- Foundation
- About 20 min
- 5 practice questions
What photosynthesis is and the experiments that revealed it
Define photosynthesis, explain what simple leaf experiments show, trace the discoveries of Priestley, Ingenhousz, Sachs, Engelmann and van Niel, and write the balanced overall equation.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Define photosynthesis and explain why all life depends on it.
- Interpret the variegated-leaf, black-paper and KOH experiments.
- State what each early scientist added to our understanding.
- Write the overall equation and explain why 12 molecules of water appear on the left.
Every bite of food you eat can be traced back to a green plant. Green plants are autotrophs: they build their own organic food from simple inorganic raw materials. Animals, fungi and most bacteria are heterotrophs that depend, directly or indirectly, on those plants. Photosynthesis is the physico-chemical process by which green plants use light energy to drive the synthesis of organic compounds such as glucose. It matters for two reasons: it is the primary source of all food on Earth, and it releases the oxygen that aerobic organisms breathe.
What simple experiments already tell us
From earlier classes you know three requirements: chlorophyll, light and carbon dioxide. Each was shown with a starch test, because the glucose made in a leaf is quickly stored as starch, which turns blue-black with iodine.
- Variegated leaf (green and white patches) kept in light: only the green patches test positive for starch. So chlorophyll is needed.
- Leaf partly covered with black paper: the covered part shows no starch. So light is needed.
- Half a leaf sealed in a tube with KOH-soaked cotton: KOH absorbs CO₂, and the enclosed half shows no starch while the half in open air does. So CO₂ is needed.
In each case only one condition differs between the two parts of the same leaf, so the difference in starch can be blamed on that one condition. This is the logic of a controlled experiment.
The early experiments, in order
| Scientist | What was done (in outline) | Conclusion |
|---|---|---|
| Joseph Priestley (1770) | Candle or mouse in a closed bell jar, with and without a mint plant | Plants restore to the air whatever burning candles and breathing animals remove |
| Jan Ingenhousz | Same set-up in light and in dark; watched an aquatic plant in sunlight | Sunlight is essential; only green parts release the bubbles, later shown to be oxygen |
| Julius von Sachs (about 1854) | Studied growing plants | Green parts make glucose, usually stored as starch; chlorophyll is located in special bodies, later called chloroplasts |
| T. W. Engelmann | Split light with a prism onto the green alga *Cladophora* with aerobic bacteria around it | Bacteria gathered in blue and red light: the first action spectrum of photosynthesis |
| Cornelius van Niel | Compared green plants with purple and green sulphur bacteria | Photosynthesis uses hydrogen from an oxidisable compound to reduce CO₂; in plants the O₂ comes from water |
How the picture of photosynthesis was built up
- Plants 'restore' air Priestley: a plant keeps a candle burning and a mouse alive in a closed jar.
- Light is essential Ingenhousz: the effect happens only in sunlight and only in green parts.
- Glucose and starch are made Sachs: green parts make glucose; chlorophyll sits in chloroplasts.
- Red and blue light work best Engelmann: aerobic bacteria crowd where O₂ is released.
- O₂ comes from water van Niel: the hydrogen donor is oxidised; in plants that donor is H₂O.
From the empirical equation to the correct one
By the middle of the nineteenth century the overall change was written as CO₂ + H₂O → [CH₂O] + O₂ (in light), where [CH₂O] stands for a unit of carbohydrate. Van Niel generalised it as 2H₂A + CO₂ → 2A + CH₂O + H₂O (in light). For purple and green sulphur bacteria the donor H₂A is H₂S, so the oxidised product A is sulphur, not oxygen. By analogy, in green plants H₂A is H₂O and A is oxygen. Radioisotope experiments later confirmed that the O₂ released comes from water.
6CO₂ + 12H₂O → C₆H₁₂O₆ + 6H₂O + 6O₂ (in the presence of light and chlorophyll). The oxygen released comes from water, and the equation summarises a multistep process, not a single reaction.
Worked example 1: why 12 molecules of water?
Six O₂ molecules contain 12 oxygen atoms. Since all the released oxygen comes from water, and each H₂O has one oxygen atom, 12 H₂O must be split. Splitting 12 H₂O also gives 24 hydrogen atoms. Glucose takes 12 of them, and the remaining 12 hydrogen atoms combine with 6 of the oxygen atoms from CO₂ to form 6 new H₂O on the right. Check the oxygen count: left side 6 × 2 (from CO₂) + 12 = 24; right side 6 (in glucose) + 6 (in water) + 12 (in O₂) = 24. Balanced.
Worked example 2: reading the KOH experiment
A student repeats the KOH set-up but forgets the KOH, so both halves of the leaf are in normal air. Both halves now test positive for starch. Reasoning: the only difference that the original set-up created was the absence of CO₂ inside the tube. Without KOH that difference disappears, so the experiment no longer tests anything. Lesson: the control and the test must differ in exactly one condition.
Key takeaways: photosynthesis converts light energy into chemical energy stored in sugar and releases O₂. Leaf experiments show that chlorophyll, light and CO₂ are needed. Priestley, Ingenhousz, Sachs, Engelmann and van Niel each added a piece; van Niel's insight that the O₂ comes from water explains why the balanced equation has 12 H₂O on the left and 6 H₂O on the right.
Check your understanding
-
1. In the half-leaf experiment, why is KOH-soaked cotton placed inside the tube?
- To supply extra water to the leaf
- To absorb CO₂ from the air around the enclosed part
- To absorb oxygen released by the leaf
- To kill bacteria on the leaf surface
Show answer
Answer: B. KOH absorbs carbon dioxide. The enclosed half therefore has no CO₂ and makes no starch, while the half in air does. Comparing the two halves shows that CO₂ is needed for photosynthesis.
-
2. Engelmann's experiment with Cladophora and aerobic bacteria gave the first
- absorption spectrum of chlorophyll b
- proof that O₂ comes from water
- action spectrum of photosynthesis
- evidence that glucose is stored as starch
Show answer
Answer: C. Aerobic bacteria crowded where oxygen was being released, which was mainly in blue and red light. Plotting photosynthetic activity against wavelength is an action spectrum, and this was the first one described.
-
3. Purple sulphur bacteria use H₂S as the hydrogen donor. According to van Niel's general equation, what do they release instead of oxygen?
- Sulphur or sulphate
- Carbon dioxide
- Hydrogen gas
- Methane
Show answer
Answer: A. In 2H₂A + CO₂ → 2A + CH₂O + H₂O, A is what is left when hydrogen is removed from the donor. With H₂S as donor, A is sulphur (or, in some bacteria, sulphate). With H₂O as donor, A is oxygen.
-
4. Assertion (A): In the balanced equation of photosynthesis, 12 molecules of water appear as reactant.
Reason (R): All the oxygen released in photosynthesis comes from water, and 6 molecules of O₂ need 12 oxygen atoms.- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- A is true, but R is false
- A is false, but R is true
Show answer
Answer: A. Both statements are true. Six O₂ contain 12 oxygen atoms; since each comes from a water molecule, 12 H₂O must be split. So R correctly explains A.
-
5. Which scientist showed that green parts of plants make glucose and that chlorophyll is located in special bodies inside the cell?
- Joseph Priestley
- Jan Ingenhousz
- Cornelius van Niel
- Julius von Sachs
Show answer
Answer: D. Julius von Sachs (around 1854) showed that glucose is made in the green parts and usually stored as starch, and that chlorophyll lies in special bodies later called chloroplasts.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.