• Foundation
  • About 17 min
  • 5 practice questions

Themes, the writer's craft and an unseen passage on honesty

Explain the story's themes (honesty, longing, childhood, homeland), its narrative voice and humour, and practise comprehension on an original passage about honesty.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • State the main themes of the story with evidence.
  • Describe Saroyan's narrative voice, humour and use of repetition and irony.
  • Answer a textbook-style question on why the boys return the horse.
  • Read an unseen passage on a similar theme and answer questions on it.

Themes

Themes of the story

  • Honesty and family pride
    • Centuries of reputation
    • Trust is repaid with the horse's return
  • Childhood longing
    • Aram's dream of riding
    • The magic of a summer
  • Innocence and excuses
    • Aram's clever reasoning
    • Riding is not stealing unless you sell
  • Homeland and exile
    • Khosrove's grief
    • The old country remembered
  • Humans and animals
    • Mourad's 'understanding' with horses, dogs, birds

Conscience or fear?

A key question is whether the boys return the horse because they are conscience-stricken or afraid. Evidence for fear: John Byro nearly recognises the horse by its teeth, so discovery is close. Evidence for conscience: Mourad had already declared, before the meeting, that the horse must go back to its true owner; and Byro's trust in their family's honesty makes keeping the horse a betrayal. A strong answer weighs both and usually concludes that trust stirred their conscience: they could not live up to the family's name while deceiving a man who believed in it.

The writer's craft

FeatureHow it works
First-person, looking backThe adult Aram recalls being nine, so the tone is nostalgic and amused
Dialogue without quotation marksSpeech runs into narration, giving a quick, oral, storytelling feel
RepetitionMourad claims a 'way with' horses, dogs, farmers; Khosrove repeats his refrain
Humour and exaggerationEleven centuries of honesty; the largest moustache in the valley
IronyA family famous for honesty hides a stolen horse; the owner trusts the 'thieves'

Practice passage: The Five-Hundred-Rupee Note (written for this lesson)

Every evening Meera's grandfather sold peanuts from a small cart near the bus stand. One evening, after he had gone home with a fever, Meera, who was twelve, ran the cart alone. A hurried traveller bought a paper cone of peanuts and, without looking, handed her a five-hundred-rupee note instead of a fifty. The bus doors were already closing. For a moment Meera held the note and thought of the new school bag she wanted, and of how her grandfather always said that the day's takings were never enough. Nobody had seen. Then she remembered something else he said: that a seller's only real stock is the trust of people who buy from him. She left the cart with the tea-seller, ran beside the moving bus, and pushed the note through the window into the startled traveller's hand. When she came back, breathless, the tea-seller was laughing. 'Your grandfather would have done the same,' he said, 'but slower.' That night her grandfather did not praise her. He only asked her to sit with him while he counted the coins, and Meera understood that this was his way of saying she had grown up.

Worked example 1: a comprehension answer

Question: what tempted Meera to keep the money? Working: look for her thoughts while she held the note: the school bag she wanted, the family's small income, and that nobody had seen. Answer: She wanted a new school bag, her family earned little, and no one had seen the mistake.

Worked example 2: linking the passage to the story

Question: how is Meera's choice like the Garoghlanian boys'? Working: both are tempted (money; a beloved horse), both remember a family value (a seller's trust; the family's honesty), and both act to restore what belongs to someone else. A difference: Meera decides at once, while the boys keep the horse for weeks. Answer: Both choose honesty because of a value learnt from their family, though Meera acts immediately and the boys only after a struggle.

The horse goes back because a trusting man believed in the family's honesty, and the boys could not betray that belief.

Key takeaways: the story's themes are honesty and family pride, childhood longing, innocent self-justification, exile and the bond with animals. Saroyan uses a nostalgic first-person voice, dialogue without quotation marks, repetition, humour and irony.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which detail is the strongest evidence that the boys returned the horse out of conscience and not only fear?

    1. John Byro looked into the horse's mouth
    2. The dogs did not bark
    3. The horse was white
    4. Mourad had already said the horse must go back to its true owner before that meeting
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Mourad's declaration came before Byro nearly recognised the horse, so the decision was not driven only by fear of discovery.

  2. 2. What is unusual about the way Saroyan writes dialogue in this story?

    1. It is all in Armenian
    2. There is no dialogue
    3. It is written without quotation marks
    4. It is in rhyme
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Speech is set into the narration without quotation marks, which gives a quick, spoken storytelling feel.

  3. 3. In the passage written for this lesson, what did Meera remember that changed her mind?

    1. That the bus was late
    2. Her grandfather's saying that a seller's real stock is people's trust
    3. That peanuts were expensive
    4. That she was afraid of the tea-seller
    Show answer

    Answer: B. She recalled her grandfather's belief that a seller's only real stock is the trust of buyers.

  4. 4. How did Meera's grandfather show his approval?

    1. He asked her to sit with him while he counted the coins
    2. He gave her the five hundred rupees
    3. He scolded her for leaving the cart
    4. He bought her a school bag
    Show answer

    Answer: A. He did not praise her in words; he asked her to sit with him while he counted, which she understood as recognition that she had grown up.

  5. 5. Which is an example of irony in the white horse story?

    1. The horse is white
    2. Aram eats breakfast
    3. Mourad sings
    4. A family famous for honesty hides a stolen horse, and the owner trusts them because of that honesty
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The situation is the opposite of what we expect from honest people, and the trust shown to the 'thieves' deepens the irony.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery