- Foundation
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Language: modals of wish and regret, and words of feeling
Use would rather, I wish and if only to express wishes and regrets as the father does, recognise allusion, and build a vocabulary of feeling: grief, longing, estrangement, reconciliation.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Use would rather and would have with the correct verb forms.
- Use I wish and if only for present wishes and past regrets.
- Explain what an allusion is, with the prodigal son as an example.
- Use words for feelings and relationships accurately.
In stanza 3 the father says what he would rather have happen. Expressing preferences, wishes and regrets accurately is an important grammar skill, and the poem is full of feelings that need precise words.
Would rather
| Pattern | Use | Our own example |
|---|---|---|
| would rather + base verb | Your own preference | I would rather walk than take the bus. |
| would rather + someone + past tense | Your preference about someone else's present or future action | I would rather you stayed at home tonight. |
| would rather + someone + had + past participle | Regret about someone else's past action | I would rather you had told me the truth. |
I wish and if only
| Pattern | Use | Our own example |
|---|---|---|
| I wish + past simple | Wish about the present | I wish I understood my brother better. |
| I wish + had + past participle | Regret about the past | I wish I had listened to him. |
| I wish + would | Wish for someone else to change | I wish he would talk to me. |
| If only + same patterns | A stronger wish or regret | If only we had spoken earlier! |
The father's thoughts are full of such wishes. We might put them in prose: I wish I understood my son. If only we did not speak like strangers. I would rather he came home than built a world without me.
Allusion
An allusion is a brief reference to a well-known story, person, event or text, which the reader is expected to recognise. The poem alludes to the parable of the Prodigal Son, from the Bible, in which a younger son takes his share of his father's wealth, wastes it far away, and returns home in shame, only to be welcomed with joy and forgiven. By using it, the poet adds the ideas of leaving, returning and forgiveness without explaining them. Indian readers may think of similar stories of homecoming and forgiveness in their own traditions.
Words of feeling and relationship
| Word | Meaning | Our own example |
|---|---|---|
| grief | deep sorrow, often at a loss | Her grief at her friend's leaving lasted for weeks. |
| longing | a strong wish for something | He felt a longing for his old village. |
| estrangement | the state of no longer being close to someone | Years of silence led to estrangement between the cousins. |
| reconciliation | becoming friendly again after a quarrel | The festival brought about a reconciliation between the brothers. |
| resentment | bitter feeling at being treated unfairly | Resentment grew when he was not consulted. |
| forgiveness | stopping feeling angry with someone for a wrong | Forgiveness made a fresh start possible. |
From estrangement to reconciliation
- Estrangement Silence and distance
- Grief Sorrow at the loss of closeness
- Longing Wishing things were different
- Forgiveness Letting go of anger
- Reconciliation Beginning again
Worked example 1: would rather
Complete: 'I would rather my son ______ (choose) his own path than follow mine unhappily.' Working: preference about someone else's present or future action takes the past tense. Answer: chose.
Worked example 2: past regret
The father did not spend time with his son when he was a teenager. Express his regret. Answer: I wish I had spent more time with him. / If only I had spent more time with him.
I wish + past = present wish; I wish + had + past participle = past regret; would rather + someone + past = preference about another person.
Key takeaways: use wish, if only and would rather with the correct tense to express wishes, regrets and preferences. An allusion enriches a poem by borrowing a known story. Precise words for feelings make your writing more mature.
Check your understanding
-
1. Choose the correct sentence.
- I would rather you came early tomorrow.
- I would rather you come early tomorrow.
- I would rather you will come early tomorrow.
- I would rather you coming early tomorrow.
Show answer
Answer: A. When would rather refers to another person's future action, the verb takes the past tense: you came.
-
2. Which sentence expresses regret about the past?
- I wish I knew the answer.
- I wish I had told him the truth.
- I wish he would call.
- I would rather walk.
Show answer
Answer: B. I wish + had + past participle (had told) expresses regret about something in the past.
-
3. What is an allusion?
- A brief reference to a well-known story, person or event
- A rhyme at the end of a line
- A word that imitates a sound
- A comparison using like or as
Show answer
Answer: A. An allusion briefly refers to something the reader is expected to know, such as the parable of the Prodigal Son.
-
4. Which word means 'becoming friendly again after a quarrel'?
- estrangement
- resentment
- reconciliation
- grief
Show answer
Answer: C. Reconciliation is the restoring of a friendly relationship; estrangement is the opposite.
-
5. 'If only we ______ more often.' Choose the form that shows a present wish.
- talk
- will talk
- talking
- talked
Show answer
Answer: D. For a present wish, if only (like I wish) is followed by the past simple: talked.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.