• Foundation
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

Matilda, her husband and the irony of the false necklace

Compare Matilda and M. Loisel with evidence, explain how the necklace changed their lives, find the cause of Matilda's ruin and how she could have avoided it, and explain the story's irony.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Write character sketches of Matilda and M. Loisel.
  • Explain how the the Loisels' whole way of life changed.
  • Identify the cause of Matilda's ruin and the role of honesty.
  • Explain the twist ending and its irony.

Maupassant's story turns on small choices: wanting to look rich for one night and hiding the truth for ten years. The last line turns everything upside down.

Matilda and her husband

Two very different people

  • Matilda Loisel
    • Pretty, vain and discontented
    • Dreams of luxury; despises her home
    • Weeps over a dress and jewels
    • Too proud to admit the loss
    • Later: hard-working, strong, honest about the debt
  • M. Loisel
    • Simple and content (enjoys his potpie)
    • Loving and generous: gives up his gun
    • Practical: searches, advertises, plans
    • Self-sacrificing: works nights copying
    • Ages quickly under the strain
The necklace completely changed the course of their lives.
ChangeBefore the necklaceAfter the necklace
Homea modest apartment with a maidattic rooms, no maid
WorkMatilda dreams; husband works as a clerkshe does all housework; he works evenings and nights too
Appearanceyoung and prettyold-looking, rough hands, hair untidy
Charactervain and self-pityingstrong, brave, responsible

The cause of her ruin, and how she could have avoided it

The deeper cause is vanity and discontent: Matilda wanted to appear richer than she was, so a new dress was not enough; she needed jewels. The immediate cause is false pride and a lack of honesty: instead of telling Mme Forestier the truth, she bought a replacement in secret. She could have avoided ruin by being content with simple flowers or her own dress, by taking more care of the borrowed necklace, or above all by confessing the loss. Had she done so, she would have learned that it was worth very little, and at most would have had to pay a small sum.

Irony and the twist ending

The ending is a classic twist: Mme Forestier reveals, in the last lines, that her necklace was fake. This creates powerful irony: ten years of hardship were spent to replace something worth very little; a woman who wanted to look rich became truly poor by trying; and it is Matilda's honesty at last, too late, that reveals the truth. Small things can ruin or save a life, a thought the story itself raises.

Language clues: are they speaking English?

The characters speak English in the translation, but clues show they are French: titles M. (Monsieur) and Mme (Madame), money in francs and sous, and Paris places such as the Palais-Royal and the Champs-Elysees. The story was written in French and translated.

Worked example 1: a long answer

Question: What led to Matilda's downfall? Model answer (about 100 words): Matilda was ruined by her vanity and her false pride. She was never satisfied with her life and wanted to appear rich at the ball, so she borrowed a necklace she believed was diamonds. When she lost it, pride stopped her from telling her friend the truth. Instead, she and her husband bought a costly replacement with borrowed money and spent ten years in hard labour to repay it. If she had been content, careful or honest, she would have learned that the necklace was false. Her ruin came from appearances, not from fate.

Worked example 2: imagining a confession

Question: What might have happened if Matilda had confessed? Working: Mme Forestier was a friend who later took her hands kindly; the necklace was worth at most five hundred francs. Answer: her friend would probably have forgiven her or asked for a small sum; the Loisels would have been spared ten years of poverty.

Honesty might have cost Matilda a moment's shame; pride cost her ten years.

Key takeaways: Matilda is vain but later heroic in hard work; her husband is loving and selfless. Vanity and false pride caused their ruin; confession would have saved them. The twist ending makes the irony unforgettable.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which quality of M. Loisel is shown when he gives Matilda his savings for a gun?

    1. Greed
    2. Vanity
    3. Selfless love
    4. Laziness
    Show answer

    Answer: C. He gives up something he wanted for himself so that she can be happy: selfless love.

  2. 2. What was the immediate cause of the Loisels' ten years of hardship?

    1. Matilda's illness
    2. Loss of Loisel's job
    3. A fire at their apartment
    4. Hiding the loss and secretly buying an expensive replacement
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Instead of telling Mme Forestier, they bought a 36,000-franc replacement, much of it borrowed.

  3. 3. How did ten years of hardship change Matilda?

    1. She became strong and hard-working, but looked old.
    2. She became even vainer.
    3. She became rich.
    4. She stopped speaking to her husband.
    Show answer

    Answer: A. She did all the heavy housework, haggled over money and became a strong, rough-looking woman, but she paid her debt bravely.

  4. 4. Which clue shows that the characters are French?

    1. They eat potpie.
    2. Money is in francs and sous, and titles are M. and Mme.
    3. They go to a ball.
    4. They live in an apartment.
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Francs, sous, Monsieur, Madame and Paris places are French; the story is a translation.

  5. 5. Why is the ending of The Necklace ironic?

    1. Matilda wins a lottery.
    2. Mme Forestier refuses to see her.
    3. Ten years of sacrifice were spent replacing a necklace that was false.
    4. M. Loisel buys the gun at last.
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The outcome is the opposite of what we expect: the costly sacrifice was for an imitation worth at most 500 francs.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery