- Foundation
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Caste and politics: inequality, change and two-way influence
Explain what made the caste system distinctive, how caste has changed and where inequality persists, how caste appears in politics and how politics changes caste, and the positive and negative effects of caste in politics.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain the features of the caste system and the changes in modern India, and where inequality continues.
- Describe how caste matters in politics and why caste alone does not decide elections.
- Explain how politics changes caste, and the positive and negative sides of caste in politics.
Gender is mostly a case where expressing a division in politics helps; communalism is mostly harmful. Caste is a mixed case, with both positive and negative aspects.
Caste inequalities
Unlike gender and religion, caste division is special to India. Many societies pass occupations from one generation to the next, but the caste system is an extreme form: hereditary occupational division was sanctioned by rituals. Members of a caste were supposed to share an occupation, marry within the caste and not eat with other castes. The system was based on exclusion of and discrimination against 'outcaste' groups, who suffered untouchability. Reformers and leaders such as Jotiba Phule, Gandhiji, B. R. Ambedkar and Periyar Ramaswami Naicker worked for a society free of caste inequality.
Partly through their efforts and partly through economic development, urbanisation, literacy and education, occupational mobility and the weakening of landlords in villages, the old caste hierarchy is breaking down. The Constitution prohibits caste-based discrimination and laid foundations for policies to reverse its injustices. Yet caste has not disappeared: most people still marry within their caste or tribe; untouchability has not ended completely; and the effects of centuries of advantage and disadvantage continue. Groups with earlier access to education did well in modern education too, so 'upper castes' are disproportionately present in the urban middle class, and caste remains closely linked to economic status - for example, the textbook's survey data show that the share living below the poverty line is much higher among Scheduled Tribes and Scheduled Castes than among upper castes.
Caste in politics
- Parties keep the caste composition of the electorate in mind when choosing candidates, and try to include different castes and tribes in governments.
- Parties and candidates appeal to caste sentiment; some parties are seen as representing certain castes.
- Universal adult franchise and one-person-one-vote made leaders mobilise support widely and brought new consciousness among castes once treated as inferior.
Casteism, like communalism, wrongly treats caste as the sole basis of community. Elections are not only about caste: no parliamentary constituency has a clear majority of one caste, so candidates must win support across castes; no party wins all votes of a caste (a 'vote bank' usually means a large share, not all); several candidates may come from the same caste, while many voters have none from theirs; and ruling parties and sitting MPs or MLAs frequently lose, which could not happen if caste preferences were frozen. Party loyalty, economic interests, gender, government performance and leaders' popularity all matter.
Politics in caste
The influence also runs the other way: politics changes caste. It is not so much that politics gets caste-ridden as that caste gets politicised. Caste groups try to grow by including neighbouring castes or sub-castes; caste groups must form coalitions with others, which requires dialogue and negotiation; and new caste groupings such as 'backward' and 'forward' castes emerge in politics.
Caste in politics: two sides
-
Positive
- Gives disadvantaged communities space to demand a share of power
- Helped Dalits and OBCs gain better access to decision-making
- Movements for dignity, land and opportunity
-
Negative
- Politics based on caste identity alone is unhealthy
- Diverts attention from poverty, development and corruption
- Can cause tension, conflict and even violence
Caste in politics cuts both ways: it can give disadvantaged groups a voice and a share in power, but politics based on caste alone diverts attention from other issues and can breed conflict.
Worked example 1: two reasons caste alone does not decide elections
Question: Give two reasons why caste alone cannot decide election results in India. Reasoning and answer: (1) No constituency has a clear majority of one caste, so every candidate must win the trust of several castes and communities. (2) Voters of the same caste vote differently according to party loyalty, economic interests and their assessment of the government; that is why sitting governments and MPs often lose.
Worked example 2: matching identities
Question: Match: (1) a person who believes in equal rights for women and men; (2) one who says religion is the principal basis of community; (3) one who thinks caste is the principal basis of community; (4) one who does not discriminate on the basis of religious beliefs - with feminist, communalist, casteist, secularist. Answer: 1 - feminist; 2 - communalist; 3 - casteist; 4 - secularist.
Key takeaways: The caste system was a ritually sanctioned hereditary division with untouchability at its base. Reform movements, development, urbanisation and education have weakened it, but endogamy, traces of untouchability and links between caste and economic status persist. Caste affects candidate choice and appeals, but elections are not only about caste. Politics also changes caste, creating new groupings and coalitions. Caste politics has empowered disadvantaged groups but, used alone, can divert attention and cause conflict.
Check your understanding
-
1. What made the caste system different from occupational divisions in other societies?
- Occupations were never inherited
- Hereditary occupational division was sanctioned by rituals
- All castes ate together and intermarried
- It existed only in cities
Show answer
Answer: B. In the caste system hereditary occupational division was sanctioned by rituals, with marriage within the caste and restrictions on eating together.
-
2. Which factor has helped break down old notions of caste hierarchy?
- Growth of literacy, education and occupational mobility
- Stronger landlords in villages
- Banning education
- Ending urbanisation
Show answer
Answer: A. Economic development, urbanisation, literacy and education, occupational mobility and the weakening of landlords have weakened the old hierarchy.
-
3. Which statement about caste and elections is correct?
- Every constituency has a clear majority of one caste
- One party always wins all votes of a caste
- Sitting MPs and MLAs never lose
- No parliamentary constituency has a clear majority of one single caste
Show answer
Answer: D. Because no constituency has one caste in clear majority, candidates must win support across castes. Ruling parties and sitting members often lose.
-
4. Which is an example of 'politics in caste' (caste getting politicised)?
- A caste group incorporating neighbouring sub-castes to become bigger
- A party choosing a candidate by merit only
- A court banning untouchability
- The Census counting religions
Show answer
Answer: A. When caste groups expand by including other sub-castes, form coalitions or create new groupings like 'backward' and 'forward', caste is being politicised.
-
5. Assertion (A): Exclusive attention to caste in politics can produce negative results. Reason (R): It can divert attention from pressing issues like poverty, development and corruption, and sometimes lead to conflict.
- A is true, but R is false.
- A is false, but R is true.
- Both A and R are true, but R does not explain A.
- Both A and R are true, and R correctly explains A.
Show answer
Answer: D. The textbook explains that politics based on caste identity alone is unhealthy because it diverts attention from other issues and can cause tension and violence. R explains A.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.