• Foundation
  • About 14 min
  • 5 practice questions

The consumer in the marketplace

Understand why individual consumers are often in a weak position, the ways they are exploited in the market, and why rules and regulations are needed to protect them.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain who a consumer is and why consumers are often in a weak position.
  • Identify common forms of exploitation and unfair trade practices.
  • Explain why rules and regulations are needed in the marketplace.

We take part in the market in two ways: as producers, working in agriculture, industry or services, and as consumers, buying the goods and services we need. This chapter looks at us as consumers. Earlier chapters showed why rules are needed to protect unorganised workers and borrowers from moneylenders; consumers need protection too.

Why consumers are often weak

Individual consumers often find themselves in a weak position. When a buyer complains about a good or service, the seller frequently tries to shift all responsibility onto the buyer, as if the seller had no responsibility once the sale was over: "If you didn't like it, go elsewhere." The consumer movement is an effort to change this attitude.

Markets also do not work fairly when producers are few and powerful while consumers buy in small amounts and are scattered. This happens especially when large companies produce the goods: with huge wealth, power and reach, they can manipulate the market, for example by spreading false information through the media to attract consumers.

Forms of exploitation

How consumers can be exploited

  • Unfair trade practices
    • Weighing or measuring less than promised
    • Adding charges not mentioned before
    • Selling adulterated or defective goods
  • Misleading information
    • False or exaggerated claims in advertisements
    • Hiding risks of a product
  • Unequal power
    • Few powerful producers, many scattered buyers
    • Seller refuses responsibility after sale

The chapter gives two well-known examples of false information. A company sold powdered milk for babies around the world for years, claiming it was more scientific and better than mother's milk; it took years of struggle to make it accept that the claim was false. Similarly, a long battle with court cases was needed before cigarette companies accepted that their product could cause cancer.

Because individual consumers are scattered and weak while sellers may be powerful, rules and regulations are needed to protect consumers in the marketplace.

Worked example 1: spotting the unfair practice

What happened (made-up cases)Type of exploitation
A vegetable seller uses a stone instead of a proper weight and gives 900 g for 1 kgWeighing less (unfair trade practice)
A restaurant adds a "service charge" that was not shown on the menuAdding charges not mentioned before
A shop sells chilli powder mixed with brick dustAdulteration
An advertisement claims a drink makes children taller in a monthFalse or misleading information

Worked example 2: why one consumer struggles alone

Situation (made up): A big company sells lakhs of bottles of hair oil. One bottle that Kavita bought leaks and stains her clothes. Question: Why is it hard for her to get justice on her own? Reasoning: The loss to her is small; the company is large and far away; the shopkeeper says it is the company's problem; and complaining costs time and money. Each consumer's loss is small, so few complain, and the company has little reason to improve. Conclusion: This imbalance is why rules, organisations and a simple system of complaint are needed.

Two sides of a sale

  • Large seller
    • Few in number, often powerful
    • Controls information about the product
    • Can afford lawyers and advertising
  • Individual consumer
    • Many and scattered
    • Buys in small amounts
    • Finds complaining costly and slow

Rules may exist and still not be followed: inspection may be weak, consumers may be unaware of their rights, and sellers may expect that few people will complain. This is why consumers' own awareness and organised action matter.

Key takeaways: Consumers buy final goods and services but are often in a weak position: sellers may shift responsibility, cheat on weight or charges, sell adulterated or defective goods, or spread false information. Markets are especially unfair when a few powerful producers face many scattered buyers. Hence the need for rules and regulations, and for an active consumer movement.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which of the following is an unfair trade practice?

    1. A shopkeeper weighing less than what the customer pays for
    2. Printing the expiry date on a medicine
    3. Giving a bill for every purchase
    4. Selling at less than the MRP
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Weighing less than promised cheats the buyer, which is an unfair trade practice. The other actions are fair or protect the consumer.

  2. 2. When does the market tend to work in an unfair way, according to the chapter?

    1. When there are many small sellers and few buyers
    2. When producers are few and powerful while consumers buy in small amounts and are scattered
    3. When prices are printed on goods
    4. When consumers know their rights
    Show answer

    Answer: B. A few powerful producers with huge wealth and reach can manipulate the market, while scattered consumers buying small amounts have little power.

  3. 3. Why did the chapter mention the long struggle over a baby milk powder and over cigarettes?

    1. As examples of products that are always safe
    2. As examples of government-run industries
    3. As examples of companies spreading false information that took years to correct
    4. As examples of fair advertising
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Both show how powerful companies passed on false information and how long it took to make them accept the truth, which shows why consumer protection is needed.

  4. 4. A trader mixes water in milk before selling it. This is an example of:

    1. Redressal
    2. Right to choice
    3. Fair trade
    4. Adulteration
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Mixing an inferior or foreign substance into a product is adulteration, one of the common forms of exploitation.

  5. 5. Assertion (A): Rules and regulations are needed to protect consumers. Reason (R): Individual consumers are often in a weak position compared to sellers.

    1. A is true but R is false
    2. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
    3. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
    4. A is false but R is true
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Because consumers are weak and scattered (R), they cannot protect themselves alone, so rules and regulations are needed (A).

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery