- Foundation
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Distance, helplessness and hope: themes and devices
Discuss whether the poem's experience is personal or universal, show how the father's helplessness and the distance between father and son are expressed, and work out the poem's consistent rhyme scheme and its half-rhymes.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Argue whether the poem describes a purely personal or a universal experience.
- Show how the father's helplessness is brought out.
- Identify phrases and lines that show distance between father and son.
- Work out the rhyme scheme and notice full rhymes and half-rhymes.
The chapter's four questions focus on universality, helplessness, distance and rhyme. Each needs evidence from the poem, given in your own words or a word or two of quotation.
Personal or universal?
Although the poem may grow from the poet's own life, its experience is universal. In almost every family, parents watch children grow into adults with their own ideas, friends, tastes and plans. Parents may feel shut out and children may feel misunderstood. This is the generation gap. By never naming the father or son, giving no place or time, the poem lets any parent or child recognise themselves in it.
How helplessness is shown
- He opens by admitting he does not understand his own child.
- He confesses he knows nothing of him, despite years together.
- He can only try to rebuild the bond from the past, when the son was small.
- He doubts himself: perhaps he killed the seed he planted.
- He cannot understand his son's words, or even his own feelings, as grief turns into anger.
- He can offer only an empty hand.
Words that show distance
Signs of distance in the poem
-
Not knowing
- does not understand this child
- knows nothing of him
-
Strangers
- they speak like strangers
- no sign of understanding
-
Separate worlds
- what he loves I cannot share
- the land is his, none of mine
- he makes and moves his own world
-
Silence and emptiness
- silence surrounds them
- an empty hand
Themes
- The generation gap: parents and grown children drift apart.
- Love and possessiveness: the father's love wants the son to stay his, even to fail and return.
- Forgiveness: both sides long for something to forgive, a way to begin again.
- Communication: the problem is less lack of love than lack of understanding.
- Hope: the final gesture of two outstretched hands suggests reconciliation is possible.
Rhyme scheme
Each stanza has six lines. Look at the line-endings of stanza 2: where (A), mine (B), sign (B), air (A), design (B), share (A). The pattern is ABBABA, and the same pattern runs through all four stanzas, so the rhyme scheme is consistent. However, many rhymes are half-rhymes (slant rhymes), where the sounds are close but not identical: for example child, build and killed in stanza 1; have, move and love in stanza 3; live, grief and forgive in stanza 4.
| Stanza | Endings (A) | Endings (B) | Kind of rhyme |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | child, build, killed | now, know, how | Mostly half-rhyme and eye-rhyme |
| 2 | where, air, share | mine, sign, design | Full rhymes |
| 3 | have, move, love | to, knew, too | Half-rhymes for A; full rhymes for B |
| 4 | live, grief, forgive | land, understand, hand | Half-rhymes for A; full rhymes for B |
Why the half-rhymes? A sound that almost, but not quite, matches suits a relationship in which father and son almost, but not quite, connect.
Other devices
| Device | Example | Effect |
|---|---|---|
| Metaphor | The seed and the land | Shows parenting as planting and the son's life as his own ground |
| Simile | Speaking like strangers | Sharpens the sense of distance |
| Allusion | The prodigal son | Brings in the ideas of leaving, returning and forgiveness |
| Personification | Silence surrounds them | Makes silence a presence between them |
| Paradox | Grief turning into anger | Shows confused, painful feelings |
| Symbol | The empty hand | Reaching out with nothing yet to give: a wish to reconcile |
Universal theme, consistent ABBABA scheme, half-rhymes for a relationship that almost connects.
Key takeaways: the poem shows a universal generation gap through a father's helpless honesty. Distance is expressed through strangers, silence and separate worlds. The ABBABA rhyme scheme is consistent, but half-rhymes echo the near-miss between father and son.
Check your understanding
-
1. Is the experience in the poem purely personal?
- No, the generation gap it describes is felt in many families everywhere.
- Yes, it could happen to only one family.
- Yes, because it names the people.
- No, because it is about animals.
Show answer
Answer: A. The poem names no one and describes a common experience: parents and grown children growing apart. That makes it universal.
-
2. What is the rhyme scheme of each stanza?
- AABBCC
- ABABAB
- ABCABC
- ABBABA
Show answer
Answer: D. In stanza 2, where/air/share are A and mine/sign/design are B, giving ABBABA; the same pattern runs through every stanza.
-
3. Which phrase best shows distance between father and son?
- Father and son
- They speak like strangers.
- The same house
- When he was small
Show answer
Answer: B. Speaking like strangers shows they no longer communicate as family; the other phrases name facts without showing distance.
-
4. Have, move and love are an example of ______.
- half-rhyme
- onomatopoeia
- full rhyme
- alliteration
Show answer
Answer: A. These words look and sound similar but not identical; they are half-rhymes (slant rhymes).
-
5. What does the closing image of both reaching out an empty hand suggest?
- They are fighting.
- They are asking for money.
- They wish to be reconciled, though neither yet has anything to give.
- They are waving goodbye.
Show answer
Answer: C. Both reach out, longing for something to forgive: a sign of a wish for reconciliation.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.