• Foundation
  • About 17 min
  • 5 practice questions

Human development, liberty indicators and appraisal of strategies

Compare human development indicators of India, China and Pakistan, explain why liberty indicators matter, appraise the three countries' reform experiences, and summarise the chapter's conclusions.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Compare the three countries on human development indicators using the textbook's data.
  • Explain what liberty indicators are and why the textbook says human development measures are incomplete without them.
  • Appraise why China reformed in 1978 and what explains the different outcomes, as the textbook frames them.

Growth figures tell only part of the story. This lesson compares how well people live in the three countries and how their strategies are assessed.

Human development indicators

Selected human development indicators (according to the textbook, Table 8.5, data for 2017-2023)
IndicatorIndiaChinaPakistan
Life expectancy at birth (years)72.078.067.6
Infant mortality rate (per 1,000 live births)25.54.851
Maternal mortality rate (per 1 lakh births)10323154
People using at least basic sanitation (per cent)789671
Prevalence of undernourishment (per cent)17319

The textbook concludes that China is moving ahead of India and Pakistan on many indicators: income per capita, share of population below the poverty line, mortality rates, sanitation, literacy, life expectancy and malnourishment. It notes that China and Pakistan are ahead of India in reducing the proportion of people below the poverty line and in sanitation, and that India and Pakistan have not been able to protect women from maternal mortality as China has. All three report improved drinking water sources for most of their people.

Worked example 1: reading a mortality gap

Using the textbook's maternal mortality figures per 1 lakh births: China 23, India 103, Pakistan 154. India's rate is 103 ÷ 23 ≈ 4.5 times China's; Pakistan's is 154 ÷ 23 ≈ 6.7 times. For an illustrative 10 lakh births (made up), deaths would be about 230 in China, 1,030 in India and 1,540 in Pakistan. The difference between India and China at this scale = 1,030 − 230 = 800 lives.

Liberty indicators

The textbook warns about relying on human development indicators with full conviction. They are extremely important but not sufficient. We also need liberty indicators. One, a measure of the extent of democratic participation in social and political decision-making, has been added but given no extra weight. Others, such as the extent of constitutional protection of citizens' rights, or of the independence of the judiciary and the rule of law, have not been introduced at all. Without these, given overriding importance, the textbook says a human development index may be considered incomplete and its usefulness limited.

Liberty indicators measure freedom: democratic participation in decision-making, constitutional protection of citizens' rights, and the independence of the judiciary and the rule of law. The textbook argues that a human development index without them is incomplete.

Appraising the strategies

Taking the start of reforms as the reference point: China 1978, Pakistan 1988, India 1991. China had no compulsion to reform from the World Bank and IMF, unlike India and Pakistan. Its new leadership was unhappy with the slow growth and lack of modernisation under Maoist rule, and felt the Maoist vision of decentralisation, self-sufficiency and shunning foreign technology, goods and capital had failed. According to the textbook, despite land reforms, collectivisation and the Great Leap Forward, per capita grain output in 1978 was the same as in the mid-1950s.

Why China's reforms produced rapid gains (as the textbook explains)

  • Pre-reform foundations
    • Infrastructure in education and health
    • Land reforms
    • Massive extension of basic rural health services
    • Commune system: more equitable food distribution
    • Decentralised planning and small enterprises
  • Method of reform
    • Each measure tried on a small scale first
    • Then extended on a massive scale
    • Costs of success or failure assessed under decentralised government
  • Results
    • Household plots brought prosperity to many poor people
    • Growth of rural industries
    • Strong support base for further reform

The book's recap stresses that China's human development gains are attributed not to the reform process but to the strategies China adopted in the pre-reform period. For Pakistan, scholars point to the reasons covered in the previous lesson: harvest-dependent agriculture, reliance on remittances and volatile farm exports, foreign debt and political instability, with a recent recovery noted.

Worked example 2: exports as a percentage of imports

The textbook asks students to calculate exports as a percentage of imports. Illustrative numbers (made up): a country exports goods worth ₹30,000 crore to a neighbour and imports ₹1,20,000 crore from it. Exports as a percentage of imports = 30,000 ÷ 1,20,000 × 100 = 25 per cent, a trade deficit of 1,20,000 − 30,000 = ₹90,000 crore. If ten years earlier exports were ₹10,000 crore and imports ₹20,000 crore, the ratio was 50 per cent, so imports have grown much faster than exports.

Conclusion of the chapter

The textbook's concluding assessment

  • India
    • Democratic institutions
    • Moderate performance
    • Majority still depend on agriculture
    • Many initiatives on infrastructure and living standards
  • China
    • Used the market system without losing political commitment
    • Raised growth and alleviated poverty
    • Kept collective land ownership; rural social security
    • Concerns about political freedom and human rights
  • Pakistan
    • Political instability
    • Over-dependence on remittances and foreign aid
    • Volatile agriculture
    • Recent positive and moderate growth

Till the late 1970s all three were at the same low level of development; the last decades have taken them to different levels. The textbook notes that while India and Pakistan have attempted to privatise public sector enterprises, China used the market mechanism to create additional social and economic opportunities, and public provision of social infrastructure even before the reforms brought positive results in its human development indicators.

Key takeaways: according to the textbook's data, China leads India and Pakistan on most human development indicators, including maternal and infant mortality, sanitation and undernourishment. The book argues human development indices are incomplete without liberty indicators such as democratic participation, constitutional rights and judicial independence. Reforms began in China in 1978 (on its own initiative), Pakistan in 1988 and India in 1991 (both under pressure from international agencies). China's gains rested on pre-reform investment in health, education and land reform and on gradual, tested reforms; its record raises concerns about political freedom. India has performed moderately with democratic institutions; Pakistan's slowdown is linked to instability, remittances, aid and volatile agriculture.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. According to the textbook's data, which country has the lowest maternal mortality rate among the three?

    1. China
    2. India
    3. Pakistan
    4. All three are equal
    Show answer

    Answer: A. According to the textbook, for one lakh births about 23 women die in China, compared with about 103 in India and 154 in Pakistan.

  2. 2. Which of these is an example of a liberty indicator mentioned in the chapter?

    1. Life expectancy at birth
    2. Infant mortality rate
    3. Extent of constitutional protection of the independence of the judiciary and the rule of law
    4. GDP per capita
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The chapter's liberty indicators include democratic participation in decision-making, constitutional protection of citizens' rights and of judicial independence and the rule of law. The others are standard human development or income indicators.

  3. 3. Illustrative data (made up): a country's exports to a neighbour are ₹45,000 crore and imports from it ₹1,50,000 crore. What are exports as a percentage of imports?

    1. 45 per cent
    2. 33 per cent
    3. 300 per cent
    4. 30 per cent
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Exports as a percentage of imports = 45,000 ÷ 1,50,000 × 100 = 30 per cent.

  4. 4. Assertion (A): China introduced structural reforms in 1978 without pressure from the World Bank or IMF. Reason (R): China's new leadership was dissatisfied with slow growth and lack of modernisation under Maoist rule.

    1. A is true, but R is false
    2. A is false, but R is true
    3. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
    4. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The chapter says China had no compulsion from the World Bank and IMF; its new leadership was unhappy with the slow pace of growth and lack of modernisation and felt the Maoist vision had failed. R explains why China chose to reform.

  5. 5. To what does the textbook's recap attribute China's improvements in human development indicators?

    1. Mainly to the reform process after 1978
    2. To the strategies China adopted in the pre-reform period
    3. To foreign aid
    4. To remittances from the Middle East
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The recap says China's human development improvements were attributed not to the reform process but to the strategies adopted in the pre-reform period, such as basic health services, education and land reforms.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery