- Foundation
- About 18 min
- 5 practice questions
Writing and speaking: a letter of confession, a debate on honesty and a diary of the ten years
Write Matilda's honest letter to Mme Forestier, argue for or against 'Honesty is the best policy' or 'We should be content with what life gives us', and write a reflective diary entry.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Write an informal letter that admits a mistake and apologises.
- Present a short debate speech with reasons and a rebuttal.
- Write a reflective diary entry in a character's voice.
The chapter's discussion topics are Honesty is the best policy and We should be content with what life gives us. This lesson builds both into writing and speaking tasks, with original models.
Informal letter: format
- Writer's address and date at the top.
- Salutation: Dear (first name),
- Body: friendly opening, the main message in clear paragraphs, a closing line.
- Close: Yours lovingly / Your friend / With love, and the name.
- Tone: warm and personal, but clear.
Worked example 1: the letter Matilda should have written (original model)
Paris, 20 January | Dear Jeanne, I must tell you something that has kept me awake for two nights. After the Minister's ball, I lost the beautiful necklace you so kindly lent me. We have searched the streets, the cab offices and the police station, and we have advertised, but it has not been found. I am deeply ashamed and very sorry. Please tell me what it is worth; my husband and I will repay you, however long it takes. I would rather face your disappointment now than hide the truth from a friend. With love and apologies, Matilda
Why it works: it comes to the point quickly, explains what was done, apologises sincerely and offers to make amends. One honest letter like this would have changed the whole story.
Debate: Honesty is the best policy
Arguments on the motion
-
For
- Truth told early costs less than lies discovered later
- Honesty builds trust in friendships
- Hiding one mistake often needs more lies
- Matilda's secrecy cost ten years
-
Against (or with reservations)
- Honesty can hurt feelings if said unkindly
- Some situations call for tact and timing
- Honesty alone does not solve every problem
Worked example 2: debate opening (for the motion, about 90 words)
Good morning, respected judges, teachers and friends. I speak for the motion: honesty is the best policy. A lie may seem to protect us for a moment, but it builds a debt that grows with interest. In Maupassant's The Necklace, one confession would have revealed that the lost jewels were false; instead, a hidden mistake cost a family ten years of poverty. My opponents may say honesty can hurt. True, but the answer is to be honest kindly, not to hide the truth. Thank you.
Diary entry: reflection after ten years
Worked example 3: Matilda's diary (original model)
Sunday night. Today I met Jeanne on the Champs-Elysees. She did not know me at first, and no wonder: my hands are red and I look old before my time. When I told her everything, she said her necklace had been false. Ten years, all those stairs and buckets, for a few hundred francs' worth of glass! At first I wanted to laugh and cry together. Yet I am not ashamed of the work; we paid every sou. I only wish I had trusted my friend with the truth. - Matilda
Letters of apology: admit, explain, apologise, offer to make amends.
Key takeaways: an informal letter is warm but clear; a debate states a stand, gives reasons and answers the other side; a diary reflects on feelings and lessons in the first person.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which salutation suits an informal letter to a close friend?
- Dear Sir,
- To whom it may concern,
- Dear Jeanne,
- Respected Madam,
Show answer
Answer: C. An informal letter to a friend uses 'Dear' and the first name.
-
2. What are the main steps of a letter of apology?
- Admit, explain, apologise and offer to make amends
- Blame others and ask for money
- Describe the weather and say goodbye
- Ask for a new necklace
Show answer
Answer: A. A sincere apology admits the mistake, explains it, says sorry and offers to put it right.
-
3. Which argument best supports 'Honesty is the best policy'?
- Truth told early usually costs less than a lie discovered later.
- Honest people never make mistakes.
- Lies are always found out the same day.
- Jewels are expensive.
Show answer
Answer: A. It gives a reason that fits the story: Matilda's hidden loss grew into a ten-year debt.
-
4. Which line best shows reflection in Matilda's diary?
- Today was Sunday.
- Jeanne had a child with her.
- The Champs-Elysees is in Paris.
- I only wish I had trusted my friend with the truth.
Show answer
Answer: D. It shows what Matilda has learned, which is the heart of a reflective diary entry.
-
5. How might a speaker 'against' the motion on honesty reasonably argue?
- Lying is always right.
- Honesty needs tact and timing, or it can hurt people needlessly.
- Matilda was right to hide the loss.
- Friends should never be trusted.
Show answer
Answer: B. A sensible opposing view accepts honesty's value but stresses kindness and timing; the other options are extreme.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.