- Foundation
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Amanda!: nagging, daydreams and the longing for freedom
Understand Robin Klein's poem Amanda!, tell the adult's voice from Amanda's daydreams in brackets, explain the mermaid, orphan and Rapunzel fantasies, and identify repetition, imagery, irony and rhyme.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Identify the two voices in the poem and how the stanzas alternate.
- Explain what each daydream shows about Amanda.
- Identify repetition, imagery, irony and the rhyme of the bracketed stanzas.
- Give a balanced view of whether Amanda is moody.
The poem with this chapter, Amanda! by the Australian writer Robin Klein, fits well beside Anne Frank: both show young people who feel controlled and misunderstood and find escape in imagination. The book suggests reading it in pairs, one person for each voice.
Two voices
The odd stanzas (1, 3, 5, 7) are spoken by an adult, most likely Amanda's mother: a stream of instructions and complaints about nail-biting, posture, homework, tidiness, shoes, chocolate, pimples, attention and sulking. The even stanzas (2, 4, 6), in brackets, are Amanda's silent thoughts. The brackets show these are inside her head; she is not listening to the nagging but escaping from it. From the complaints (homework, acne, chocolate), she seems to be a pre-teen or young teenager, perhaps eleven to thirteen.
The two voices
-
The adult (odd stanzas)
- Commands: don't, stop, sit up
- Questions about homework and room
- Reminders about acne and chocolate
- Ends by denying she nags
-
Amanda (bracketed stanzas)
- A mermaid alone in a calm green sea
- An orphan wandering free
- Rapunzel alone in a tower
- Longing for peace, silence and freedom
The three daydreams
| Daydream | What it gives her | What it shows |
|---|---|---|
| Mermaid | A calm, emerald sea where she is the only one, drifting happily | She wants solitude and freedom to move as she likes. |
| Orphan | Roaming the streets barefoot in silence, with no one to give orders | She wishes, for a moment, to be free of parents' control; she is not really an orphan. |
| Rapunzel | A peaceful tower where she will never let her hair down | Unlike the fairy-tale Rapunzel, who let down her hair so others could climb up, she wants no one to reach her. |
In the fairy tale, Rapunzel is shut in a tower and lets down her long hair so that others can climb up. Amanda twists the tale: she would happily stay alone and never let anyone climb in. Each fantasy is quieter and more isolated, showing how strongly she wants to be left alone.
Poetic devices
- Repetition: the name Amanda ends almost every line of the adult's stanzas, sounding like constant nagging.
- Imagery: a calm green sea, soft dust under bare feet, a golden silence; pictures of peace that contrast with the noise of orders.
- Alliteration: repeated consonant sounds in the dream stanzas make them smooth and musical.
- Rhyme: each bracketed stanza has three lines rhyming together (AAA), giving them a dreamy, song-like flow, while the adult's lines are irregular.
- Irony: in the last stanza the adult says that anyone would think she nagged, after six stanzas of nagging.
Worked example 1: is Amanda moody?
Question: Is Amanda really sulking and moody? Working: the adult calls her moody but gives her no space and never asks how she feels. Amanda's silence is her way of escaping constant criticism. Answer: her withdrawal is a reaction to nagging, not a fixed trait. A balanced view: the adult's advice is meant well, but too many orders push a child into silence.
Worked example 2: an original stanza in the same pattern
Our own lines, in the shape of a bracketed stanza: (I am a kite above the town, / no strings to pull me up or down, / the sky my field, the wind my crown.) Working: the three lines rhyme (town, down, crown), the fantasy is about freedom, and the brackets show a private thought. This is how Klein's dream stanzas work.
Odd stanzas: the nagging adult. Even stanzas, in brackets: Amanda's escape into freedom. The last line is ironic.
Key takeaways: Amanda! sets an adult's constant instructions against a child's longing for freedom. Her daydreams (mermaid, orphan, Rapunzel) show a wish for peace and independence. Repetition, imagery, rhyme and irony build the contrast.
Check your understanding
-
1. Why are stanzas 2, 4 and 6 of Amanda! in brackets?
- They are spoken by the teacher.
- They are Amanda's private thoughts and daydreams.
- They were added later by an editor.
- They are less important.
Show answer
Answer: B. The brackets mark Amanda's inner world, which she does not speak aloud. She escapes into these fantasies while the adult talks.
-
2. Why does Amanda imagine herself as an orphan?
- Her parents have died.
- She wants to live on the street forever.
- She wishes for freedom from constant instructions.
- She is lost in a city.
Show answer
Answer: C. She is not really an orphan; the fantasy shows a longing to be free of parental control, with silence and freedom.
-
3. How is Amanda's Rapunzel different from the fairy-tale Rapunzel?
- She would never let down her hair, wanting no one to reach her.
- She escapes from the tower at once.
- She cuts her hair short.
- She lives in a castle by the sea.
Show answer
Answer: A. The original Rapunzel lets down her hair so others can climb up. Amanda wants the calm of the tower and would keep everyone out.
-
4. What is ironic about the last stanza?
- Amanda finally obeys.
- The adult praises Amanda.
- Amanda speaks aloud for the first time.
- The adult says people might think she nagged, after nagging throughout.
Show answer
Answer: D. The adult denies nagging right after a poem full of nagging, which is the opposite of what the reader sees.
-
5. What is the rhyme pattern of each bracketed stanza?
- ABAB
- AAA
- ABC
- AABB
Show answer
Answer: B. Each bracketed stanza has three lines that all rhyme with one another, giving AAA.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.