulator and change from time to time.
The chain of steps
- Value after the fall: original value × (1 − fall).
- Net realisation: sale value minus the costs of sale.
- Shortfall: dues minus net realisation, if that is positive. If net realisation is more than the dues, there is no shortfall.
- Secured and unsecured parts: the secured part of the dues is the smaller of the dues and the net realisation; the rest of the dues is the unsecured part.
- Provision (invented rates): secured part × its rate + unsecured part × its rate.
A safe loan-to-value
To stay whole after a price fall and costs of sale, the loan must not exceed the value the asset can still fetch. If prices could fall by f and costs are c of the sale value, then maximum loan = value × (1 − f) × (1 − c). The loan-to-value ratio is then (1 − f)(1 − c).
Worked examples
Example 1. Suppose a loan with dues of ₹60 lakh was secured on a property valued at ₹80 lakh. Prices fall by 30% before the sale, and the bank spends ₹2 lakh in costs. Value after the fall = 80 × 0.7 = ₹56 lakh. Net realisation = 56 − 2 = ₹54 lakh. Shortfall = 60 − 54 = ₹6 lakh.
Example 2. Continue Example 1, and suppose the bank provides 25% on the secured part and 100% on the unsecured part (invented rates). Secured part = smaller of 60 and 54 = ₹54 lakh. Unsecured part = 60 − 54 = ₹6 lakh. Provision = 54 × 25% + 6 × 100% = 13.5 + 6 = ₹19.5 lakh. Net NPA on this account = 60 − 19.5 = ₹40.5 lakh.
Example 3. A bank wants to be safe after a 40% price fall, with costs of sale equal to 5% of the sale value. A property is worth ₹80 lakh. Maximum loan = 80 × 0.6 × 0.95 = 80 × 0.57 = ₹45.6 lakh, which is a loan-to-value of 57%. A loan of ₹60 lakh on the same property would leave a shortfall: 80 × 0.57 = 45.6, so 60 − 45.6 = ₹14.4 lakh.
Example 4. Suppose the net realisation of a property is ₹48 lakh against dues of ₹40 lakh. There is no shortfall, and the surplus of ₹8 lakh belongs to the borrower after the bank has been repaid. The whole of the dues is the secured part, ₹40 lakh.
Value after the fall, less costs, gives realisation. Dues minus realisation is the shortfall. Safe loan = value × (1 − fall) × (1 − costs).
Key takeaways. Apply the fall to the value, then deduct the costs. The shortfall exists only if realisation is below the dues. Split the dues into secured and unsecured parts before applying provision rates. A cautious loan-to-value ratio is what remains of the value after the worst expected fall and the costs of sale.
Check your understanding
-
1. A property worth ₹50 lakh falls in value by 20%. What is its value after the fall?
- ₹30 lakh
- ₹40 lakh
- ₹45 lakh
- ₹10 lakh
Show answer
Answer: B. Value after the fall = 50 × 0.8 = ₹40 lakh.
-
2. Dues are ₹36 lakh. The security fetches ₹30 lakh and costs of sale are ₹1 lakh. What is the shortfall?
- ₹5 lakh
- ₹6 lakh
- ₹1 lakh
- ₹7 lakh
Show answer
Answer: D. Net realisation = 30 − 1 = ₹29 lakh. Shortfall = 36 − 29 = ₹7 lakh.
-
3. Suppose the bank provides 20% on the secured part and 100% on the unsecured part. Dues are ₹50 lakh and net realisation ₹40 lakh. What is the provision?
- ₹18 lakh
- ₹10 lakh
- ₹8 lakh
- ₹20 lakh
Show answer
Answer: A. Secured = ₹40 lakh, unsecured = ₹10 lakh. Provision = 40 × 20% + 10 × 100% = 8 + 10 = ₹18 lakh.
-
4. Prices may fall by 50% and there are no costs of sale. What is the maximum safe loan on an asset worth ₹90 lakh?
- ₹30 lakh
- ₹60 lakh
- ₹45 lakh
- ₹90 lakh
Show answer
Answer: C. Maximum loan = 90 × (1 − 0.5) = ₹45 lakh.
-
5. Net realisation from security is ₹55 lakh and the dues are ₹45 lakh. What is the position?
- A shortfall of ₹10 lakh remains with the bank
- A shortfall of ₹55 lakh remains with the bank
- A provision of 100% is required on the loan
- There is no shortfall as the dues are covered
Show answer
Answer: D. Realisation exceeds the dues, so there is no shortfall. The bank recovers all it is owed.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.