- Foundation
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
On-the-job training, migration, information, and physical versus human capital
Explain on-the-job training, migration and information as sources of human capital, and compare physical and human capital by decision, tangibility, mobility, depreciation and benefits.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain why on-the-job training, migration and information count as sources of human capital.
- Use cost-benefit reasoning to judge whether training or migration is worthwhile.
- Compare physical and human capital on five points.
Education and health are not the only ways people become more productive. Firms train workers, people move to better jobs, and everyone needs information to make good choices. The common test, as the textbook explains, is that the return on the spending is greater than its cost.
On-the-job training
Firms spend on on-the-job training for their workers in two ways: training within the firm under a skilled worker's supervision, or sending workers for off-campus training. Since the firm bears the cost, it will insist that workers stay for a specific period after training, so it can recover the benefit of higher productivity. Such spending is a source of human capital because the return in higher labour productivity exceeds its cost.
Worked example 1: recovering training costs
Illustrative numbers (made up): a firm spends ₹36,000 training a machine operator. Training raises the operator's output by an amount worth ₹4,000 a month to the firm. Months needed to recover the cost = 36,000 ÷ 4,000 = 9 months. So the firm may ask the worker to agree to stay at least 9 months after training. If the worker stays two years, the firm gains 24 × 4,000 − 36,000 = ₹60,000 more than it spent.
Migration
People migrate for jobs with higher salaries. In India, unemployment is the reason for rural-urban migration. Technically qualified people such as engineers and doctors may migrate to other countries for higher salaries. Migration has costs: transport, higher cost of living in the new place, and psychic costs of living in a strange socio-cultural setting. Because the enhanced earnings outweigh these costs, spending on migration is a source of human capital formation.
Worked example 2: is migration worthwhile?
Illustrative numbers (made up): Meena, a made-up nurse, earns ₹18,000 a month in her town. A city hospital offers ₹30,000. Moving costs ₹12,000 once, and her living costs rise by ₹7,000 a month. Monthly net gain = (30,000 − 18,000) − 7,000 = ₹5,000. In the first year: 12 × 5,000 − 12,000 = ₹48,000 net gain. The money gain outweighs the money costs; she must also weigh the psychic cost of leaving family and familiar surroundings, which the textbook counts as a real cost too.
Information
People spend to get information about the labour market and about education and health: what different jobs pay, whether an institution teaches employable skills, and at what cost. This information is needed to make good decisions about investing in human capital and to use the human capital already acquired efficiently. So spending on information is also a source of human capital formation.
Physical capital and human capital compared
The concept of physical capital is the base for the idea of human capital. Both result from conscious investment decisions, but they differ in important ways.
| Basis | Physical capital | Human capital |
|---|---|---|
| Nature of decision | Mainly an economic and technical process; owner calculates expected returns | Partly a social process (parents, peers, educators) and partly the person's own decision |
| Tangibility and separability | Tangible; can be sold; separable from the owner (a bus owner need not be present) | Intangible; built into the body and mind; only its services are sold; inseparable (the driver must be present) |
| Mobility | Completely mobile between countries except for artificial trade restrictions | Not perfectly mobile; restricted by nationality and culture |
| How it can be built | Even through imports | Through conscious policy and spending by the state and individuals |
| Depreciation | Wears out with use; becomes obsolete with new technology | Depreciates with ageing, but reduced by continuous investment in education and health, which also helps cope with new technology |
| Benefits | Private benefit only, to those who pay for its products | Private and social benefits (external benefits) |
The last point matters most for policy. An educated person can take part effectively in democracy and contribute to social and economic progress; a healthy person who keeps up hygiene helps stop the spread of contagious diseases. These benefits to others are called external benefits.
Two kinds of capital
-
Physical capital
- Tangible and saleable
- Separable from owner
- Fully mobile across countries
- Only private benefit
-
Human capital
- Intangible; only services sold
- Inseparable from owner
- Mobility limited by nationality and culture
- Private and social benefits
Human capital benefits not only its owner but society as well (external benefits), while physical capital gives only private benefit.
Key takeaways: on-the-job training, migration and information are sources of human capital because their returns exceed their costs. Firms recover training costs by asking trained workers to stay for a period. Migration costs include transport, higher living costs and psychic costs, outweighed by higher earnings. Information guides investment in and use of human capital. Physical capital is tangible, separable, fully mobile and gives private benefit; human capital is intangible, inseparable, less mobile, can be renewed against depreciation by further investment, and gives both private and social benefits.
Check your understanding
-
1. Why do firms insist that workers stay for a specific period after on-the-job training?
- To punish the workers
- To recover the benefits of enhanced productivity from the training
- Because training is free
- Because the law requires lifetime employment
Show answer
Answer: B. Firms incur the cost of training, so they want workers to stay long enough for the firm to recover the benefit of their higher productivity.
-
2. Which of these is a psychic cost of migration?
- Bus fare to the city
- Higher rent in the city
- The strain of living in an unfamiliar socio-cultural setting
- Higher salary in the city
Show answer
Answer: C. The chapter lists transport costs, higher cost of living and psychic costs of living in a strange socio-cultural set-up. The strain of an unfamiliar setting is the psychic cost; a higher salary is a benefit.
-
3. Illustrative data (made up): training a worker costs a firm ₹30,000 and raises the worker's monthly output by ₹2,500. How many months does the firm need to recover the cost?
- 6 months
- 12 months
- 25 months
- 10 months
Show answer
Answer: B. Months to recover = 30,000 ÷ 2,500 = 12 months.
-
4. Assertion (A): Human capital is not perfectly mobile between countries. Reason (R): Movement of people across countries is restricted by nationality and culture.
- A is true, but R is false
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- A is false, but R is true
Show answer
Answer: C. Box 4.1 says physical capital is completely mobile except for trade restrictions, while human capital is not perfectly mobile because movement is restricted by nationality and culture. R explains A.
-
5. Which statement about benefits is correct, according to the chapter?
- Physical capital creates both private and social benefits
- Human capital creates only private benefits
- Human capital creates both private and social benefits, while physical capital creates only private benefit
- Neither creates any social benefit
Show answer
Answer: C. An educated person contributes to democracy and social progress, and a healthy person helps stop epidemics: external benefits. Physical capital benefits only those who pay for its products.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.