• Foundation
  • About 18 min
  • 5 practice questions

Private and public companies; choosing a form of business organisation

Distinguish private and public companies and the privileges of a private company, and choose a suitable form of organisation using cost, liability, continuity, management ability, capital, control and nature of business.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Distinguish a private company from a public company and list a private company's privileges.
  • Explain the factors that decide the choice of form of organisation.
  • Recommend a suitable form for a given business situation, with reasons.

A company can be private or public, and every entrepreneur must eventually decide which form, from sole proprietorship to public company, suits the business. This lesson brings the whole chapter together.

Private company

As the textbook describes it, a private company (a) restricts members' right to transfer shares; (b) has a minimum of 2 and a maximum of 200 members, excluding present and past employees; (c) does not invite the public to subscribe to its securities. It must use the words 'private limited' after its name; if it breaks these conditions it ceases to be a private company and loses its privileges.

  • Can be formed by only two members (seven are needed for a public company).
  • No prospectus is needed because the public is not invited.
  • Shares can be allotted without receiving minimum subscription; business can start on receiving the certificate of incorporation.
  • Needs only two directors against a minimum of three for a public company; the maximum for both is fifteen.
  • Need not keep an index of members.

Public company

A public company is one that is not a private company: it has a minimum of 7 members and no maximum, no restriction on transfer of securities, and may invite the public to subscribe. A private company that is a subsidiary of a public company is also treated as public.

Public and private companies (as given in the textbook)
BasisPublic companyPrivate company
MembersMinimum 7, no maximumMinimum 2, maximum 200
Minimum directorsThreeTwo
Index of membersCompulsoryNot compulsory
Transfer of sharesNo restrictionRestricted
Inviting the publicCan invite subscription to shares or debenturesCannot invite

Choosing a form of organisation

Factors in choosing a form

  • Cost and ease of setting up Sole proprietorship cheapest and easiest; company costliest
  • Liability Unlimited for sole proprietor and partners; limited in cooperative and company
  • Continuity Company, cooperative and HUF stable; sole proprietorship and partnership less so
  • Management ability Complex operations need professional management, so company
  • Capital Large scale suits a company; small and medium suit partnership or proprietorship
  • Degree of control Full personal control in proprietorship; separation of ownership and management in a company
  • Nature of business Personal contact: proprietorship; professional services: partnership; large manufacturing: company
Based on the textbook's summary table
FactorMost advantageousLeast advantageous
Availability of capitalCompanySole proprietorship
Cost of formationSole proprietorshipCompany
Ease of formationSole proprietorshipCompany
Transfer of ownershipCompany (except private company)Partnership
Managerial skillsCompanySole proprietorship
RegulationsSole proprietorshipCompany
FlexibilitySole proprietorshipCompany
ContinuityCompanySole proprietorship
LiabilityCompanySole proprietorship

These factors are inter-related: a form that suits a business on a small scale may not suit it when it grows. All relevant factors must be weighed together.

No form is best for every business. Match the form to the scale, capital need, risk, continuity, control and nature of the business, and review the choice as the business grows.

Worked example 1: private or public?

A made-up family-owned firm, Sahyadri Spices, has 45 shareholders, restricts transfer of its shares and wants to raise a large amount by inviting the public to buy shares. Reasoning: as a private company it cannot invite the public. To do so it must become a public company: it would then need at least 7 members (it has 45), at least three directors, an index of members, and no restriction on transfer of shares.

Worked example 2: recommend a form

Three made-up ventures: (a) Priya wants to open a neighbourhood stationery shop with her own savings and full control; (b) three qualified architects want to offer design services together; (c) a group plans a large steel plant needing huge capital and professional managers. Recommendation: (a) sole proprietorship: low cost, personal contact, full control; (b) partnership: professional services, pooled skill, shared risk; (c) public company: large capital from the public, limited liability, continuity and professional management.

Key takeaways: a private company restricts share transfer, has 2 to 200 members and cannot invite the public, and enjoys privileges such as two directors and no prospectus; a public company has at least 7 members and free transfer; the choice of form depends on cost, liability, continuity, management, capital, control and nature of business, weighed together.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. According to the textbook, the minimum number of members needed to form a public company is:

    1. 2
    2. 7
    3. 10
    4. 50
    Show answer

    Answer: B. A public company needs a minimum of 7 members and has no maximum; a private company needs 2.

  2. 2. Which is a privilege of a private company over a public company?

    1. It can invite the public to buy its shares
    2. It must keep an index of members
    3. It needs only two directors
    4. It has no limit on members
    Show answer

    Answer: C. A private company needs only two directors against a minimum of three for a public company.

  3. 3. Which form is most advantageous from the point of view of continuity?

    1. Company
    2. Sole proprietorship
    3. Partnership
    4. Partnership at will
    Show answer

    Answer: A. A company has perpetual succession, so its continuity is the most stable.

  4. 4. Case: Kavya (made-up) runs a three-branch accessories shop as a sole proprietor and plans branches across the country needing large capital and expert managers. Which form fits her plan best?

    1. Remain a sole proprietor
    2. Joint Hindu family business
    3. Cooperative society
    4. Company
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Nationwide expansion needs large capital, professional management and limited liability, which a company provides.

  5. 5. Assertion (A): Sole proprietorship is preferred when cost of formation is the main concern. Reason (R): It involves minimum legal formalities and least expenditure to set up.

    1. Both A and R are true and R explains A
    2. A is true but R is false
    3. A is false but R is true
    4. Both A and R are false
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Sole proprietorship is the most inexpensive and easiest form to set up, which is why it is preferred on the basis of initial cost.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery