• Foundation
  • About 16 min
  • 5 practice questions

Human capital, economic growth and human development

Explain how human capital raises growth, why the evidence is unclear and causation runs both ways, how Indian planning saw human resources, and how human capital differs from human development.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain the channels through which human capital contributes to economic growth.
  • Explain why the evidence is unclear, including measurement problems and two-way causality.
  • Distinguish human capital from human development.

Who contributes more to national income, an unskilled factory worker or a software professional? Economic growth means an increase in a country's real national income. Since an educated person's labour skill and income are higher, an educated person contributes more to growth. A healthy person who can supply labour without interruption for longer also adds more. This lesson looks at the link between human capital and growth, and then at a broader idea, human development.

How human capital raises growth

From human capital to growth

  1. Investment Education, health, training, migration, information.
  2. Higher productivity Each worker can produce more.
  3. Innovation Knowledge of science and society spurs new ideas.
  4. Absorbing technology Educated workers adapt to new technologies.
  5. Economic growth Real national income rises.

Human capital not only raises labour productivity; it also stimulates innovations and creates the ability to absorb new technologies. Education gives knowledge to understand social changes and scientific advances, which helps inventions and innovations.

Why the evidence is unclear

The textbook says empirical evidence that more human capital causes growth is rather nebulous (unclear), partly because of measurement problems. Years of schooling, teacher-pupil ratios and enrolment rates may not reflect the quality of education; health spending in money terms, life expectancy and mortality rates may not reflect people's true health status.

Using such indicators, comparisons of developing and developed countries show convergence in human capital but no convergence in per capita real income: human capital has grown faster in developing countries, but their per capita income has not grown as fast. There is also reason to believe that causality runs both ways: higher income leads to more human capital, and more human capital leads to higher income. India's own data show education, health and income indicators rising together, each probably reinforcing the others.

Select indicators that rose together in India (according to the textbook, Table 4.1)
Indicator19512018-22
Infant mortality rate (per 1,000 live births)14628
Crude death rate (per 1,000 population)25.16.0

The book's table also shows real per capita income, life expectancy and literacy rising over the same decades. The point is not any single number but that education, health and income indicators improved together.

Worked example 1: reading two indicators

Using the textbook's figures: the infant mortality rate fell from 146 to 28 per 1,000 live births. Fall = 146 − 28 = 118 per 1,000. Percentage fall = 118 ÷ 146 × 100 ≈ 80.8 per cent. The crude death rate fell from 25.1 to 6.0 per 1,000: a fall of 19.1, or 19.1 ÷ 25.1 × 100 ≈ 76.1 per cent. Over the same period real per capita income rose many times. The indicators moved together, but as the textbook warns, this alone does not prove which caused which.

Indian planning and human capital

India recognised the role of human capital long ago. The Seventh Five Year Plan gave human resource development a key role in development strategy, arguing that a large population, trained and educated on sound lines, can itself become an asset for faster growth and desired social change. The National Education Policy 2020, as summarised in the textbook, notes that rapid scientific and technological change, such as big data, machine learning and artificial intelligence, may let machines take over many unskilled jobs while raising demand for skilled, multidisciplinary workers, and that climate change, pollution and epidemics will need new skills too. The book presents this as a vision of growth based on knowledge.

Human capital versus human development

The two terms sound similar but differ clearly. Human capital treats education and health as means to increase labour productivity; in this view, investment in education and health is unproductive if it does not raise output. Human development treats education and health as integral to human well-being: only people who can read and write and lead a long, healthy life can make the other choices they value. Here human beings are ends in themselves, and welfare should be raised through education and health even if productivity does not rise. So every individual has a right to basic education and basic health care.

Human capital versus human development

  • Human capital
    • People as a means to an end
    • End = higher productivity
    • Education and health valued for output
    • Spending that does not raise output is unproductive
  • Human development
    • People as ends in themselves
    • Education and health part of well-being
    • Valued even without higher productivity
    • Basic education and health are rights

Human capital sees education and health as means to higher productivity; human development sees them as ends in themselves, part of a good life and a right of every person. Human development is therefore the broader idea.

Worked example 2: two ways of judging a programme

Illustrative case (made up): a literacy class for 60 elderly women costs ₹90,000; none of them will join the paid workforce. From a strict human capital view, the extra output is ₹0, so the return is zero and the spending looks unproductive. From a human development view, 60 women can now read medicine labels, letters and bank forms: their choices and dignity increase, so the programme is worthwhile in itself. Cost per learner = 90,000 ÷ 60 = ₹1,500. The same numbers lead to different judgements depending on the idea used.

Key takeaways: human capital raises growth by raising productivity, stimulating innovation and helping absorb new technology. Evidence of causation is nebulous because measures miss quality, human capital has converged across countries while income has not, and causality runs both ways. The Seventh Plan saw a trained population as an asset, and NEP 2020 points to a knowledge-based future. Human capital treats people as means to productivity; human development treats them as ends, with basic education and health as rights.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. According to the chapter, why is the evidence that human capital causes growth described as nebulous?

    1. Because there is no data at all
    2. Because of measurement problems, such as indicators not reflecting quality of education or true health status
    3. Because human capital has no effect on output
    4. Because only physical capital is measured
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Indicators like years of schooling, enrolment, health spending and mortality may not reflect quality of education or true health status, so the evidence is unclear.

  2. 2. What does the chapter mean by convergence in human capital but not in per capita income?

    1. Developing countries' human capital grew faster, but their per capita real income did not grow as fast
    2. Developed countries' incomes fell to developing countries' level
    3. Both human capital and income are now equal everywhere
    4. Human capital fell in developing countries
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The chapter says human capital growth in developing countries has been faster, but growth of per capita real income has not been that fast, so incomes have not converged.

  3. 3. Which view treats human beings as ends in themselves?

    1. Human capital
    2. Physical capital
    3. Human development
    4. Import substitution
    Show answer

    Answer: C. In the human development perspective human beings are ends in themselves, and education and health are valued even without higher productivity. Human capital treats them as means to productivity.

  4. 4. Assertion (A): Higher income can lead to more human capital. Reason (R): The chapter says causality between human capital and growth may run in either direction.

    1. A is false, but R is true
    2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
    3. A is true, but R is false
    4. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The chapter says causality flows both ways: higher income causes building of human capital, and human capital causes growth of income. R explains A.

  5. 5. Using the textbook's figures, the infant mortality rate fell from 146 to 28 per 1,000. By how many points did it fall?

    1. 118
    2. 174
    3. 28
    4. 146
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Fall = 146 − 28 = 118 per 1,000 live births, about an 81 per cent reduction.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery