- Foundation
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Consumer rights: safety, information and choice
Learn the right to safety, the right to be informed (including labels, MRP and the Right to Information Act) and the right to choose, with examples of how each is denied and upheld.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain the right to safety with examples of goods and services that need safety rules.
- Explain the right to be informed, including product labels, MRP and the RTI Act.
- Explain the right to choose and identify situations where choice is denied.
The law recognises several rights of consumers. This lesson covers three of them, safety, information and choice, using cases of the kind that reach consumer commissions. The next lesson covers the remaining rights.
The right to safety
While using many goods and services, consumers have the right to be protected against the marketing of goods and delivery of services that are hazardous to life and property. Producers must strictly follow safety rules. A pressure cooker, for example, has a safety valve; if it is defective it can cause a serious accident, so its makers must ensure high quality, and public or government action is needed to see that quality is maintained. Yet poor-quality products still reach the market because supervision is weak and the consumer movement is not strong enough.
Services can be unsafe too. The textbook describes a case in which a schoolboy was crippled for life because of negligence in giving anaesthesia during a minor operation at a private hospital. His father's complaint was first dismissed at the state level for lack of evidence, but on appeal the National Commission held the hospital responsible for medical negligence and ordered it to pay compensation.
| Good or service (examples) | Safety rule the producer should follow |
|---|---|
| LPG cylinder | Leak-proof valve, regular testing, correct weight |
| Cinema hall | Fire exits kept open, fire extinguishers, no overcrowding |
| Medicines | Correct composition, expiry date, warnings on side effects |
| High-rise building | Approved design, fire safety, safe lifts |
The right to be informed
Packaged goods carry details such as ingredients, price, batch number, date of manufacture, expiry date and the manufacturer's address. Medicines carry directions for use and information on side effects; garments carry washing instructions. Rules require this because consumers have the right to be informed about the particulars of goods and services they buy. With this information they can complain and ask for compensation or replacement if a product is defective, for instance a product that fails within its expiry period. Selling expired medicines invites severe action. One can also protest if a good is sold above the MRP (maximum retail price) printed on it; in fact consumers may bargain to pay less than the MRP.
MRP is the maximum retail price: a seller may not charge more than this printed price, though a buyer may bargain to pay less.
The right to information now also covers services provided by the government. The Right to Information (RTI) Act, which came into force in October 2005, entitles citizens to information about the functioning of government departments. The textbook describes an engineering graduate who heard nothing after a government job interview; using an RTI application she learnt the reasons for the delay and also received her appointment letter.
The right to choose
Any consumer who receives a service, regardless of age, gender or the nature of the service, has the right to choose whether to continue receiving it. The textbook describes a student who paid two years' fees in advance to a coaching institute, left after one year because the teaching was poor, and was refused a refund. The District Commission ordered a partial refund, holding that she had the right to choose; the State Commission upheld this, fined the institute for a frivolous appeal and ordered compensation, and also barred institutions in that state from charging the whole course's fees in advance at one go.
Choice is also denied in everyday ways: a shopkeeper who sells toothpaste only if you also buy a toothbrush, or a gas dealer who insists you buy a stove from him with a new connection, forces you to buy what you may not want.
Three consumer rights in this lesson
-
Right to safety
- Protection from hazardous goods and services
- Producers must follow safety rules
-
Right to be informed
- Labels: ingredients, price, dates, batch, address
- MRP
- RTI Act for government services
-
Right to choose
- Freedom to continue or stop a service
- No forced tie-in purchases
Worked example 1: which right is involved?
| Case (made up) | Right involved | Reason |
|---|---|---|
| A new electric kettle gives Ali a shock | Safety | The product is hazardous to life |
| A biscuit packet has no expiry date | Information | The buyer cannot judge freshness or complain |
| A shop sells notebooks only if pens are also bought | Choice | The buyer is forced into an unwanted purchase |
| A citizen asks why a ration card application is delayed | Information (RTI) | Information about a government service |
Worked example 2: overcharging
Case (made up): A soft drink has an MRP of Rs 40, and a shop at a railway station charges Rs 50. Question: What can the consumer do? Answer: Selling above the MRP is not allowed, so she can refuse to pay more than Rs 40, ask for a bill and complain; if the problem continues, a consumer group or the appropriate authority can act. The printed MRP is information the law requires precisely so that such overcharging can be challenged.
Key takeaways: Consumers have the right to safety from hazardous goods and services; the right to be informed through labels, MRP and, for government services, the RTI Act; and the right to choose, which is denied by forced purchases or refusal to let a person leave a service. Each right is upheld when consumers know it and act on it.
Check your understanding
-
1. A pressure cooker's safety valve is defective and causes an accident. Which consumer right has been violated?
- Right to choose
- Right to representation
- Right to safety
- Right to consumer education
Show answer
Answer: C. Consumers have the right to be protected from goods hazardous to life and property; a defective safety valve endangers both.
-
2. Why do rules require manufacturers to print details such as expiry date, batch number and address on packets?
- To make packets look attractive
- Because the RTI Act requires it
- To raise prices
- Because consumers have the right to be informed and can then complain or seek replacement
Show answer
Answer: D. The right to information lets consumers judge goods and, if a product is defective within its expiry period, claim replacement from the identified maker.
-
3. What does MRP printed on a packet mean?
- The maximum retail price; the seller cannot charge more, though the buyer may bargain for less
- The minimum price a seller must charge
- The manufacturer's profit
- The price fixed by the RTI Act
Show answer
Answer: A. MRP is the maximum retail price; charging above it can be challenged, and consumers may pay less if they can bargain.
-
4. A gas agency insists that a customer buy a stove from it to get a new cooking gas connection. Which right is denied?
- Right to safety
- Right to choose
- Right to redressal
- Right to information
Show answer
Answer: B. Forcing a buyer to purchase something he does not want, as a condition of the sale, denies the right to choose.
-
5. Assertion (A): The RTI Act extended the right to information to services provided by the government. Reason (R): It entitles citizens to information about the functioning of government departments.
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- A is false but R is true
- A is true but R is false
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
Show answer
Answer: D. Because citizens can now obtain information about how government departments work (R), the right to information covers government services as well (A).
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.