- Practice
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Choosing the right system: matching a need to a payment design
Read a short scenario, pick the payment system whose design fits it, and explain why each other option fails, using value, repetition, direction and finality as filters.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Many practice questions do not name a system. They describe a need - a large land payment, a monthly fee, a late-night transfer to a friend - and ask which system fits. The answer comes from the design of each system, not from memorised limits or timings, which change and are not tested here. This lesson gives a small decision routine and drills it on scenarios. One fact to keep in mind: NEFT and RTGS both run round the clock on every day of the year (NEFT since December 2019, RTGS since December 2020), so the hour never rules them out; for a small late-night payment the real difference is that UPI and IMPS credit the payee instantly, while NEFT credits only after its next batch settles.
Match the need to the design
| Need described | Best fit | Reason from the design |
|---|---|---|
| A very large payment that must be final at once | RTGS | Gross and real-time: each payment settles alone and is final |
| Salaries for hundreds of employees on one day | NACH credit | Bulk push: one file from the sponsor bank to many destination banks |
| Premiums or EMIs collected every month under a signed mandate | NACH debit | Pull under a standing mandate, repeated without fresh instructions |
| A small transfer to a friend that must arrive instantly, even late at night | UPI or IMPS | Retail systems that credit the customer at once; NEFT also runs at any hour but credits only after a batch |
| Paying a shopkeeper by scanning a code | UPI | Pay by a virtual payment address; the customer approves with a PIN |
| A moderate payment, no hurry, from net banking | NEFT | Push in batches; final after the batch settles |
| A payee holding a paper instrument | Cheque through CTS | The image travels to the drawee bank; the payee's bank presents it |
Three filters, in this order
- One-off or repeated? A repeated collection under a mandate points to NACH debit (or an equivalent electronic mandate).
- Who starts it? If the payer pushes, think RTGS, NEFT, IMPS, UPI pay or NACH credit. If the payee's side pulls, think cheque, NACH debit or a UPI collect request.
- What kind of finality is needed? Final between banks at once means RTGS. Only instant credit to the customer means IMPS or UPI.
Large and final: RTGS. Bulk and repeated: NACH. Instant retail credit: UPI or IMPS. Paper: cheque through CTS. Moderate and not urgent: NEFT.
Worked examples
Example 1. A builder must pay a seller ₹2 crore today, and the seller will release the documents only when the money is irrevocably settled. Which system? Working: the value is large and the timing is critical, and the seller wants finality, not merely a credit notice. NEFT settles in batches. UPI and IMPS are retail systems for everyday sums. NACH is for repeated or bulk flows. Answer: RTGS, because each payment settles individually, in real time, and is final.
Example 2. A school collects a monthly fee from 400 parents who have each signed a standing mandate for ₹3,500. Which system, which side, and how much reaches the school's bank? Working: the fee is repeated and under a mandate, so it is NACH debit, a pull. The school is the user institution; its bank is the sponsor bank, and the parents' banks are destination banks. Total = 400 × 3,500 = ₹14,00,000 (an illustrative figure). Answer: NACH debit; the sponsor bank receives ₹14,00,000 in all, net of nothing else, from the destination banks.
Example 3. At 11 pm on a holiday, Rhea wants to send ₹750 to a friend with an account in another bank. Is NEFT the only way to reach another bank? Working: no. Interbank reach is not unique to NEFT: UPI and IMPS are interoperable among banks and credit the friend at once. NEFT also works at 11 pm on a holiday, since it runs round the clock, but the friend is credited only after the next half-hourly batch settles. Answer: UPI or IMPS for an instant credit; NEFT would also reach the friend, a little later. The statement 'NEFT is the only system that works across banks' is false.
Traps in need-matching
- 'Urgent' does not automatically mean RTGS. A small urgent payment suits UPI or IMPS; RTGS is for large, time-critical payments.
- 'Mandate' or 'standing instruction' signals a pull from the payee's side, not a push from the payer.
- 'Paper' does not mean the paper itself travels in CTS: the image does.
- 'Instant credit' describes the customer's side; it does not make interbank settlement gross or real-time.
Key takeaways. Ask whether the need is one-off or repeated, who starts it, and what finality is required. Match large-and-final to RTGS, bulk-and-repeated to NACH, instant retail to UPI or IMPS, paper to CTS and moderate-and-unhurried to NEFT. Reject any option that fails on even one filter.
Check your understanding
-
1. A company must pay a very large sum to a supplier today, and the payment must be final the moment it settles. Which system fits best?
- RTGS
- NEFT
- UPI
- NACH
Show answer
Answer: A. Large, time-critical and final at once is the profile of RTGS, which settles each payment individually in real time. NEFT settles in batches; UPI is a retail system; NACH is for bulk or repeated flows.
-
2. An insurer collects premiums every month from customers who signed a standing mandate. Which facility is the natural fit?
- RTGS credit transfer
- NACH debit
- IMPS push payment
- Cheque deposit
Show answer
Answer: B. A repeated collection under a mandate is a pull and is the design purpose of NACH debit. RTGS and IMPS are payer-pushed one-off transfers; a cheque needs fresh paper each time.
-
3. A company pays salaries to 600 employees on one date through a single file from its bank. Which description is correct?
- NACH debit, pulled by the employees' banks
- RTGS, one payment per employee
- NACH credit through its sponsor bank
- A cheque for each employee
Show answer
Answer: C. Bulk pushes such as salaries are NACH credit: the company's bank, as sponsor bank, submits one file and the destination banks credit the employees. Employees do not pull a salary; RTGS is not meant for bulk retail credits.
-
4. Which statement about choosing a system is FALSE?
- IMPS and UPI credit the customer at once
- A mandate points to a pull from the payee's side
- RTGS is meant for large, time-critical payments
- NEFT is the only system that reaches other banks
Show answer
Answer: D. UPI and IMPS also work between different banks, so NEFT is not the only interbank route. The other three statements are accurate.
-
5. 400 parents each pay a school fee of ₹3,500 through NACH debit mandates. The sponsor bank receives in all:
- ₹14,00,000
- ₹1,40,000
- ₹3,500
- ₹1,40,00,000
Show answer
Answer: A. 400 × 3,500 = 1,400,000, which is ₹14,00,000. The other figures misplace the zeros or ignore the number of parents. The figures are illustrative.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.