• Foundation
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

Self-help groups and credit for the poor

Understand why the poor find it hard to get bank loans, how self-help groups pool savings and overcome the lack of collateral, and what the Grameen Bank of Bangladesh showed.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain why poor households depend on informal credit.
  • Describe how a self-help group (SHG) works and how it helps members get bank loans.
  • Explain the social as well as economic benefits of SHGs and the lesson of the Grameen Bank.

If formal credit is cheaper, why do poor families still go to moneylenders? And what can be done about it? This lesson looks at one of the most important answers tried in recent decades: organising the poor, especially women, into self-help groups.

Why the poor depend on informal lenders

Banks are not present everywhere in rural India. Even where they are, getting a bank loan is harder than borrowing informally: banks need proper documents and collateral, and the absence of collateral is one of the major reasons the poor cannot get bank loans. Moneylenders know borrowers personally and often lend without collateral; a borrower can even approach them again before repaying an earlier loan. But moneylenders charge very high interest, keep no records and harass poor borrowers.

How a self-help group works

The idea is to organise the rural poor, particularly women, into small Self Help Groups (SHGs) and pool their savings. According to the textbook, a typical SHG has 15-20 members, usually from one neighbourhood, who meet and save regularly; each saves a small amount according to their ability. Members can take small loans from the group, which charges interest, but less than a moneylender.

How an SHG grows

  1. Women form a group 15-20 members from one neighbourhood
  2. Save regularly Small, regular contributions are pooled
  3. Lend within the group Small loans at lower interest than moneylenders
  4. Become bank-eligible After a year or two of regular saving
  5. Bank loan in the group's name For members' self-employment

After a year or two, if the group saves regularly, it becomes eligible for a bank loan, sanctioned in the name of the group and meant to create self-employment for members. Loans may be for releasing mortgaged land, for working capital (seeds, fertilisers, bamboo, cloth), for housing materials, or for assets such as a sewing machine, handloom or cattle.

The members take most of the important decisions: which loans to give, for what purpose, how much, at what interest and on what repayment schedule. The group is responsible for repayment; if any member fails to repay, the others follow it up seriously. Because of this, banks are willing to lend to poor women organised in SHGs even though they have no collateral.

Self-help groups help the poor overcome the lack of collateral: the group's regular savings and its shared responsibility for repayment make banks willing to lend to members who own no assets.

Worked example 1: the savings add up

Data (illustrative): An SHG has 18 members, each saving Rs 50 a month. Working: In one month the group saves 18 × 50 = Rs 900. In one year it saves 900 × 12 = Rs 10,800. From this pool, one member can borrow Rs 3,000 to buy a goat or bamboo for baskets, paying interest to the group, which is lower than the moneylender's rate. After regular saving, the group can seek a larger bank loan.

More than money

SHGs are the building blocks of organisation of the rural poor. Besides helping women become financially self-reliant, the regular meetings provide a platform to discuss and act on social issues such as health, nutrition and domestic violence.

Benefits of self-help groups

  • Economic
    • Timely loans at reasonable interest
    • No collateral needed for group loans
    • Self-employment through small enterprises
  • Social
    • Women become financially self-reliant
    • Platform for issues like health and nutrition
    • Collective strength and confidence

The Grameen Bank of Bangladesh

The Grameen Bank of Bangladesh is one of the biggest success stories in meeting the credit needs of the poor at reasonable rates. It began in the 1970s as a small project and grew to reach millions of members across Bangladesh. Almost all its borrowers are women from the poorest sections of society. They have shown that poor women are reliable borrowers who can start and run a variety of small income-generating activities. Its founder, Professor Muhammad Yunus, received the Nobel Peace Prize in 2006. His central idea was that if the poor can get credit on appropriate and reasonable terms, their many small enterprises can together achieve a great deal of development.

Worked example 2: deciding where to borrow

Case: Lata wants to start a tailoring business and needs Rs 8,000. She has no land. Options: a moneylender (quick, no collateral, very high interest) or her SHG (lower interest, needs her to be a regular saver, decided by the group). Reasoning: The moneylender's high interest would eat into her small profits and could trap her in debt. The SHG gives cheaper credit and support from other members. Better choice: the SHG, which is exactly the need SHGs were designed to meet.

Key takeaways: The poor depend on costly informal credit mainly because they lack collateral and banks are far away. SHGs pool small savings, lend within the group and, after a period of regular saving, obtain bank loans without collateral because the group takes responsibility for repayment. SHGs also empower women socially. The Grameen Bank showed that poor women are reliable borrowers.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. What is one of the major reasons that prevents the poor from getting bank loans?

    1. Absence of collateral
    2. They do not need credit
    3. Banks charge more than moneylenders
    4. Banks lend only to women
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Banks require documents and collateral. Many poor households have no assets to offer as collateral, so they turn to informal lenders.

  2. 2. In an SHG, who takes most of the decisions about savings and loans?

    1. The bank
    2. The members of the group
    3. The moneylender
    4. The government
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Members decide which loans to grant, the purpose, amount, interest and repayment schedule; the group is responsible for repayment.

  3. 3. Why are banks willing to lend to poor women organised in SHGs even without collateral?

    1. The government repays all such loans
    2. SHG loans carry no interest
    3. The group is responsible for repayment and members follow up any default
    4. Banks are required to lend without checks
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Shared responsibility for repayment and the group's record of regular saving give the bank confidence, so the group overcomes the lack of collateral.

  4. 4. An SHG has 15 members who each save Rs 60 a month. How much does the group save in 6 months?

    1. Rs 900
    2. Rs 10,800
    3. Rs 3,600
    4. Rs 5,400
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Monthly saving = 15 × 60 = Rs 900. In 6 months = 900 × 6 = Rs 5,400.

  5. 5. Assertion (A): Self-help groups have social benefits besides providing credit. Reason (R): Their regular meetings give women a platform to discuss issues such as health, nutrition and domestic violence.

    1. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
    2. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
    3. A is true but R is false
    4. A is false but R is true
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Because the groups meet regularly and act together on social issues (R), SHGs benefit women socially as well as financially (A).

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery