- Foundation
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Pakistan's development path
Describe Pakistan's mixed economy path from import substitution and the green revolution to nationalisation, denationalisation and the 1988 reforms, and explain the reasons scholars give for its slowdown.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Trace the main phases of Pakistan's economic policy.
- Identify the similarities between Pakistan's and India's strategies.
- Explain the reasons scholars give for slow growth and the re-emergence of poverty in Pakistan.
Pakistan's policies show many similarities with India's. Like India, it follows a mixed economy model with public and private sectors co-existing.
Phases of policy
Pakistan's policy path (from the chapter)
- Late 1950s-1960s Regulated framework for import substitution-based industrialisation.
- Green revolution Mechanisation and public investment in infrastructure in select areas; more food grains.
- 1970s Nationalisation of capital goods industries.
- Late 1970s-1980s Denationalisation and encouragement of the private sector.
- 1988 Reforms initiated.
- Import substitution (late 1950s and 1960s): the policy combined tariff protection for manufacturing consumer goods with direct import controls on competing imports, much like India's.
- Green revolution: led to mechanisation and more public investment in infrastructure in select areas, raising food grain production and changing the agrarian structure dramatically.
- 1970s: nationalisation of capital goods industries.
- Late 1970s and 1980s: a shift towards denationalisation and encouraging the private sector. Pakistan received financial support from western nations and remittances from a growing number of emigrants to the Middle East, which stimulated growth; the government also gave incentives to the private sector, creating a climate for new investment.
- 1988: reforms were initiated.
Why growth slowed and poverty returned
The textbook reports that scholars argue the reform process in Pakistan led to a worsening of economic indicators: compared with the 1980s, the growth of GDP and its sectors had not improved. Scholars using Pakistan's official data indicate rising poverty: according to the textbook the share of poor was more than 40 per cent in the 1960s, fell to 25 per cent in the 1980s and started rising again in recent decades. The reasons scholars give:
Reasons scholars give for Pakistan's slowdown
-
Agriculture
- Growth based on good harvests, not on an institutionalised process of technical change
- Good harvest: economy did well; bad harvest: stagnation or decline
-
Foreign exchange
- Mostly from remittances by workers in the Middle East
- Exports of highly volatile agricultural products
-
Debt
- Growing dependence on foreign loans
- Increasing difficulty in repaying them
-
Politics
- Political instability over a long period
The contrast the textbook draws: a country that earns foreign exchange through sustainable exports of manufactured goods need not worry, but one relying on remittances and volatile farm exports is exposed. The book also notes that in recent years Pakistan's growth recovered and many macroeconomic indicators began to show stable and positive trends.
Worked example 1: harvest-dependent growth
Illustrative numbers (made up): agriculture is 30 per cent of an economy and the rest grows steadily at 4 per cent a year. In a good-harvest year farm output rises 6 per cent; in a bad year it falls 4 per cent. Overall growth in a good year = 0.30 × 6 + 0.70 × 4 = 1.8 + 2.8 = 4.6 per cent. In a bad year = 0.30 × (−4) + 0.70 × 4 = −1.2 + 2.8 = 1.6 per cent. The swing of 3 percentage points comes entirely from the weather. Growth built on technical change in agriculture would be steadier.
Worked example 2: a fragile source of foreign exchange
Illustrative numbers (made up): a country earns $20 billion of foreign exchange a year: $9 billion from workers' remittances, $6 billion from farm exports and $5 billion from manufactured exports. It must repay $4 billion of foreign loans. If a fall in jobs abroad cuts remittances by a third and a poor harvest cuts farm exports by half, earnings fall by 3 + 3 = $6 billion, to $14 billion. Earnings from manufactured exports are 5 ÷ 20 × 100 = 25 per cent of the total, too small to cushion the shock. This shows why the textbook contrasts volatile sources with sustainable manufactured exports.
Scholars cite political instability, over-dependence on remittances and foreign aid, and volatile agricultural performance as the reasons for the slowdown of Pakistan's economy.
Key takeaways: Pakistan, like India, follows a mixed economy. It used regulated import substitution in the late 1950s and 1960s, gained from the green revolution, nationalised capital goods industries in the 1970s, turned to denationalisation and the private sector in the late 1970s and 1980s (helped by western financial support and Middle East remittances), and began reforms in 1988. Scholars say growth slowed and poverty re-emerged because farm growth depended on good harvests rather than technical change, foreign exchange came from remittances and volatile farm exports, foreign debt grew, and politics was unstable; the book notes a recent recovery.
Check your understanding
-
1. What happened to capital goods industries in Pakistan in the 1970s?
- They were nationalised
- They were sold to China
- They were closed down
- They were reserved for small-scale firms
Show answer
Answer: A. The chapter says that in the 1970s nationalisation of capital goods industries took place in Pakistan; denationalisation followed in the late 1970s and 1980s.
-
2. In which year were reforms initiated in Pakistan?
- 1978
- 1991
- 1988
- 1956
Show answer
Answer: C. Reforms were introduced in China in 1978, Pakistan in 1988 and India in 1991. 1956 is when Pakistan announced its first five year plan.
-
3. Illustrative data (made up): agriculture is 25 per cent of an economy and the rest grows at 5 per cent. In a drought year farm output falls 8 per cent. What is overall growth?
- 3.75 per cent
- 1.75 per cent
- −3 per cent
- 5 per cent
Show answer
Answer: B. Growth = 0.25 × (−8) + 0.75 × 5 = −2 + 3.75 = 1.75 per cent.
-
4. Assertion (A): Pakistan's agricultural growth was volatile. Reason (R): According to scholars, it was based not on an institutionalised process of technical change but on good harvests.
- A is true, but R is false
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- A is false, but R is true
Show answer
Answer: B. The chapter says agricultural growth and food supply depended on good harvests rather than technical change: good harvests meant good times, bad ones stagnation. R explains A.
-
5. Which pair of factors helped stimulate Pakistan's growth in the late 1970s and 1980s, according to the chapter?
- One-child norm and communes
- Nationalisation of all banks and land ceilings
- Special economic zones and dual pricing
- Financial support from western nations and remittances from emigrants to the Middle East
Show answer
Answer: D. The chapter says Pakistan received financial support from western nations and remittances from emigrants to the Middle East, which helped stimulate growth, along with incentives to the private sector.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.