- Foundation
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Religion and politics: understanding communalism
Distinguish acceptable links between religion and politics from communal politics, explain why the communal way of thinking is flawed, and describe the forms communalism takes in politics.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Give examples of a relationship between religion and politics that is not harmful.
- Define communalism and explain why its central belief is flawed.
- Describe four forms that communalism can take in politics.
Religious diversity is widespread in the world, and many countries, including India, have followers of different religions. Unlike gender differences, religious differences are often expressed in politics. The question is: when is that healthy, and when does it become dangerous?
Religion and politics: not always a problem
Consider three examples from the textbook. Gandhiji said religion can never be separated from politics; by religion he meant not any particular faith but the moral values common to all religions, and he believed politics must be guided by ethics. Human rights groups have asked the government to take special steps to prevent communal riots and protect religious minorities. The women's movement has argued that family laws of all religions discriminate against women and asked for them to be made more equitable. Each links religion and politics, yet none seems wrong. People may express needs and demands as members of a religious community, ideas from religions may guide politics, and those in power may regulate religious practice to prevent discrimination - as long as every religion is treated equally.
What is communalism?
The problem begins when religion is seen as the basis of the nation, and becomes acute when religion is expressed in politics in exclusive and partisan terms: when one religion's beliefs are presented as superior, when one group's demands are framed against another's, and when state power is used to establish the domination of one religious group over others. This is communal politics. It rests on the idea that religion is the principal basis of social community: followers of one religion form one community with the same fundamental interests, and followers of different religions cannot belong to the same community. In its extreme form it holds that people of different religions cannot live as equal citizens in one nation - one must dominate, or they must form separate nations.
Communalism is the belief that religion is the principal basis of community. It is flawed because people of one religion have many other identities and many different voices and interests.
This belief is fundamentally flawed. People of one religion do not have the same interests in every context; each person has many roles, positions and identities, and every community has many voices with a right to be heard. Trying to unite all followers of a religion in non-religious matters suppresses many of those voices.
Forms of communalism in politics
Forms of communalism
- Everyday beliefs Prejudices, stereotypes, belief in one's religion's superiority - often unnoticed.
- Quest for political dominance Majoritarian dominance, or a minority's wish for a separate political unit.
- Political mobilisation on religious lines Sacred symbols, religious leaders, emotional appeal and fear to unite voters of one religion.
- Communal violence Riots and massacres, as at Partition and later.
Worked example 1: healthy link or communalism?
Cases (made up): (a) A group asks the government to make all religions' family laws fairer to women. (b) A speaker tells a crowd that followers of another faith are a threat and must be kept out of the town. Reasoning: (a) seeks equality and applies to all religions equally - acceptable. (b) presents one community as opposed to another, uses fear and seeks exclusion - communal. Answer: (a) is a healthy link between religion and politics; (b) is communalism.
Worked example 2: identifying the form
Question: A person often repeats jokes and generalisations that portray one religious community as inferior, without any political aim. Which form of communalism is this? Reasoning: it involves prejudice and stereotypes held in daily life, not a demand for power or violence. Answer: communalism in everyday beliefs, the most common form, which people often fail to notice in themselves.
Key takeaways: Religion and politics can be linked acceptably when values guide politics, communities express demands, or the state prevents discrimination, provided all religions are treated equally. Communalism treats religion as the principal basis of community and nation and pits one religion against another; it is flawed because people have many identities and voices. It appears as everyday prejudice, quests for dominance, religious mobilisation and, at worst, violence.
Check your understanding
-
1. What did Gandhiji mean by saying religion can never be separated from politics?
- Politics should be run by one religion
- Politics must be guided by moral values common to all religions
- Religious leaders should hold all offices
- Elections should be held in places of worship
Show answer
Answer: B. By religion Gandhiji meant the moral values that inform all religions, not any particular religion, and he wanted politics guided by such ethics.
-
2. Communal politics is based on the belief that:
- people of all religions are equal citizens
- religion is the principal basis of social community
- the state must treat all religions equally
- caste is the only identity
Show answer
Answer: B. Communalism holds that religion is the principal basis of community, so followers of one religion form one community with the same interests.
-
3. Which is the most common expression of communalism, according to the textbook?
- Everyday beliefs such as religious prejudices and stereotypes
- Communal riots
- Formation of separate countries
- Constitutional amendments
Show answer
Answer: A. The most common form is in everyday beliefs - prejudices, stereotypes and belief in one's religion's superiority - often so common that it goes unnoticed.
-
4. Using sacred symbols, religious leaders and emotional appeals to bring followers of one religion together in elections is an example of:
- secularism
- feminism
- local self-government
- political mobilisation on religious lines
Show answer
Answer: D. This is political mobilisation on religious lines, a frequent form of communalism in electoral politics.
-
5. Assertion (A): The communal belief that all followers of a religion have the same interests is flawed. Reason (R): Every person has many roles and identities, and every community has many voices.
- Both A and R are true, and R correctly explains A.
- Both A and R are true, but R does not explain A.
- A is true, but R is false.
- A is false, but R is true.
Show answer
Answer: A. Because people within a religion differ by class, gender, region, occupation and views, they do not share one set of interests. R explains A.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.