- Foundation
- About 17 min
- 5 practice questions
Joint stock company: features, merits and limitations
Explain the company as an artificial person with separate legal entity, perpetual succession and limited liability, calculate a shareholder's liability, and evaluate the merits and limitations of the company form.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain the features of a joint stock company under the Companies Act, 2013.
- Calculate the limit of a shareholder's liability on partly paid shares.
- Evaluate the merits and limitations of the company form.
When a business needs very large capital, professional managers and a life beyond its founders, it usually takes the company form. A company is unlike the other forms because the law treats it as a person in its own right.
Meaning
A company is an association of persons formed for business with a legal status independent of its members. It is described as an artificial person with a separate legal entity, perpetual succession and a common seal. It is governed by the Companies Act, 2013; under section 2(20), a company means one incorporated under this Act or any previous company law. Shareholders own the company; the Board of Directors, elected by them, is the chief managing body. Capital is divided into shares, freely transferable except in a private company.
A company is an artificial person created by law, with an identity separate from its members, perpetual succession, limited liability of members and management by an elected Board of Directors.
Features
- Artificial person: created by law; can own property, borrow, contract, sue and be sued, but cannot breathe, eat or talk.
- Separate legal entity: from incorporation its assets and liabilities are distinct from its owners'.
- Formation: time-consuming, expensive and complicated; incorporation is compulsory.
- Perpetual succession: members come and go but the company continues until it is wound up by law.
- Control: by the Board of Directors, accountable to shareholders; shareholders do not run day-to-day affairs.
- Limited liability: members are liable only up to the unpaid amount on their shares.
- Risk bearing: risk is spread over all shareholders.
Company form: merits and limitations
-
Merits
- Limited liability
- Easy transfer of interest (public company shares can be sold)
- Perpetual existence
- Scope for expansion: public capital and loans
- Professional management and specialisation
-
Limitations
- Complexity in formation
- Lack of secrecy: reports go to the Registrar
- Impersonal work environment
- Numerous regulations (Registrar, SEBI)
- Delay in decision making
- Oligarchic management: rule by a few directors
- Conflict of interests among stakeholders
Oligarchic management needs a word of explanation. In theory a company is democratic because directors represent shareholders. In practice, in large companies with shareholders spread across the country and few attending meetings, the Board enjoys great freedom; a dissatisfied shareholder's main option is to sell and exit. The book calls this rule by a few. Conflict of interests arises because employees want higher pay, consumers want better goods at lower prices and shareholders want higher dividends and share value.
Worked example 1: liability on partly paid shares
Illustrative: a made-up shareholder, Tara, holds 1,500 shares of ₹10 each on which ₹6 per share has been paid. The company fails. Working: unpaid amount per share = 10 - 6 = ₹4. Maximum further liability = 1,500 × 4 = ₹6,000. Beyond ₹6,000 she cannot be asked to pay anything, and her personal property is safe. If the shares were fully paid (₹10 paid), her further liability would be nil.
Worked example 2: perpetual succession in action
All five directors of a made-up company, Himgiri Foods Ltd, retire, and two major shareholders die in the same year. Reasoning: the company is a separate legal entity, so it continues: new directors are elected and the shares pass to the heirs. Contrast a partnership, where the death of a partner can end the firm, and a sole proprietorship, which may close with the owner.
How the company differs from the forms studied so far
| Basis | Sole proprietorship | Partnership | Company |
|---|---|---|---|
| Legal identity | Not separate from owner | Not separate from partners | Separate legal entity |
| Liability of owners | Unlimited | Unlimited, joint and several | Limited to unpaid amount on shares |
| Continuity | Ends with owner's death or insolvency | May end with a partner's death, retirement or insolvency | Perpetual succession |
| Management | Owner | Partners by mutual consent | Board of Directors; ownership separate from management |
| Transfer of interest | With formalities | Not without consent of others | Shares of a public company freely transferable |
Reading across the table shows why the company suits large undertakings: it can collect capital from a very large number of investors because each investor's risk is capped, investors can leave by selling shares without disturbing the business, and the business outlives every individual. The price is paid in formalities, regulation and a loss of the personal touch that a proprietor or partner enjoys.
Key takeaways: a company is an artificial person with separate legal entity, perpetual succession and a common seal, governed by the Companies Act, 2013; members' liability is limited to the unpaid amount on their shares; it offers capital, transferability, continuity and professional management, but is complex to form, heavily regulated, slow to decide and may become oligarchic.
Check your understanding
-
1. The feature by which a company continues even if all its members die is:
- limited liability
- common seal
- perpetual succession
- mutual agency
Show answer
Answer: C. Perpetual succession means members may come and go but the company continues until it is wound up by law.
-
2. Illustrative: Raj holds 800 shares of ₹10 each, ₹7 paid. His maximum further liability is:
- ₹2,400
- ₹5,600
- ₹8,000
- Nil
Show answer
Answer: A. Unpaid per share = 10 - 7 = ₹3. Liability = 800 × 3 = ₹2,400.
-
3. Why is a company called an artificial person?
- Its directors are not real people
- It is created by law and can own property, contract and sue, though it has no physical existence
- It has no members
- It does not pay taxes
Show answer
Answer: B. A company is a creation of law with legal rights like a natural person, but it cannot breathe, eat or talk.
-
4. Case: In a made-up company with lakhs of shareholders spread across the country, few attend meetings and the directors take decisions some shareholders dislike; those shareholders simply sell their shares. Which limitation is shown?
- Lack of secrecy
- Complexity in formation
- Impersonal work environment
- Oligarchic management
Show answer
Answer: D. When dispersed shareholders have little influence and directors effectively rule, the result is oligarchic management, rule by a few.
-
5. Which is NOT a merit of the company form?
- Scope for expansion
- Transfer of interest
- Secrecy of operations
- Professional management
Show answer
Answer: C. Lack of secrecy is a limitation: public companies must file a lot of information with the Registrar, which the public can see.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.