• Foundation
  • About 17 min
  • 5 practice questions

Formal and informal sources of credit

Compare the terms of credit offered by banks, cooperatives, moneylenders, traders and employers, understand the RBI's supervision, and see why cheap credit must reach the poor.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Classify sources of credit into formal and informal.
  • Explain how the RBI supervises formal lenders and why no one supervises informal lenders.
  • Explain why formal credit needs to expand and reach poor households.

Who lends money in a typical Indian village, and on what terms? The chapter follows two students who interview people in a village it calls Sonpur. Their findings show that the terms of credit depend heavily on who is lending and who is borrowing.

Credit in a village

Sources and terms of credit in the textbook's example village
BorrowerLenderTerms (as described in the textbook)
Small farmer with 1.5 acresVillage moneylender earlier; now an agricultural traderMoneylender: 5% per month. Trader: 3% per month, inputs on credit, and the farmer must sell the crop to the trader
Farmer with 7 acresBank8.5% per year, repayable within three years; can take a fresh loan against a cold storage receipt
Landless agricultural labourerHer landowner-employer5% per month, repaid by working for him; she takes new loans before old ones are repaid
Members of a farmers' cooperativeThe cooperativeCheap loans for implements, cultivation, fishery, housing and other needs

Notice how the small farmer loses twice to the trader: he pays interest, and he must sell his crop to the trader right after harvest when prices are low, while the trader sells later when prices have risen. The landless labourer's debt keeps rising and she continues working for an employer who treats her badly because he is her only source of loans. Only the larger farmer, who can offer security, gets a cheap bank loan.

Cooperatives

Besides banks, cooperative societies are a major source of cheap credit in rural areas. Members pool their resources: there are farmers' cooperatives, weavers' cooperatives, industrial workers' cooperatives and others. A cooperative accepts deposits from its members and, using these as collateral, can get a large loan from a bank, which it lends to members. When those loans are repaid, another round of lending can take place.

Formal and informal sectors

Two sectors of credit

  • Formal sector
    • Banks and cooperatives
    • Supervised by the RBI
    • Lower interest rates
    • Need collateral and documents
  • Informal sector
    • Moneylenders, traders, employers, relatives and friends
    • No supervising organisation
    • Usually much higher interest
    • May use unfair means to recover money

The RBI supervises formal lenders. It checks that banks actually maintain the minimum cash balance out of deposits, and it sees that banks lend not only to profit-making businesses and traders but also to small cultivators, small-scale industries and small borrowers. Banks must report to the RBI periodically on how much they lend, to whom and at what interest rate. No organisation supervises informal lenders. They can charge whatever interest they choose, and nobody stops them from using unfair means to recover money.

Formal credit (banks, cooperatives) is supervised by the RBI and is usually cheaper; informal credit (moneylenders, traders, employers, relatives, friends) is unsupervised and usually much more expensive.

Why the cost of credit matters

Higher interest means a larger part of the borrower's earnings goes to repaying the loan, leaving less income. Sometimes the amount to be repaid is greater than the borrower's income, leading to growing debt and a debt trap. People who want to start an enterprise may not borrow at all because of the high cost. Cheap and affordable credit is therefore crucial for the country's development.

Worked example 1: how much is left?

Data (illustrative): A vendor borrows Rs 5,000 for a month to buy stock and earns Rs 7,000 from selling it. Informal loan at 10% a month: repays 5,000 + 500 = 5,500; keeps 7,000 − 5,500 = Rs 1,500. Formal loan at 1% a month: repays 5,000 + 50 = 5,050; keeps 7,000 − 5,050 = Rs 1,950. The cheaper loan leaves the vendor Rs 450 more in a single month.

Who gets formal credit?

According to the textbook's data on urban households, poor households took more than half of their loans from informal sources, while rich households took most of theirs from formal sources; a similar pattern is found in rural areas. So the rich get cheap credit while the poor pay a lot for borrowing. Two things follow: formal credit must expand, especially in rural areas, so that dependence on informal lenders falls; and formal credit must be distributed more equally so that the poor benefit from cheaper loans.

Worked example 2: reading a source

Source (summarised): In the village, only the farmer with seven acres got a bank loan. Question: Why might banks lend to him but not to the landless labourer? Answer: He owns land and a crop that can serve as collateral and has a clear way to repay; the labourer has no assets and irregular income. Banks demand collateral, which not everyone can provide.

Key takeaways: Credit comes from formal sources (banks, cooperatives), supervised by the RBI, and informal sources (moneylenders, traders, employers, relatives, friends), which are unsupervised and usually costlier. High-cost credit reduces income and can cause debt traps. Formal credit must expand and reach the poor, who today depend mostly on informal lenders.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which of the following is an informal source of credit?

    1. A commercial bank
    2. An employer who lends to his workers
    3. A farmers' cooperative
    4. A cooperative bank
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Employers, moneylenders, traders, relatives and friends are informal lenders. Banks and cooperatives are formal sources supervised by the RBI.

  2. 2. Which is one way the RBI supervises banks?

    1. It fixes the price of crops
    2. It lends directly to farmers in every village
    3. It checks that banks maintain a minimum cash balance and lend to small borrowers too
    4. It supervises moneylenders
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The RBI monitors banks' cash balances and sees that they lend to small cultivators, small industries and small borrowers, not only to big businesses. It does not supervise informal lenders.

  3. 3. A trader gives a small farmer inputs on credit on the condition that the farmer sells him the crop at harvest. Why is this unfavourable for the farmer?

    1. He can sell to anyone he likes
    2. He gets the inputs free
    3. The trader pays more than the market price
    4. He must sell when prices are low, while the trader profits by selling later at higher prices
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Crop prices are low just after harvest. Forced to sell to the trader then, the farmer loses, while the trader stores and sells later when prices rise, on top of charging interest.

  4. 4. According to the textbook, how do the sources of loans differ between poor and rich urban households?

    1. Poor households depend more on informal sources; rich households mostly on formal sources
    2. Both depend mostly on informal sources
    3. Rich households depend more on moneylenders
    4. Neither takes loans
    Show answer

    Answer: A. More than half of poor households' loans are informal, while most of rich households' loans are formal, so the poor pay much more for credit.

  5. 5. Assertion (A): Informal lenders often charge very high interest rates. Reason (R): No organisation supervises the credit activities of informal lenders.

    1. A is true but R is false
    2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
    3. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
    4. A is false but R is true
    Show answer

    Answer: C. With no supervisor (R), informal lenders can charge whatever rate they choose and use unfair means to recover money, which is why their rates are often very high (A).

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery